1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:08,153
Peace and blessings of Allah be upon you.
In the name of Allah,
the Most Merciful, the Compassionate.

2
00:00:08,153 --> 00:00:14,880
Welcome, honourable brothers, to this new
session of your programme, “Live Halaqa”.

3
00:00:14,880 --> 00:00:22,340
We continue this halaqa discussing
the topic of legal rulings (Hukm Shar'i).

4
00:00:22,340 --> 00:00:31,400
After defining the types of legal
ruling in the previous session,

5
00:00:31,400 --> 00:00:42,320
we now speak with you and invite
your interaction through questions
at the end or during the session.

6
00:00:42,320 --> 00:00:50,280
In this episode, we discuss
the levels of Shari'ah legal rulings.

7
00:00:50,280 --> 00:01:00,020
Shari'ah legal rulings do not all have the
same level of certainty or probability.

8
00:01:00,020 --> 00:01:13,060
The address of the Legislator has
come to us through definitive evidence
and through speculative evidence.

9
00:01:13,060 --> 00:01:21,540
A Shari'ah legal ruling may
therefore be definitive or probable.

10
00:01:21,540 --> 00:01:29,173
Both types—or both categories—of Shari’ah
legal rulings are binding upon us.

11
00:01:29,173 --> 00:01:40,129
The Muslim is accountable for adhering
to the Shari’ah’s rulings,
responsible for fulfilling every Shari’ah

12
00:01:40,129 --> 00:01:52,316
legal ruling relevant to their actions,
and responsible for carrying Islam in all
its details regarding these rulings,

13
00:01:52,316 --> 00:01:58,370
alongside matters of creed—whether
they are definite or probable.

14
00:01:58,370 --> 00:02:08,320
All of it constitutes religion;
all of it originates from Allah’s
legislation, exalted is He.

15
00:02:08,320 --> 00:02:17,720
What do we mean by a definitive Shari'ah
legal ruling, and what do we mean
by a probable Shari'ah legal ruling?

16
00:02:17,720 --> 00:02:26,488
A definitive Shari'ah legal ruling is
one indicated by definitive evidence.

17
00:02:26,488 --> 00:02:34,360
A probable Shari'ah legal ruling is one
whose evidence is not fully definitive.

18
00:02:34,360 --> 00:02:39,700
For a Shari’ah legal
ruling to be definite,

19
00:02:39,700 --> 00:02:46,919
it must derive from evidence
that is definitive in authenticity
and definitive in indication.

20
00:02:46,919 --> 00:02:54,355
What do we mean by definitive
in authenticity? And what do we
mean by definitive in indication?

21
00:02:54,355 --> 00:03:05,480
Conversely, what constitutes
speculative in indication, and what
does speculative in authenticity entail?

22
00:03:05,480 --> 00:03:17,820
Regarding authenticity, the legal
proofs are the Book and the Sunnah,
along with what they indicate.

23
00:03:17,820 --> 00:03:27,539
We know that the entire Book
of Allah—exalted is He—is
definitive in its authenticity;

24
00:03:27,539 --> 00:03:41,180
there is no doubt about any verse of the
Noble Qur’an, nor even about any word
within it being from Allah—exalted is He.

25
00:03:41,180 --> 00:03:47,226
The Qur’an was recited by the Prophet
may Allah bless him and grant him peace

26
00:03:47,226 --> 00:03:55,780
to a gathering of believers that reached
the threshold of mass transmission,
exceeding its minimum requirement.

27
00:03:55,780 --> 00:04:05,600
Since the time of the Prophet may Allah
bless him and grant him peace, it has
been preserved by a vast number of people,

28
00:04:05,600 --> 00:04:11,480
including Companions of the Messenger
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

29
00:04:11,480 --> 00:04:20,572
This Qur’an has passed down from the era
of the Prophet may Allah bless him
and grant him peace to our present

30
00:04:20,572 --> 00:04:29,640
day through mass transmission alone,
conveyed generation after generation
among Muslims throughout history.

31
00:04:31,100 --> 00:04:37,500
The Qur’an that Muslims have transmitted
since the time of the Messenger

32
00:04:37,500 --> 00:04:46,420
may Allah bless him and grant him
peace—preserved by mass transmission—was
also written during his lifetime.

33
00:04:46,420 --> 00:04:54,780
The documents recorded in his era
are those from which today’s
copies were transcribed,

34
00:04:54,780 --> 00:05:03,100
including the very copy we read now:
the Mushaf compiled by ‘Uthman
may Allah be pleased with him.

35
00:05:03,100 --> 00:05:10,500
Thus, the Qur’an was preserved in hearts
as it was preserved in writing.

36
00:05:10,500 --> 00:05:16,811
The mass transmission that has
characterised the entire text
of the Noble Qur’an from the time

37
00:05:16,811 --> 00:05:24,174
of the Prophet may Allah bless him
and grant him peace until this day
definitively establishes that the whole

38
00:05:24,174 --> 00:05:31,780
Qur’an is authentically conveyed
from the tongue of the Messenger of Allah
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

39
00:05:31,780 --> 00:05:40,170
And since there is definitive
evidence that Muhammad is
indeed the Messenger of Allah,

40
00:05:40,170 --> 00:05:43,973
then the Noble Qur’an becomes
definitively the Word of Allah.

41
00:05:43,973 --> 00:05:52,568
We are absolutely certain without
any doubt that every verse, word,
and letter in the Qur’an we possess—all

42
00:05:52,568 --> 00:06:03,680
of it—is the speech of Allah the Exalted,
just as it was revealed to the Messenger
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

43
00:06:03,680 --> 00:06:06,960
Thus, the entire Qur’an is
definitive in its authenticity.

44
00:06:06,960 --> 00:06:11,580
As for the Prophetic Sunnah, it has
two levels: the sound Prophetic Sunnah.

45
00:06:11,580 --> 00:06:19,780
In this discussion,
we have excluded everything transmitted
from the Messenger of Allah,

46
00:06:19,780 --> 00:06:25,233
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
that has not been established;

47
00:06:25,233 --> 00:06:33,660
everything more likely than not to be
unsound; and everything whose soundness
or lack thereof cannot be judged.

48
00:06:33,660 --> 00:06:43,028
We have excluded every report attributed
to the Messenger of Allah, may Allah
bless him and grant him peace, that we

49
00:06:43,028 --> 00:06:52,020
know with certainty is false, that is
more likely than not to be false, or whose
truth or falsity we cannot determine.

50
00:06:52,020 --> 00:06:58,120
These three categories lie
outside the process of legal
reasoning in Islamic Shari’ah.

51
00:06:58,120 --> 00:07:05,720
These are the two recognised levels
according to all Muslim scholars,
without exception.

52
00:07:05,720 --> 00:07:17,011
No consideration is given to the groups
or scattered individuals who claim that
the Sunnah is not a source of legislation

53
00:07:17,011 --> 00:07:27,408
and that revelation consists only
of the Qur'an; Allah willing, we may
later devote a session to answering them.

54
00:07:27,408 --> 00:07:30,828
The sound Prophetic
Sunnah has two divisions:

55
00:07:30,828 --> 00:07:38,924
one is definitive in authenticity,
which is what has reached us
through mass transmission;

56
00:07:38,924 --> 00:07:48,100
the other is speculative in authenticity,
which is what has reached us
through solitary transmission.

57
00:07:48,100 --> 00:07:52,620
A Hadeeth narrated from the
Messenger of Allah may Allah bless

58
00:07:52,620 --> 00:08:00,965
him and grant him peace by a group
whose collusion in lying is impossible,
then transmitted to us through successive

59
00:08:00,965 --> 00:08:09,480
stages of transmission by groups likewise
beyond suspicion of such collusion—this
constitutes mass transmission (tawatur).

60
00:08:09,480 --> 00:08:11,744
We are certain it is true;

61
00:08:11,744 --> 00:08:19,480
we are certain it originates
from the words of the Messenger of Allah
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

62
00:08:19,480 --> 00:08:23,480
The words of the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

63
00:08:23,480 --> 00:08:28,599
concerning legislation and religion
in general are revelation
from Allah Almighty. He says:

64
00:08:28,599 --> 00:08:30,449
﴿ وَمَا يَنطِقُ عَنِ ٱلْهَوَىٰٓ
إِنْ هُوَ إِلَّا وَحْىٌۭ يُوحَىٰ ﴾

65
00:08:30,449 --> 00:08:32,564
‘Nor does he speak from his own desire. It

66
00:08:32,564 --> 00:08:34,480
is only a revelation revealed’ [53:3–4]

67
00:08:34,480 --> 00:08:40,455
The distinction between the Book (the
Qur’an) and the Sunnah lies in this:

68
00:08:40,455 --> 00:08:47,480
the Book of Allah is divine
revelation from Almighty Allah
in both its wording and meaning.

69
00:08:47,480 --> 00:08:54,262
Its very words—let alone their meaning—are
a direct revelation from Him.

70
00:08:54,262 --> 00:09:02,607
As for the Sunnah,
its meanings were revealed to the Prophet
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

71
00:09:02,607 --> 00:09:08,480
but he conveyed them through his own
words, actions, or tacit approval.

72
00:09:08,480 --> 00:09:14,866
Of this Sunnah, what has been transmitted
to us through mass transmission
is definitive in authenticity

73
00:09:14,866 --> 00:09:21,840
(qati’ al-thubut), while what was conveyed
via solitary reports remains speculative
in authenticity (zanni al-thubut).

74
00:09:22,880 --> 00:09:27,376
When addressing Shari’ah legal
rulings—the legislative domain

75
00:09:27,376 --> 00:09:34,077
and practical matters—there
is no disagreement whatsoever
among Islamic scholars regarding

76
00:09:34,077 --> 00:09:41,880
the obligation to act upon a solitary
report from the Messenger of Allah may
Allah bless him and grant him peace.

77
00:09:41,880 --> 00:09:48,175
If a Hadeeth of the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant
him peace, comes through

78
00:09:48,175 --> 00:09:56,821
a sound chain from its highest link to its
lowest, and through a sound, uninterrupted
chain from its lowest link to its highest,

79
00:09:56,821 --> 00:10:04,880
and is free from anything that impairs
its authenticity, then it is affected
by no hidden defect and is not irregular.

80
00:10:04,880 --> 00:10:07,880
This Hadeeth must be acted upon.

81
00:10:07,880 --> 00:10:14,804
All Shari’ah legal rulings—every
category of ruling without
exception—are derived from it: whether

82
00:10:14,804 --> 00:10:23,075
they are hudood penalties, worships,
financial legislation, or marital
matters such as marriage and divorce.

83
00:10:23,075 --> 00:10:25,880
There is no exception at all.

84
00:10:25,880 --> 00:10:30,334
All Shari’ah legal rulings come
from authentic Prophetic Hadeeths,

85
00:10:30,334 --> 00:10:38,880
whether definitive in authenticity—the
mass-transmitted—or speculative
in authenticity—the solitary report.

86
00:10:38,880 --> 00:10:48,196
A definitive Shari'ah legal ruling
is one derived from evidence
that is definitive in authenticity.

87
00:10:48,196 --> 00:10:58,880
A further condition is required for the
ruling to be definitive: the evidence
must also be definitive in indication.

88
00:10:58,880 --> 00:11:01,553
In other words, the evidence

89
00:11:01,553 --> 00:11:11,880
indicating this Shari'ah legal ruling
must be definitive in indication as
well as definitive in authenticity.

90
00:11:11,880 --> 00:11:17,935
What do we mean by evidence that
is definitive in indication,

91
00:11:17,935 --> 00:11:24,232
and, conversely, by evidence that
is speculative in indication?

92
00:11:24,232 --> 00:11:34,880
Evidence that is definitive
in indication can bear only one
meaning for the Shari'ah legal ruling:

93
00:11:34,880 --> 00:11:42,880
it can indicate only one Shari'ah
legal ruling and only one
understanding of that ruling.

94
00:11:42,880 --> 00:11:48,174
If the text used as evidence
comes from the Book of Allah,
may He be exalted, or from the Sunnah

95
00:11:48,174 --> 00:11:54,809
of the Prophet may Allah bless him
and grant him peace, or from the consensus
of the Companions may Allah be pleased

96
00:11:54,809 --> 00:12:01,880
with them—and if it admits no meaning
other than one—then there is no room
for speculation in its interpretation.

97
00:12:01,880 --> 00:12:06,880
It is definitive in indication,
whether it is Qur’anic, Prophetic Sunnah,
or a matter of consensus.

98
00:12:06,880 --> 00:12:18,880
If the evidence can bear more than
one meaning, the mujtahids may
understand the text in different ways.

99
00:12:18,880 --> 00:12:28,880
The Shari'ah legal ruling is then
probable. To make the picture clearer:

100
00:12:28,880 --> 00:12:38,880
We provide examples of definite
Shari’ah rulings and probable
Shari’ah rulings among Muslims.

101
00:12:38,880 --> 00:12:45,880
There are many examples
of a definite Shari’ah ruling.

102
00:12:46,880 --> 00:12:55,121
There is absolute consensus—no
disagreement whatsoever—that prayer
is obligatory, fasting is obligatory,

103
00:12:55,121 --> 00:13:01,880
Hajj is obligatory for those who
can perform it, zakat is obligatory,
honouring parents is obligatory,

104
00:13:01,880 --> 00:13:11,880
theft is forbidden, fornication is
forbidden, usury is forbidden, and ruling
by what Allah has revealed is obligatory.

105
00:13:12,880 --> 00:13:21,817
These are some of the definite
Shari’ah legal rulings
that cannot be doubted in any way,

106
00:13:21,817 --> 00:13:30,880
nor can it ever be claimed
that there is room for ijtihad
or speculation regarding them.

107
00:13:31,880 --> 00:13:38,880
Anyone who denies that prayer
is obligatory, or doubts that it
is obligatory, is a disbeliever.

108
00:13:38,880 --> 00:13:42,312
The same applies to all the examples
I gave a moment ago, such as fasting,

109
00:13:42,312 --> 00:13:48,880
Hajj, zakat, the prohibition of usury,
the prohibition of fornication,
the prohibition of theft, and so on.

110
00:13:49,880 --> 00:13:57,526
Why? Because these legal
rulings are supported
by definitive-in-authenticity evidence.

111
00:13:57,526 --> 00:14:03,158
All of them have been
established in the Qur’an,
and every indication from the Noble

112
00:14:03,158 --> 00:14:10,880
Qur’an regarding these rulings is
definitive in meaning—admitting
neither doubt nor speculation.

113
00:14:12,880 --> 00:14:16,784
The texts that command prayer
are definitive in indication—they

114
00:14:16,784 --> 00:14:20,880
admit no speculation,
ambiguity, or dual meaning;
they convey only one clear meaning.

115
00:14:20,880 --> 00:14:24,880
The same applies to all
the examples I have provided.

116
00:14:25,880 --> 00:14:27,139
These legal rulings

117
00:14:27,139 --> 00:14:33,880
were not merely derived but extracted
from evidence that is definitive
both in authenticity and indication.

118
00:14:37,880 --> 00:14:42,301
The rest are probable
Shari’ah legal rulings.

119
00:14:42,301 --> 00:14:46,364
Let me first give an example of a definite

120
00:14:46,364 --> 00:14:57,880
Shari’ah ruling before addressing the
probable ones—this one comes not from the
Qur’an but from the Prophetic tradition.

121
00:14:57,880 --> 00:15:04,886
The obligation of prayer is explicitly
stated in the Qur’an, whereas

122
00:15:04,886 --> 00:15:15,880
there is no definitive evidence in the
Qur’an specifying the five daily prayers:
Fajr, Dhuhr, Asr, Maghrib and Isha.

123
00:15:16,880 --> 00:15:25,959
Likewise, the number of rak’ahs
for these prayers is not indicated by any
verse regarding how many rak’ahs Allah,

124
00:15:25,959 --> 00:15:33,980
may He be exalted, prescribed—these
are among Islam’s pillars:
that Fajr prayer consists of two rak’ahs,

125
00:15:33,980 --> 00:15:38,131
Dhuhr four, Asr four,
Maghrib three, and Isha four.

126
00:15:38,131 --> 00:15:41,918
The Qur’an contains no
verse pointing to this,

127
00:15:41,918 --> 00:15:50,204
but the Sunnah transmitted through
mass transmission (tawatur)
from the time of the Prophet may Allah

128
00:15:50,204 --> 00:16:00,480
bless him and grant him peace until today
clearly establishes these five prayers
along with their respective rak’ah counts.

129
00:16:00,480 --> 00:16:07,725
Whoever doubts the obligation
to perform these five prayers—not
merely the general duty of prayer,

130
00:16:07,725 --> 00:16:16,559
but specifically doubts the obligation
to observe them with their prescribed
number of rak’ahs—has departed from Islam.

131
00:16:16,559 --> 00:16:23,539
This is because they reject what
has been definitively transmitted
concerning the Messenger

132
00:16:23,539 --> 00:16:29,900
of Allah may Allah bless
him and grant him peace,
who was revealed to by Allah the Exalted.

133
00:16:29,900 --> 00:16:36,480
Thus, this category is clearly one where
the Shari’ah legal ruling is definitive.

134
00:16:36,480 --> 00:16:41,400
It is supported by evidence
that is definitive both
in authenticity and indication.

135
00:16:41,400 --> 00:16:47,899
In Shari’ah, there are probable legal
rulings for one of three reasons:

136
00:16:47,899 --> 00:16:58,731
either because they were deduced
or inferred from evidence—whether a single
piece of evidence that is definitive

137
00:16:58,731 --> 00:17:10,520
in authenticity but speculative
in indication, or definitive in indication
but speculative in authenticity,

138
00:17:10,520 --> 00:17:18,000
or from evidence that is speculative
both in authenticity and indication.
Examples include:

139
00:17:18,000 --> 00:17:21,964
The amputation of the hand
for theft is obligatory.

140
00:17:21,964 --> 00:17:26,429
The evidence—definitive

141
00:17:26,429 --> 00:17:37,400
in both authenticity
and indication—establishes that theft
requires cutting off the thief’s hand.

142
00:17:37,400 --> 00:17:41,280
As for the details, some
jurists differ upon them.

143
00:17:41,280 --> 00:17:51,032
Similarly, the definitive evidence—both
definitive in authenticity and definitive
in indication—indicates that it is

144
00:17:51,032 --> 00:17:56,200
obligatory to take jizyah from
dhimmis within an Islamic state.

145
00:17:56,200 --> 00:18:04,166
However, the jurists differed over
how this jizyah is to be collected,

146
00:18:04,166 --> 00:18:14,205
because one part of the verse commanding
the collection of jizyah is speculative
in indication. It is Allah's saying:

147
00:18:14,205 --> 00:18:15,379
﴿ وَهُمْ صَـٰغِرُونَ ﴾

148
00:18:15,379 --> 00:18:18,000
‘while they are humbled’ [9:29]

149
00:18:18,000 --> 00:18:25,480
One group of jurists said
that abasement must be made visible
upon those who pay the jizyah.

150
00:18:25,480 --> 00:18:35,840
Another group said that abasement here
means submission: by merely paying
the jizyah, they are submitting,

151
00:18:35,840 --> 00:18:42,400
so there is no need to display
humiliation when the jizyah is paid.

152
00:18:42,400 --> 00:18:50,960
Some said it must be called jizyah,
while others held that there was no
objection to calling it ‘double zakat’.

153
00:18:50,960 --> 00:18:56,560
This is what has been narrated about
our master Umar ibn al-Khattab,
may Allah be pleased with him,

154
00:18:56,560 --> 00:19:04,120
regarding his dealings with certain
tribes who requested that jizyah
be referred to as a doubled zakat.

155
00:19:04,120 --> 00:19:07,733
Here, the verse in which this
command appears—Allah's saying,

156
00:19:07,733 --> 00:19:08,838
﴿ وَهُمْ صَـٰغِرُونَ ﴾

157
00:19:08,838 --> 00:19:10,659
‘while they are humbled’ [9:29]

158
00:19:10,659 --> 00:19:14,190
—is definitive in authenticity.
However, the indication of

159
00:19:14,190 --> 00:19:15,294
﴿ وَهُمْ صَـٰغِرُونَ ﴾

160
00:19:15,294 --> 00:19:17,115
‘while they are humbled’ [9:29]

161
00:19:17,115 --> 00:19:18,191
is speculative.

162
00:19:18,191 --> 00:19:22,360
The evidence for this particular
matter was therefore speculative,

163
00:19:22,360 --> 00:19:29,200
so disagreement over this Shari'ah
legal ruling was permissible:
How is the jizyah to be paid?

164
00:19:29,200 --> 00:19:31,083
As another example, Allah says:

165
00:19:31,083 --> 00:19:32,137
﴿ وَٱلْمُطَلَّقَـٰتُ يَتَرَبَّصْنَ

166
00:19:32,137 --> 00:19:33,267
بِأَنفُسِهِنَّ ثَلَـٰثَةَ قُرُوٓءٍۢ ﴾

167
00:19:33,267 --> 00:19:35,828
‘Divorced women shall wait by themselves

168
00:19:35,828 --> 00:19:37,560
for three quru’ periods’ [2:228]

169
00:19:40,140 --> 00:19:49,300
The word quru' can have two meanings
in Arabic: it can mean menstruation,
or the period of purity from menstruation.

170
00:19:49,300 --> 00:19:55,342
The jurists therefore differed over
the waiting period of a divorced woman:

171
00:19:55,342 --> 00:20:00,300
is it three menstrual periods
or three periods of purity?

172
00:20:00,300 --> 00:20:04,451
This text is definitive
in its authenticity but
speculative in its indication;

173
00:20:04,451 --> 00:20:09,460
thus, jurists disagreed among themselves
regarding its precise meaning.

174
00:20:09,460 --> 00:20:14,782
Another example is a Shari'ah
legal ruling taken from Qur'anic

175
00:20:14,782 --> 00:20:21,460
evidence that is definitive
in authenticity but
speculative in indication.

176
00:20:21,460 --> 00:20:29,167
This concerns touching among the acts
that invalidate wudu. Allah says
concerning the acts that invalidate wudu:

177
00:20:29,167 --> 00:20:30,232
﴿ أَوْ لَـٰمَسْتُمُ ٱلنِّسَآءَ ﴾

178
00:20:30,232 --> 00:20:32,200
‘or you have touched women’ [4:43]

179
00:20:32,200 --> 00:20:41,560
One group of jurists said that “you
touched” means direct physical
contact—that is, skin touching skin.

180
00:20:41,560 --> 00:20:50,380
Another group said that touching
here is a figurative expression
for sexual intercourse.

181
00:20:50,380 --> 00:20:57,920
One group argued that the verse
indicates that touching invalidates wudu,

182
00:20:57,920 --> 00:21:04,140
while another held that it specifies
sexual intercourse as what breaks wudu.

183
00:21:04,140 --> 00:21:12,280
This legal ruling is a probable
Shari’ah ruling. That is:
does touching invalidate wudu or not?

184
00:21:12,280 --> 00:21:19,480
It is a probable Shari’ah ruling
because the evidence pointing
to it is speculative in indication.

185
00:21:19,480 --> 00:21:26,460
The verse cited by one group of jurists is
nevertheless definitive in authenticity,

186
00:21:26,460 --> 00:21:29,140
for it is the word of Allah
in His Almighty Book.

187
00:21:29,140 --> 00:21:33,350
This is an example of a probable
Shari’ah legal ruling derived

188
00:21:33,350 --> 00:21:40,862
from evidence definitive in authenticity
but speculative in indication,
making the ruling itself probable.

189
00:21:40,862 --> 00:21:48,580
Consequently, it was classified through
ijtihad as a matter of disagreement
among mujtahids and jurists,

190
00:21:48,580 --> 00:21:50,520
allowing differing opinions on it.

191
00:21:50,520 --> 00:21:57,260
A probable Shari'ah ruling may
be taken from evidence that is
definitive in indication,

192
00:21:57,260 --> 00:22:06,360
yet the ruling is probable because
the evidence itself is speculative
in authenticity: It is a report

193
00:22:06,360 --> 00:22:15,320
transmitted from the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
through solitary transmission.

194
00:22:15,320 --> 00:22:23,575
An example is the Shari'ah legal
ruling that forbids men to adorn
themselves with gold and wear silk.

195
00:22:23,575 --> 00:22:30,780
The Hadeeth of the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

196
00:22:30,780 --> 00:22:38,213
is definitive in authenticity
and definitive in indication;
it cannot bear two meanings.

197
00:22:38,213 --> 00:22:41,390
He said: «إِنَّ هَذَيْنِ حَرَامٌ عَلَى
ذُكُورِ أُمَّتِي، حِلٌّ لِإِنَاثِهِمْ»
— ‘These two are prohibited for

198
00:22:41,390 --> 00:22:46,466
the males of my Ummah and permitted
for its females’ [Musannaf

199
00:22:46,466 --> 00:22:51,137
Ibn Abi Shaybah 24060]. The
wording is clear, explicit and

200
00:22:51,137 --> 00:23:00,580
definitive in indication that gold and
silk are prohibited—both are prohibited
for men—and permitted for women.

201
00:23:00,580 --> 00:23:08,352
The evidence here is
definitive in indication but
speculative in authenticity,

202
00:23:08,352 --> 00:23:14,180
since the hadeeth was transmitted
through a solitary report.

203
00:23:14,180 --> 00:23:21,420
Therefore, this Shari’ah legal ruling
is probable rather than definite.

204
00:23:21,420 --> 00:23:27,727
It must be noted that even if the evidence
is speculative in authenticity,

205
00:23:27,727 --> 00:23:34,220
this does not always mean
disagreement over it is permissible.

206
00:23:34,220 --> 00:23:42,120
If the jurists agree
that a Hadeeth is authentic,
even on the basis of preponderant belief,

207
00:23:42,120 --> 00:23:46,320
they agree that acting
upon it is obligatory.

208
00:23:46,320 --> 00:23:57,540
Evidence being speculative in authenticity
is not a basis for abandoning the Shari'ah
legal ruling, releasing oneself from it,

209
00:23:57,540 --> 00:24:01,363
or saying that the ruling is not binding.

210
00:24:01,363 --> 00:24:09,320
A Shari'ah legal ruling may be probable,
yet still be the sole ruling
of Islam on the matter.

211
00:24:10,820 --> 00:24:15,596
It is correct that the report
indicating the prohibition of gold

212
00:24:15,596 --> 00:24:20,372
and silk for men relies on evidence
speculative in authenticity.

213
00:24:20,372 --> 00:24:29,039
However, since this hadeeth—and others
pointing to this legal ruling—are agreed
upon as sound by preponderant opinion,

214
00:24:29,039 --> 00:24:33,904
then this Shari’ah legal ruling is
an unchallenged ruling of Islam,

215
00:24:33,904 --> 00:24:42,660
and disagreement over it is impermissible
because there is no dispute about the
obligation to act on a solitary report.

216
00:24:42,660 --> 00:24:48,660
However, scholars have differed regarding
the authenticity of this Hadeeth:

217
00:24:48,660 --> 00:24:54,080
some maintain it is authentic,
while others consider it weak.

218
00:24:54,080 --> 00:25:01,440
In such a case, one who deems the Hadeeth
weak would be excused from acting upon
it—indeed, they must abandon it entirely.

219
00:25:01,440 --> 00:25:11,200
It is impermissible for them to act on a
Hadeeth where their preponderant opinion
holds that it is weak and unauthentic.

220
00:25:11,200 --> 00:25:16,560
Thus, if someone confirms its
authenticity, they may rely upon it;
but if they do not confirm it,

221
00:25:16,560 --> 00:25:19,800
they should refrain from acting upon it.

222
00:25:19,800 --> 00:25:24,440
If a Hadeeth is established—even
by preponderant opinion—it
is agreed to be authentic,

223
00:25:24,440 --> 00:25:29,694
even if not mass-transmitted,
and acting upon it becomes obligatory.

224
00:25:29,694 --> 00:25:36,005
Should its indication be definitive,
the legal ruling derived from it
is the legal ruling of Islam;

225
00:25:36,005 --> 00:25:40,835
but if it is speculative in indication,
then whoever opposes it commits sin.

226
00:25:40,835 --> 00:25:48,080
Therefore, here the speculative
nature of the ruling does not justify
abandoning or neglecting adherence to it.

227
00:25:49,920 --> 00:25:52,720
The ruling of Islam is not necessarily...

228
00:25:52,720 --> 00:25:56,483
When we say “the ruling of Islam”
and “an Islamic ruling”,

229
00:25:56,483 --> 00:26:01,080
there is the ruling of the Shari'ah
and there is a Shari'ah legal ruling.

230
00:26:01,080 --> 00:26:05,234
When we use the expression
“the ruling of the Shari'ah”,

231
00:26:05,234 --> 00:26:10,660
it means that the Shari'ah contains no
other ruling or ijtihad on the matter.

232
00:26:10,660 --> 00:26:18,080
The legal ruling of Islam regarding
gold and silver is that it is
prohibited for Muslim males.

233
00:26:18,080 --> 00:26:23,742
Although this ruling is
speculative rather than definitive,

234
00:26:23,742 --> 00:26:31,102
there is no competing
evidence or alternative proof
that challenges or undermines it.

235
00:26:31,102 --> 00:26:41,016
From this perspective, if there remains
no scope for ijtihad—meaning the evidence
pointing to this ruling is not open

236
00:26:41,016 --> 00:26:47,662
to reinterpretation—and if there is
no doubt regarding its authenticity,

237
00:26:47,662 --> 00:26:56,960
even if the Hadeeth in question is
considered authentic by preponderant
opinion, then Islam’s legal ruling stands.

238
00:26:56,960 --> 00:27:03,905
As for matters where there is room
for disagreement among jurists—whether
due to differences in the authenticity

239
00:27:03,905 --> 00:27:11,288
of a hadeeth, or because one hadeeth is
given precedence over another, or because
the indication of a hadeeth—or hadeeths—is

240
00:27:11,288 --> 00:27:18,086
speculative—then it can be said about
such cases: this Shari’ah legal ruling
has an opposing Shari’ah legal ruling.

241
00:27:18,086 --> 00:27:23,848
Thus, each mujtahid had their own
understanding: one mujtahid
understood one Shari’ah legal ruling,

242
00:27:23,848 --> 00:27:28,320
while another mujtahid understood
a different Shari’ah legal ruling.

243
00:27:28,320 --> 00:27:32,345
I give an example of this as
I mentioned earlier.

244
00:27:32,345 --> 00:27:38,641
When the Shafi’is state that if a man
touches a woman or a woman touches a man,

245
00:27:38,641 --> 00:27:42,770
it invalidates wudu’,
then this is a Shari’ah legal

246
00:27:42,770 --> 00:27:50,380
ruling—but it cannot be said to be
the ruling of Islam or of the Shari’ah,
because it is based on their ijtihad.

247
00:27:50,380 --> 00:27:56,600
It is Allah’s ruling for those who
undertook such inquiry.

248
00:27:56,600 --> 00:28:04,132
Others, such as the Hanafis, state that if
a man touches a woman or a woman touches
a man, this does not invalidate wudu’.

249
00:28:04,132 --> 00:28:09,420
This too is a Shari’ah legal ruling,
though it is not the sole
Shari’ah legal ruling.

250
00:28:09,420 --> 00:28:16,552
The ijtihad of the Shafi’is is Allah’s
ruling for them, and the ijtihad
of the Hanafis is Allah’s ruling for them.

251
00:28:16,552 --> 00:28:21,680
Thus, one is a Shari’ah legal ruling, and
the other is also a Shari’ah legal ruling.

252
00:28:21,680 --> 00:28:29,460
Even though the correct view is,
in principle, confined to one
opinion—to one ijtihad, not two.

253
00:28:29,460 --> 00:28:33,680
Allah willing, we will discuss
this further at a later time.

254
00:28:34,580 --> 00:28:41,720
The remaining example concerns a
probable Shari’ah legal ruling,

255
00:28:41,720 --> 00:28:54,075
as it is derived from evidence that is
both speculative in authenticity
and speculative in indication.

256
00:28:54,075 --> 00:29:04,320
Fasting six days of Shawwal is
such a ruling—it is recommended
by a broad spectrum of jurists,

257
00:29:04,320 --> 00:29:09,620
indeed representing
the preponderant opinion among them.

258
00:29:09,620 --> 00:29:13,598
However, this Shari'ah legal
ruling is probable because its

259
00:29:13,598 --> 00:29:18,560
evidence is speculative in authenticity
and speculative in indication.

260
00:29:18,560 --> 00:29:20,986
It is not speculative in indication.

261
00:29:20,986 --> 00:29:27,499
I apologise to the honourable brothers:
the Hadeeth is clear in its meaning;
the Hadeeth is definitive in indication.

262
00:29:27,499 --> 00:29:33,380
The Messenger of Allah may Allah bless him
and grant him peace said: ‘Whoever fasts
Ramadan with faith and seeking reward,

263
00:29:33,380 --> 00:29:37,164
then follows it with six days
from Shawwal, will be like one who

264
00:29:37,164 --> 00:29:39,536
fasted the entire year.’
[see Sahih Muslim 1164].

265
00:29:39,536 --> 00:29:48,086
This Shari'ah legal ruling was reported
in a Hadeeth that is speculative in
authenticity but definitive in indication.

266
00:29:48,086 --> 00:29:51,000
It is therefore a probable ruling.

267
00:29:51,000 --> 00:30:00,528
For this reason, it was reported that Imam
Malik did not accept this Hadeeth because,
among his sources of legislation,

268
00:30:00,528 --> 00:30:08,780
may Allah have mercy on him,
were the consensus of the people
of Madinah—or their established practice.

269
00:30:08,780 --> 00:30:14,328
The people of Madinah were those
who lived alongside the Prophet

270
00:30:14,328 --> 00:30:20,780
may Allah bless him and grant him
peace and his noble Companions.

271
00:30:20,780 --> 00:30:28,403
Imam Malik, may Allah have mercy on him,
stated: I never saw the people
of Madinah fast six days in Shawwal.

272
00:30:28,403 --> 00:30:33,540
This led him to doubt this Hadeeth,
which is a solitary report.

273
00:30:33,540 --> 00:30:44,836
To correct myself: the prohibition
on leasing agricultural land is a Shari'ah
legal ruling derived from evidence that is

274
00:30:44,836 --> 00:30:50,597
speculative in authenticity
and speculative in indication.

275
00:30:50,597 --> 00:30:58,955
The evidence reported
from the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

276
00:30:58,955 --> 00:31:09,440
concerning the leasing or renting
of agricultural land consists of solitary
reports, not mass-transmitted reports.

277
00:31:09,440 --> 00:31:19,740
Not all of these solitary reports have
been questioned; some of these Hadeeths
are agreed to be authentic.

278
00:31:19,740 --> 00:31:24,680
However, scholars differed over
the indication of these Hadeeths.

279
00:31:24,680 --> 00:31:30,623
One group of jurists held
that leasing agricultural land is not
permissible—leasing agricultural land is

280
00:31:30,623 --> 00:31:32,020
impermissible.

281
00:31:32,020 --> 00:31:36,360
Another group maintained that leasing
agricultural land is permissible.

282
00:31:36,360 --> 00:31:40,960
The Shafi’i school ruled that renting
agricultural land is permissible,

283
00:31:40,960 --> 00:31:46,040
whereas the Hanafi school
ruled that renting agricultural
land is impermissible.

284
00:31:46,040 --> 00:31:55,720
This discussion highlights...
it demonstrates the ranks
of Shari’ah legal rulings.

285
00:31:55,720 --> 00:32:07,760
There are definite Shari’ah legal rulings
derived from evidence that is definitive
both in authenticity and indication,

286
00:32:07,760 --> 00:32:16,768
while other Shari’ah legal
rulings are probable because they
originate from evidence that may be

287
00:32:16,768 --> 00:32:25,160
speculative either in authenticity or in
indication—or even speculative in both.

288
00:32:25,160 --> 00:32:29,820
This detailed classification
does not imply:

289
00:32:29,820 --> 00:32:38,380
whatever is definitive, we adhere to it;
and whatever is speculative,
we are free to disregard.

290
00:32:38,380 --> 00:32:41,780
No—absolutely not.

291
00:32:41,780 --> 00:32:45,180
Everything derived from legal evidence,

292
00:32:45,180 --> 00:32:54,580
whether through definitive
or speculative deduction,
constitutes Shari’ah legal rulings.

293
00:32:54,580 --> 00:32:59,879
However, the purpose
of this classification is
to remind us that Shari’ah

294
00:32:59,879 --> 00:33:08,799
legal rulings derived from evidence
that is definitive in authenticity and
indication are therefore definite rulings.

295
00:33:08,799 --> 00:33:11,360
Such rulings do not permit ijtihad.

296
00:33:11,360 --> 00:33:18,079
Whoever doubts these rulings—like
someone who doubts that prayer,
fasting and Hajj are obligatory;

297
00:33:18,079 --> 00:33:23,637
that usury and fornication are prohibited;
that the thief's hand must be cut off;
or that the fornicator

298
00:33:23,637 --> 00:33:30,248
must be flogged—and whoever doubts
or denies these definitive rulings has
disbelieved in the Law of Allah Almighty.

299
00:33:30,248 --> 00:33:32,586
They are called upon to repent.

300
00:33:32,586 --> 00:33:38,120
If they do not repent,
the prescribed punishment for apostasy
is carried out against them,

301
00:33:38,120 --> 00:33:41,980
because they have denied something
definitive in the religion.

302
00:33:41,980 --> 00:33:50,534
Regarding probable Shari’ah legal rulings
derived from speculative evidence—whether
speculative in indication or speculative

303
00:33:50,534 --> 00:33:57,284
in authenticity—disagreement is
permissible only where there exists
a genuine scholarly divergence.

304
00:33:57,284 --> 00:34:02,620
Where no disagreement
has been established,
such disagreement is impermissible.

305
00:34:02,620 --> 00:34:09,660
I gave an example of this: the prohibition
of gold and silver for males.

306
00:34:09,660 --> 00:34:14,065
Whoever denies this agreed-upon
Shari'ah legal ruling is sinful,

307
00:34:14,065 --> 00:34:19,879
even though it is based on evidence
that is speculative in authenticity.

308
00:34:19,879 --> 00:34:30,140
It cannot be said that a person has the
right to deny this ruling because it is
probable, for it is the ruling of Islam.

309
00:34:30,140 --> 00:34:39,140
As for a matter over which there
is disagreement, some may adopt one
opinion and others may adopt the other.

310
00:34:39,140 --> 00:34:44,840
Nor may this be used as
a means of releasing oneself
from the Shari'ah legal ruling.

311
00:34:44,840 --> 00:34:55,378
If jurists differ over detailed rulings
concerning prayer, for example—how
to pray, how to fast or how to perform

312
00:34:55,378 --> 00:35:05,080
Hajj—a Muslim must adopt one of these
ijtihads, because no action of a believer
may be without a Shari'ah legal ruling.

313
00:35:05,080 --> 00:35:09,442
It is not permissible for a
Muslim to argue that the Shari’ah

314
00:35:09,442 --> 00:35:16,831
legal ruling in this matter has
been disputed by scholars and say:
“I am absolved of all these opinions.”

315
00:35:16,831 --> 00:35:18,255
No, it is absolutely

316
00:35:18,255 --> 00:35:26,740
impermissible because no act of a Muslim
can be devoid of a Shari’ah legal
ruling legislated by Allah, the Exalted.

317
00:35:26,740 --> 00:35:33,765
If the ruling is probable, he must
adopt what gives him confidence through
the legitimate methods we will discuss,

318
00:35:33,765 --> 00:35:37,180
God willing, in subsequent sessions.

319
00:35:37,180 --> 00:35:39,620
He must rely on some opinion.

320
00:35:39,620 --> 00:35:47,960
If mujtahids have differed over
reciting Al-Fatihah behind the imam,
one may adopt this opinion or that.

321
00:35:47,960 --> 00:35:52,800
At times, it becomes impossible
to reconcile both views.

322
00:35:52,800 --> 00:36:02,875
For instance, the Shafi’is
hold that it is obligatory
for the follower to recite Al-Fatihah

323
00:36:02,875 --> 00:36:13,765
behind the imam—whether he reads aloud
or silently—and prayer is invalid without
doing so, even if recited behind him.

324
00:36:13,765 --> 00:36:22,500
This applies even when the imam recites
aloud in prayers such as Maghrib,
Isha’, Fajr and Jumu’ah.

325
00:36:22,500 --> 00:36:30,144
As for the Hanafis,
they cite evidence that it is
not permissible for the follower

326
00:36:30,144 --> 00:36:39,980
to recite Al-Fatihah behind the imam;
instead, he remains silent,
whether the imam reads aloud or silently.

327
00:36:39,980 --> 00:36:45,660
Thus, a Muslim must either adopt
this view or its alternative.

328
00:36:45,660 --> 00:36:51,800
Alternatively, one may adopt
a third opinion held by the Malikis,
may Allah have mercy on them.

329
00:36:51,800 --> 00:36:55,381
They say that when the imam recites aloud,

330
00:36:55,381 --> 00:37:02,860
the follower remains silent;
when the imam recites silently,
the follower recites Al-Fatihah.

331
00:37:02,860 --> 00:37:04,700
These are three opinions.

332
00:37:04,700 --> 00:37:09,340
Disagreement over an issue like this
cannot be an excuse for a Muslim to say,

333
00:37:09,340 --> 00:37:15,325
“I am not bound by any of these opinions
because they are all ijtihadi opinions.”

334
00:37:15,325 --> 00:37:21,007
Rather, you must adopt one of them,
and it becomes Allah's
ruling with respect to you.

335
00:37:21,007 --> 00:37:26,518
No action of a servant may be without a
Shari'ah legal ruling to which he adheres,

336
00:37:26,518 --> 00:37:33,980
because Allah Almighty will question
the Muslim on the Day of Resurrection
about every one of his actions.

337
00:37:33,980 --> 00:37:40,057
This, my honourable brothers,
is today’s detailed explanation
of the levels of Shari’ah legal rulings.

338
00:37:40,057 --> 00:37:46,300
May Allah, exalted be He,
grant that we have performed this well
and that it benefits us and you alike.

339
00:37:46,300 --> 00:37:47,891
O Allah, teach us what profits us,

340
00:37:47,891 --> 00:37:54,920
benefit us with what You have taught us,
and increase us in knowledge—You are
the Most Merciful of those who show mercy.

341
00:37:54,920 --> 00:37:59,260
My brother Jamil Hafiz asks:

342
00:37:59,260 --> 00:38:07,920
You will certainly have heard the reports
about the Saudi Crown Prince's call
to review the Prophetic Hadeeths.

343
00:38:07,920 --> 00:38:10,560
My question is: is this permissible?

344
00:38:10,560 --> 00:38:20,260
Do these well-known Prophetic Hadeeths,
documented in the books of Sunnah,
need to be reviewed?

345
00:38:25,620 --> 00:38:30,403
Regardless of who is calling
for this—and he is not trustworthy—yes,

346
00:38:30,403 --> 00:38:37,480
we have heard the report
that an academy for the noble
Hadeeth has been established.

347
00:38:37,480 --> 00:38:42,840
Leaving that event aside,
let us discuss the subject
of reviewing the Prophetic Hadeeths.

348
00:38:42,840 --> 00:38:53,229
The Hadeeths among us are sourced
from collections: beginning with Sahih
al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim, followed

349
00:38:53,229 --> 00:39:03,980
by Sunan Ibn Majah, Sunan al-Tirmidhi,
Sunan Abu Dawud, the Musnad of Imam Ahmad,
and the Musnad of al-Shafi’i.

350
00:39:03,980 --> 00:39:12,735
There are many sources for noble Hadeeths.
Not every Hadeeth in these sources
is automatically accepted.

351
00:39:12,735 --> 00:39:18,576
The people who collected and
recorded these Hadeeths did not

352
00:39:18,576 --> 00:39:24,760
themselves claim that they had
judged all of them to be authentic.

353
00:39:24,760 --> 00:39:29,980
After reliable scholars examined
al-Bukhari and Muslim, they said:

354
00:39:29,980 --> 00:39:35,213
We found that the conditions
set by al-Bukhari and Muslim
for their two Sahih collections,

355
00:39:35,213 --> 00:39:41,920
and their application of those conditions,
showed after investigation that all
these Hadeeths are authentic.

356
00:39:41,920 --> 00:39:50,121
Therefore, in the overwhelming majority
of cases, a Muslim accepts the Hadeeths
in these two Sahih collections

357
00:39:50,121 --> 00:39:54,940
without examining their chains
of transmission or their authenticity,

358
00:39:54,940 --> 00:40:01,060
because their authenticity
has already been established
through detailed examination.

359
00:40:01,060 --> 00:40:08,026
Apart from these two sources,
no collection of Hadeeth is accepted
on the basis that everything it contains

360
00:40:08,026 --> 00:40:14,960
is authentic, whether the reports are from
the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless
him and grant him peace, or from others.

361
00:40:14,960 --> 00:40:21,333
These sources include the Sunan works,
chains of transmission
and Musnad collections.

362
00:40:21,333 --> 00:40:24,542
They contain reports
from the Messenger of Allah,

363
00:40:24,542 --> 00:40:30,960
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
reports from the Companions,
and reports from the Followers.

364
00:40:30,960 --> 00:40:35,280
These reports are subject to scrutiny,

365
00:40:35,280 --> 00:40:44,940
examination, and verification—this
is what scholars and jurists
have done for hundreds of years.

366
00:40:44,940 --> 00:40:51,260
This depends on a vast discipline known
as the science of hadith terminology,

367
00:40:51,260 --> 00:40:57,395
which primarily relies on narrator
studies: who among them was just?

368
00:40:57,395 --> 00:41:02,640
Who was trustworthy and who
lacked trustworthiness?

369
00:41:02,640 --> 00:41:10,795
Who was both just and reliable,
and who was neither?
This work—has it reached its conclusion?

370
00:41:10,795 --> 00:41:20,760
Has it fulfilled its purpose and ended?
No. This matter remains open
until the Day of Resurrection.

371
00:41:20,760 --> 00:41:25,120
If someone judges a Hadeeth
to be authentic, his judgement
is not automatically accepted,

372
00:41:25,120 --> 00:41:26,700
for it is a human ijtihad.

373
00:41:26,700 --> 00:41:32,640
Likewise, if someone judges
a Hadeeth to be weak, his judgement
is not automatically accepted.

374
00:41:32,640 --> 00:41:39,680
Just as the door of ijtihad remains
open until the Day of Resurrection
and no one may close it,

375
00:41:39,680 --> 00:41:46,362
so too does ijtihad encompass examining
the authenticity of a hadeeth—whether
it is authentic or not.

376
00:41:46,362 --> 00:41:53,052
It cannot be claimed that those who
preceded us have exhausted
this subject through research,

377
00:41:53,052 --> 00:41:57,340
definitively determining what
is authentic and what is not.

378
00:41:57,340 --> 00:42:04,666
Indeed, there are certain narrations
that scholars have unanimously
excluded due to their agreed weakness.

379
00:42:04,666 --> 00:42:10,282
There is also a substantial
body of hadeeths they have
unanimously authenticated.

380
00:42:10,282 --> 00:42:13,620
However, there remains
an intermediate category:

381
00:42:13,620 --> 00:42:20,539
some reports from the Messenger
of Allah may Allah bless him and grant
him peace and his Companions—may

382
00:42:20,539 --> 00:42:28,240
Allah be pleased with them—that hadith
specialists and meticulous scholars differ
over in terms of their authenticity.

383
00:42:28,240 --> 00:42:32,260
This disagreement will endure
as long as Allah wills.

384
00:42:32,260 --> 00:42:33,651
Consequently, it cannot

385
00:42:33,651 --> 00:42:40,120
be said that this matter is closed
or that reviewing the authenticity
of these hadeeths is no longer acceptable.

386
00:42:40,120 --> 00:42:46,180
Honourable brothers, we will content
ourselves today, in this session,
with what has been discussed.

387
00:42:46,180 --> 00:42:53,120
We ask Allah Almighty to help us
complete this series and guide us
to what He loves and is pleased with.

388
00:42:53,120 --> 00:42:57,229
I invoke Allah's blessings and peace
upon the Messenger of Allah,

389
00:42:57,229 --> 00:43:04,566
upon his family and Companions,
and upon all who follow his guidance with
excellence until the Day of Judgement.

390
00:43:04,566 --> 00:43:07,720
Peace and Allah's mercy
and blessings be upon you.
