1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:02,519
In the name of Allah.
All praise is due to Allah.

2
00:00:02,519 --> 00:00:08,509
May peace and blessings be upon
the Messenger of Allah, his family,
his companions, and those who follow them.

3
00:00:08,509 --> 00:00:13,820
Welcome, my noble brothers, to a new
episode of your programme Live Session.

4
00:00:13,820 --> 00:00:24,693
In these sessions, which we began several
weeks ago, we entered a series centred on
how to follow the Shari’ah after finishing

5
00:00:24,693 --> 00:00:30,023
the topics concerning the path
of faith and related matters.

6
00:00:30,023 --> 00:00:36,660
We discussed the Hukm Shar’i,
the types of legal ruling
and the ranks of legal rulings.

7
00:00:36,660 --> 00:00:46,226
In the previous session,
we discussed those qualified to derive
Shari’ah legal rulings from the Book,

8
00:00:46,226 --> 00:00:51,340
the Sunnah and what they
indicate: the mujtahids.

9
00:00:51,340 --> 00:00:54,860
We explored the subject
of ijtihad in some detail.

10
00:00:54,860 --> 00:01:02,995
Today, we turn to a matter
concerning mujtahids: when is it

11
00:01:02,995 --> 00:01:17,360
permissible or obligatory for a mujtahid
to abandon his own opinion
in favour of another mujtahid’s?

12
00:01:17,360 --> 00:01:30,462
We previously spoke about the mujtahid
who derives a Shari’ah legal ruling after
exerting his utmost effort, exhausting

13
00:01:30,462 --> 00:01:43,960
his capacity in deriving the ruling and
seeking a probable or preponderant view of
the Shari’ah ruling on a particular issue.

14
00:01:43,960 --> 00:01:54,510
Naturally, when discussing ijtihad,
we are referring to probable Shari’ah
legal rulings that admit multiple

15
00:01:54,510 --> 00:02:05,060
interpretations—meaning there can
be more than one understanding
of the evidence upon which they are based.

16
00:02:05,060 --> 00:02:11,757
The definite Shari’ah legal
rulings derived from texts that do

17
00:02:11,757 --> 00:02:22,060
not permit ijtihad or admit more
than a single meaning leave no
room for ijtihad or disagreement.

18
00:02:22,160 --> 00:02:29,316
One cannot say, for example: Abu Hanifa’s
opinion is that prayer is obligatory,
while another scholar holds it is not.

19
00:02:29,316 --> 00:02:37,473
If someone doubts the obligation
of prayer or denies its obligation,
they are not a Muslim.

20
00:02:37,473 --> 00:02:45,220
The same applies to all definite
Shari’ah legal rulings—such as
the obligations of fasting, pilgrimage,

21
00:02:45,220 --> 00:02:53,423
alms-giving (zakat), and jihad; the
prohibition against judging by anything
other than what Allah has revealed;

22
00:02:53,423 --> 00:02:57,160
and the prohibitions on adultery,
theft, and usury.

23
00:02:57,160 --> 00:03:02,160
All these are Shari’ah legal rulings.

24
00:03:02,160 --> 00:03:12,160
There are many other definite rulings
as well that do not admit ijtihad
or disagreement among mujtahids.

25
00:03:12,160 --> 00:03:25,000
Ijtihad applies only to matters
derived from texts that admit
multiple meanings and interpretations.

26
00:03:25,000 --> 00:03:37,855
We have previously provided examples
in earlier sessions of Shari’ah
legal rulings subject to ijtihad,

27
00:03:37,855 --> 00:03:51,160
where mujtahids differed; we also
explained the causes of such differences
and why a ruling may be probable.

28
00:03:53,160 --> 00:04:03,160
We stated that whatever each mujtahid
derives through a valid Shari’ah
method is a Shari’ah legal ruling,

29
00:04:03,160 --> 00:04:08,200
even if one mujtahid differs
from another regarding that ruling.

30
00:04:08,200 --> 00:04:15,412
Thus, Abu Hanifa’s view
that reciting the Fatihah in prayer
is obligatory but not a pillar,

31
00:04:15,412 --> 00:04:23,200
and that the follower may not
recite the Fatihah behind the imam,
is a Shari’ah legal ruling.

32
00:04:23,200 --> 00:04:30,560
Al-Shafi‘i’s view that reciting
the Fatihah is a pillar without
which prayer is invalid,

33
00:04:30,560 --> 00:04:38,040
even behind an imam and even
if the imam recites aloud,
is also a Shari’ah legal ruling.

34
00:04:38,040 --> 00:04:47,380
Each is a Shari’ah legal ruling because
both were derived from Shari’ah evidence
through a valid Shari’ah method.

35
00:04:47,380 --> 00:04:53,741
However, we stated that Allah’s
legal ruling is singular;

36
00:04:53,741 --> 00:05:01,840
therefore, one of these two
rulings alone is correct
and accurately reflects the truth.

37
00:05:01,840 --> 00:05:12,680
Indeed, Allah, Exalted be He, legislated
only one of these two rulings for us.

38
00:05:12,680 --> 00:05:25,097
Yet since the texts carry probable
indications, one mujtahid arrived at
this probable indication while another

39
00:05:25,097 --> 00:05:32,598
reached a different probable
indication—both were permissible.

40
00:05:32,598 --> 00:05:42,140
Thus, each was a Shari’ah legal ruling,
and Allah’s correct ruling
is indeed one of them.

41
00:05:42,140 --> 00:05:53,340
Since no one can state with certainty that
his opinion is correct, the mujtahid’s
actual position and statement are:

42
00:05:53,340 --> 00:06:03,220
‘My opinion is correct, though it may be
wrong; the opinion of another is wrong,
though it may be correct.’

43
00:06:03,220 --> 00:06:05,393
Here, my dear brothers,

44
00:06:05,393 --> 00:06:15,534
we must note that whatever a mujtahid
derives through ijtihad is Allah’s
legal ruling concerning him.

45
00:06:15,534 --> 00:06:27,060
Allah’s legal ruling concerning
al-Shafi‘i is that reciting the Fatihah
is one of the pillars of prayer.

46
00:06:27,060 --> 00:06:33,039
Prayer is therefore invalid unless
the Fatihah is recited in every rak‘ah,

47
00:06:33,039 --> 00:06:38,834
even if a man is praying behind
an imam who recites it aloud.

48
00:06:38,834 --> 00:06:46,560
This is Allah’s legal ruling concerning
al-Shafi‘i and anyone who imitates him.

49
00:06:46,560 --> 00:06:54,160
Allah’s legal ruling regarding
Abu Hanifa is that the Fatihah
is obligatory but not a pillar,

50
00:06:54,160 --> 00:07:02,756
and it is impermissible for the follower
to recite it behind the imam—even
if the imam reads softly in prayer.

51
00:07:02,756 --> 00:07:09,860
Thus, Allah’s legal ruling
concerning every mujtahid is whatever
conclusion their ijtihad reaches.

52
00:07:09,860 --> 00:07:20,412
However, is it permissible
for the mujtahid—after his ijtihad
has led him to an opinion or legal

53
00:07:20,412 --> 00:07:32,760
ruling and he considers this to be Allah’s
ruling upon himself—to abandon his own
inquiry in favour of another person’s?

54
00:07:32,760 --> 00:07:35,820
This is our topic today.

55
00:07:35,820 --> 00:07:42,642
The principle is that a mujtahid
may not abandon his ijtihad
for the ijtihad of another.

56
00:07:42,642 --> 00:07:52,849
The issue here is not that Allah, exalted
be He, has legislated two opinions and it
is permissible for man to choose either;

57
00:07:52,849 --> 00:08:01,750
nor that He has chosen between two
rulings so that we are permitted to take
one or the other without any harm.

58
00:08:01,750 --> 00:08:08,698
Therefore, it does not follow
that a mujtahid may absolutely abandon
his own ijtihad in favour of another’s

59
00:08:08,698 --> 00:08:09,740
legal ruling.

60
00:08:09,740 --> 00:08:13,195
No, Allah’s legal ruling
on this matter is singular.

61
00:08:13,195 --> 00:08:19,177
This concerns an entirely different
subject from that of concession
and obligation.

62
00:08:19,177 --> 00:08:27,181
In matters of concession and obligation,
the evidence indicates that the believer
has a choice between them—Allah,

63
00:08:27,181 --> 00:08:31,900
exalted be He, legislated concession
as such and obligation as such.

64
00:08:31,900 --> 00:08:36,086
When mujtahids differ over a
Shari’ah legal ruling, one says,

65
00:08:36,086 --> 00:08:42,900
‘This is my ijtihad, and I consider it
correct,’ while another says, ‘That is
my ijtihad, and I consider it correct.’

66
00:08:42,900 --> 00:08:46,510
One of these two ijtihads must be correct.

67
00:08:46,510 --> 00:08:54,541
What a mujtahid reaches through
his ijtihad is therefore Allah’s ruling
concerning him and those who imitate him.

68
00:08:54,541 --> 00:08:59,240
We shall discuss imitation (taqlid)
in a later halaqa, Allah willing.

69
00:09:00,980 --> 00:09:02,201
Therefore, it

70
00:09:02,201 --> 00:09:10,637
is not permissible for the mujtahid
to abandon his own ijtihad in favour
of another’s; this is the principle.

71
00:09:10,637 --> 00:09:21,847
Yet we know that every rule
has an exception. What then is
the exception here? When does it apply?

72
00:09:21,847 --> 00:09:30,060
And what exempts a mujtahid
from the prohibition against leaving
his understanding for that of others?

73
00:09:30,060 --> 00:09:36,360
When may a mujtahid abandon his own
ijtihad in order to adopt that of another?

74
00:09:36,360 --> 00:09:41,060
We say—with Allah’s success:
there are four circumstances.

75
00:09:42,060 --> 00:09:49,993
We shall examine these four
circumstances and find that, perhaps
in one or two cases, the mujtahid must

76
00:09:49,993 --> 00:09:59,060
abandon his ijtihad for that of another;
while in the remaining two cases, he is
permitted—indeed, it is allowed—to do so.

77
00:09:59,140 --> 00:10:06,140
Moreover, with a different classification
of these four circumstances:

78
00:10:06,140 --> 00:10:15,849
in some cases, the mujtahid abandons
acting upon his own opinion while still
retaining the right to express it;

79
00:10:15,849 --> 00:10:22,140
whereas in others, he abandons both
speaking and acting upon his opinion.

80
00:10:22,140 --> 00:10:26,140
We shall now address each case one by one.

81
00:10:27,140 --> 00:10:36,140
What is the first circumstance in which
a mujtahid must abandon his own
opinion—his ijtihad—for that of another?

82
00:10:37,140 --> 00:10:46,000
If it becomes established for the mujtahid
who has exerted ijtihad in a particular
matter—or matters—that his evidence is

83
00:10:46,000 --> 00:10:52,140
weak, whereas another opinion
and its corresponding ijtihad
possess stronger evidence,

84
00:10:52,140 --> 00:10:57,140
then what is obligatory here is
to follow the stronger evidence.

85
00:10:58,140 --> 00:11:02,995
It is not correct to say that once
a mujtahid has performed ijtihad (diligent

86
00:11:02,995 --> 00:11:10,140
legal inquiry) and reached a probable
Shari’ah ruling, he must thereafter never
change his opinion or reconsider it.

87
00:11:10,140 --> 00:11:18,101
No—just as his initial ijtihad led him by
preponderant opinion to conclude that the
correct legal ruling was such-and-such,

88
00:11:18,101 --> 00:11:23,727
so too if later evidence
establishes for him by preponderant
opinion that his previous

89
00:11:23,727 --> 00:11:31,048
view was incorrect and another view—whose
supporting evidence is now stronger—is
more accurate or sounder, then it

90
00:11:31,048 --> 00:11:39,140
becomes obligatory upon him to abandon his
earlier position and adopt the one whose
evidence he has determined to be stronger.

91
00:11:41,140 --> 00:11:49,679
In this case, one may say
that the mujtahid does not abandon
his opinion for someone else’s;

92
00:11:49,679 --> 00:11:56,000
rather, he revises it—forming
a new view—and thus remains
bound by it in all circumstances.

93
00:11:56,000 --> 00:12:08,128
It is well known in the history
of Islamic jurisprudence that al-Shafi‘i,
may Allah have mercy on him,

94
00:12:08,128 --> 00:12:11,160
had two schools:
an old school and a new school.

95
00:12:11,160 --> 00:12:16,860
Why did al-Shafi‘i have an old
school and a new school?

96
00:12:17,520 --> 00:12:20,721
Al-Shafi‘i, may Allah have mercy on him,

97
00:12:20,721 --> 00:12:29,473
spent his life reconsidering
his opinions and ijtihads and always
seeking the stronger evidence.

98
00:12:29,473 --> 00:12:34,168
We know that Imam al-Shafi‘i,
may Allah have mercy on him,

99
00:12:34,168 --> 00:12:43,773
was raised in the school of hadith
in Madinah and studied under Imam Malik
ibn Anas, may Allah have mercy on him.

100
00:12:43,773 --> 00:12:54,125
He therefore belonged to the school of
hadith, whose most prominent scholar was
Imam Malik, may Allah have mercy on him,

101
00:12:54,125 --> 00:12:58,180
one of the founders of
the four famous schools.

102
00:12:58,180 --> 00:13:02,070
Imam al-Shafi‘i then broadened
his study and reflection.

103
00:13:02,070 --> 00:13:11,520
He moved to Iraq and encountered
the school known as the school
of reasoned opinion:

104
00:13:11,520 --> 00:13:17,206
the school of Abu Hanifa,
Sufyan al-Thawri and other Iraqi jurists.

105
00:13:17,206 --> 00:13:25,084
It was known as the school of reasoned
opinion, meaning the school of ijtihad.

106
00:13:25,084 --> 00:13:28,520
Malik’s school,
may Allah have mercy on him,

107
00:13:28,520 --> 00:13:38,520
and similar schools were known
as the school of transmitted
reports or the school of hadith.

108
00:13:38,520 --> 00:13:45,520
Al-Shafi‘i, may Allah have mercy on him,
studied both schools
and benefited from both.

109
00:13:45,520 --> 00:13:58,520
He developed his own method and no longer
followed either Imam Malik’s school
or the Iraqi school of reasoned opinion.

110
00:13:58,520 --> 00:14:08,130
It is well known that Imam al-Shafi‘i,
may Allah have mercy on him,
laid the foundations of his new school.

111
00:14:08,130 --> 00:14:14,727
He was the first to record
the discipline of usul al-fiqh
in his famous book al-Risalah.

112
00:14:14,727 --> 00:14:23,520
He also set out rules of usul al-fiqh
throughout other books, especially
his famous work of fiqh, al-Umm.

113
00:14:23,520 --> 00:14:32,520
It was widely recognised that upon
his arrival in Egypt, Imam al-Shafi‘i
developed a new legal approach. Why?

114
00:14:32,520 --> 00:14:41,144
Because he systematically reviewed
the evidence and gained access
to further knowledge—specifically,

115
00:14:41,144 --> 00:14:47,666
additional hadiths concerning the Prophet
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

116
00:14:47,666 --> 00:14:56,337
That period was one of intense
hadith collection; thus,
he encountered more Prophetic traditions,

117
00:14:56,337 --> 00:15:06,061
reassessed the principles of legal
derivation, and formalised his methodology
in al-Risalah, as mentioned earlier.

118
00:15:06,061 --> 00:15:13,520
Consequently, he constructed a novel
jurisprudence grounded in fresh study,

119
00:15:13,520 --> 00:15:18,520
deeper engagement with evidence,
and renewed analysis of those proofs.

120
00:15:18,520 --> 00:15:29,520
Let me pause here briefly to address
a misconception that has persisted among
scholars for some time, unfortunately.

121
00:15:31,520 --> 00:15:39,373
Many students and scholars cite
what happened to Imam al-Shafi‘i,
may Allah have mercy on him, as evidence

122
00:15:39,373 --> 00:15:48,520
that the environment influences a jurist:
he had one school before coming to Egypt
and a new school after arriving there.

123
00:15:48,520 --> 00:15:57,624
Such claimants—without evidence or
hesitation in their judgement—assert that
Imam al-Shafi‘i’s jurisprudence was shaped

124
00:15:57,624 --> 00:16:00,681
by the environment between Hijaz and Iraq.

125
00:16:00,681 --> 00:16:04,520
Then, after moving to Egypt, they argue,

126
00:16:04,520 --> 00:16:11,867
it was the people of Egypt or Egyptian
society itself that influenced
his thinking, producing a jurisprudence

127
00:16:11,867 --> 00:16:20,520
aligned with this new reality, this new
environment, and this new community in
which he lived during his time in Egypt.

128
00:16:20,520 --> 00:16:29,607
My dear brothers, this claim is unworthy
of fiqh and unworthy of Imam al-Shafi‘i,
the giant of fiqh and usul,

129
00:16:29,607 --> 00:16:32,520
may Allah have mercy on him.

130
00:16:32,520 --> 00:16:36,631
Great jurists—those
truly eminent scholars,

131
00:16:36,631 --> 00:16:48,520
the diligent mujtahids—they are not
people whose derivation of Shari’ah legal
rulings is swayed by contemporary reality.

132
00:16:48,520 --> 00:16:57,520
Reality is never a source for such
rulings; it must never influence
their extraction in any circumstance.

133
00:16:57,520 --> 00:17:04,942
The legal ruling, the Legislator’s address
regarding the deeds of servants—this
is the speech of Allah, exalted be He.

134
00:17:04,942 --> 00:17:10,567
Jurisprudence knows this fully,
and a mujtahid like al-Shafi‘i
understands completely:

135
00:17:10,567 --> 00:17:17,520
neither environment nor circumstance has
any right to influence the derivation
of Shari’ah legal rulings.

136
00:17:17,520 --> 00:17:19,572
Thus, reality itself—customs,

137
00:17:19,572 --> 00:17:26,665
traditions, or earlier legal
systems—has no authority to approach
or affect Islamic jurisprudence.

138
00:17:26,665 --> 00:17:30,682
For it is Islamic jurisprudence
that must mould reality,

139
00:17:30,682 --> 00:17:37,520
not the other way around;
it is the Shari’ah rulings that should
shape society, never be shaped by it.

140
00:17:37,520 --> 00:17:45,228
Correct; new issues may arise
in a changing reality that require
deriving Shari’ah legal rulings.

141
00:17:45,228 --> 00:17:50,208
However, such a ruling must be derived
from its legal evidences—the Qur’an,

142
00:17:50,208 --> 00:17:56,370
the Sunnah and what they indicate—so that
it can be applied to address this reality.

143
00:17:56,370 --> 00:18:00,298
The Shari’ah legal ruling
treats this reality;

144
00:18:00,298 --> 00:18:06,520
it does not allow reality
to influence the Shari’ah legal
ruling or the mujtahid’s ijtihad.

145
00:18:06,520 --> 00:18:11,121
This is not true under any circumstances.

146
00:18:11,121 --> 00:18:18,639
In contemporary terms, it happened—it
happened merely by coincidence—that
al-Shafi‘i’s new school emerged in Egypt.

147
00:18:18,639 --> 00:18:27,155
In Egypt he reconsidered matters,
just as he had continually reconsidered
his ijtihads before reaching Egypt.

148
00:18:27,155 --> 00:18:35,871
He changed his ijtihads according
to what became clear to him and according
to new evidence that reached him,

149
00:18:35,871 --> 00:18:43,013
including hadiths from Allah’s Messenger,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

150
00:18:43,013 --> 00:18:49,505
He also reconsidered how he had
used the evidence from which he
derived his earlier ijtihads.

151
00:18:49,505 --> 00:18:52,440
He therefore arrived at new ijtihads.

152
00:18:52,440 --> 00:18:57,805
These new ijtihads became Allah’s
legal ruling concerning al-Shafi‘i,

153
00:18:57,805 --> 00:19:02,287
may Allah have mercy on him,
and everyone who imitated him.

154
00:19:02,287 --> 00:19:08,303
No one may say, ‘I imitate al-Shafi‘i,
but I take his old school
rather than his new school.’

155
00:19:08,303 --> 00:19:12,417
As long as you trust al-Shafi‘i,
you take Shari’ah

156
00:19:12,417 --> 00:19:21,885
legal rulings from him as a mujtahid
because you yourself are not qualified for
ijtihad and have placed your trust in him.

157
00:19:21,885 --> 00:19:28,897
Allah’s legal ruling concerning him
is therefore Allah’s legal ruling
concerning you when you imitate him.

158
00:19:28,897 --> 00:19:38,288
This is not a matter of personal desire
or choosing between two opinions. The
issue is what is most probably correct.

159
00:19:38,288 --> 00:19:47,556
After reconsidering the matter,
al-Shafi‘i reached the preponderant
opinion that his new school was correct,

160
00:19:47,556 --> 00:19:51,520
so it became Allah’s legal
ruling concerning him.

161
00:19:53,360 --> 00:20:01,064
Therefore, the first case where
a mujtahid must abandon his opinion
for another is when it becomes

162
00:20:01,064 --> 00:20:10,447
clear to him that his view is weak because
its evidence is weak, and he realises that
the other ijtihad’s evidence is correct.

163
00:20:10,447 --> 00:20:15,520
He then changes his view and moves
from one opinion to another.

164
00:20:15,520 --> 00:20:23,647
As for the second case where
a mujtahid may abandon his own
opinion in favour of another,

165
00:20:23,647 --> 00:20:29,998
this occurs when he is convinced
that such-and-such a person
among the mujtahidin possesses

166
00:20:29,998 --> 00:20:38,313
stronger ijtihad than himself
and that he trusts that individual’s
ijtihad more than he trusts his own.

167
00:20:38,313 --> 00:20:42,325
This is naturally not a general
case nor one that is widespread.

168
00:20:42,325 --> 00:20:51,787
The principle is that the mujtahid must
trust in his own ijtihad; otherwise,
he would not engage in it at all.

169
00:20:51,787 --> 00:20:55,520
However, in specific circumstances,

170
00:20:55,520 --> 00:21:03,357
he feels deep within himself
and becomes convinced that such-and-such
an individual possesses stronger

171
00:21:03,357 --> 00:21:11,520
legal inquiry than him—and that he
trusts this other mujtahid’s
effort more than he trusts his own.

172
00:21:11,520 --> 00:21:18,520
In this situation,
it is permissible for him to abandon
his ijtihad in favour of the ijtihad

173
00:21:18,520 --> 00:21:27,520
of someone whom he trusts among
the mujtahidin and who appears stronger
than himself in terms of legal inquiry.

174
00:21:27,520 --> 00:21:29,770
What is the evidence for this?

175
00:21:29,770 --> 00:21:36,520
The evidence is a hadith narrated
by al-Sha‘bi, may Allah have mercy on him,
in which he said:

176
00:21:40,520 --> 00:21:48,620
Al-Sha‘bi reported: ‘Six Companions
of Allah’s Messenger, may Allah bless
him and grant him peace, used to issue

177
00:21:48,620 --> 00:21:56,139
legal rulings to people: Ibn Mas‘ud, Umar
ibn al-Khattab, Ali ibn Abi Talib, Zayd
ibn Thabit, Ubayy ibn Ka‘b and Abu Musa.’

178
00:21:56,139 --> 00:22:02,520
Abu Musa here means Abu Musa al-Ash‘ari.
May Allah be pleased with them all.

179
00:22:02,520 --> 00:22:07,520
Three of them would set aside their
opinions for the opinions of three others.

180
00:22:07,520 --> 00:22:13,520
Abdullah—that is,
Abdullah ibn Mas‘ud—would set aside
his opinion for Umar’s opinion.

181
00:22:13,520 --> 00:22:17,520
Abdullah ibn Mas‘ud would set
aside his view for Umar’s view,

182
00:22:17,520 --> 00:22:24,474
Abu Musa would set aside his view
for Ali’s view, and Zayd would set
aside his view for Ubayy ibn Ka‘b’s

183
00:22:24,474 --> 00:22:27,520
view. [see The Islamic
Personality, vol. 1, p. 161].

184
00:22:27,520 --> 00:22:35,520
These great Companions would
do this among themselves,
in full view of the other Companions.

185
00:22:35,520 --> 00:22:41,520
Had it been impermissible, the Companions
would have rebuked them for doing so.

186
00:22:41,520 --> 00:22:53,084
Since they were accepted in that practice,
this indicates that the Companions reached
a tacit consensus permitting a mujtahid

187
00:22:53,084 --> 00:22:59,520
to abandon his own ijtihad in favour
of another whose ijtihad he trusts.

188
00:22:59,520 --> 00:23:05,602
Therefore, there exists a case where
an individual may relinquish his own
ijtihad for that of another—provided he

189
00:23:05,602 --> 00:23:10,520
believes or trusts the other
mujtahid’s ijtihad more than
his own in that particular matter.

190
00:23:10,520 --> 00:23:18,711
In this scenario, we say:
abandoning one’s opinion and forsaking
one’s ijtihad for another’s

191
00:23:18,711 --> 00:23:29,982
is permissible—contrasting the first case,
where it becomes obligatory because
a stronger proof has been established.

192
00:23:29,982 --> 00:23:39,520
Here, however, it falls under
permissibility rather than obligation.
Thus, this constitutes the second case.

193
00:23:39,520 --> 00:23:50,279
The third case is when one seeks to unite
Muslims upon a particular opinion
for the sake of gathering them together.

194
00:23:50,279 --> 00:24:00,812
In such situations, holding firmly
to one’s own ijtihad may lead to division
among Muslims or prevent their unity.

195
00:24:00,812 --> 00:24:05,682
It becomes possible—and
indeed preferable—to avoid

196
00:24:05,682 --> 00:24:17,076
such discord at least by relinquishing
one’s personal view or legal inquiry
in favour of another mujtahid’s opinion.

197
00:24:17,076 --> 00:24:26,520
One thus abandons their own position
out of concern for uniting the Muslim
community upon a single stance.

198
00:24:26,520 --> 00:24:28,893
What is the evidence for this?

199
00:24:28,893 --> 00:24:36,900
The evidence is what Uthman ibn Affan,
may Allah be pleased with him,
did when he received the pledge

200
00:24:36,900 --> 00:24:45,699
of allegiance before the assembled
Companions and the people of Madinah,
and with the Companions’ approval.

201
00:24:45,699 --> 00:24:52,520
This constituted a tacit
consensus (ijma‘ sukuti) among
the Companions on the matter.

202
00:24:52,520 --> 00:24:54,862
The details are as follows.

203
00:24:54,862 --> 00:24:59,652
When the Commander of the Faithful,
Umar ibn al-Khattab,

204
00:24:59,652 --> 00:25:07,520
may Allah be pleased with him,
lay on his deathbed, the Companions
asked him to appoint a successor.

205
00:25:07,520 --> 00:25:16,471
He refused to do what Abu Bakr,
may Allah be pleased with him,
had done when, acting with authority

206
00:25:16,471 --> 00:25:25,520
delegated by the Companions,
he chose Umar ibn al-Khattab to be
the Caliph of the Muslims after his death.

207
00:25:25,520 --> 00:25:30,088
The Companions wanted to repeat
this with Umar ibn al-Khattab,

208
00:25:30,088 --> 00:25:37,640
may Allah be pleased with him,
after he had been stabbed and lay
dying a few days before his death.

209
00:25:37,640 --> 00:25:42,360
They said, ‘Choose for us, O Commander
of the Faithful. Appoint a successor.’

210
00:25:43,580 --> 00:25:48,853
Umar ibn al-Khattab, may Allah be pleased
with him, refused to choose one person.

211
00:25:48,853 --> 00:25:55,280
Instead, he restricted the nomination
to the six remaining men who
had been promised Paradise.

212
00:25:55,280 --> 00:26:02,660
Upon his death, five men gathered;
one of them—Talha—was absent on a journey.

213
00:26:06,660 --> 00:26:17,643
Abd al-Rahman ibn Awf, may Allah be
pleased with him, withdrew from candidacy
after securing the agreement of the other

214
00:26:17,643 --> 00:26:23,870
candidates to submit to his choice
and accept whoever he selected.

215
00:26:23,870 --> 00:26:34,060
He then removed himself from contention
entirely and took their pledge
that they would follow his decision.

216
00:26:35,400 --> 00:26:41,367
Abd al-Rahman ibn Awf consulted
first with the candidates,
then with the people of Madinah;

217
00:26:41,367 --> 00:26:50,000
all opinions converged between Ali
ibn Abi Talib and Uthman ibn Affan—may
Allah be pleased with both of them.

218
00:26:50,000 --> 00:26:59,040
After completing his efforts in
consultation, he gathered the Muslims—the
people of Madinah—in the mosque.

219
00:27:02,040 --> 00:27:07,920
He then called Ali ibn Abi Talib,
may Allah be pleased with him,
took his hand and said,

220
00:27:07,920 --> 00:27:14,920
‘O Ali, will you pledge to me that you
will act according to the Book of Allah,
the Sunnah of Allah’s Messenger,

221
00:27:14,920 --> 00:27:22,280
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
and the practice of the two Shaykhs—the
practice of Abu Bakr and Umar?’

222
00:27:24,280 --> 00:27:32,533
Ali ibn Abi Talib refused to bind
himself or commit to following
Abu Bakr’s and Umar’s actions,

223
00:27:32,533 --> 00:27:35,682
may Allah be pleased with them both.

224
00:27:35,682 --> 00:27:44,804
Instead, he said: ‘I will rule by the Book
of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger,
and exercise my ijtihad.’

225
00:27:44,804 --> 00:27:55,120
He exerted diligent legal inquiry in
matters where Abu Bakr and Umar had done
so—but I do not commit to their opinion.

226
00:27:56,000 --> 00:28:00,120
Abd al-Rahman then left Ali
and turned instead to Uthman.

227
00:28:01,000 --> 00:28:04,560
In this, Abd al-Rahman saw a means
of uniting the Muslims’ position.

228
00:28:05,560 --> 00:28:13,319
When Ali refused, Abd al-Rahman turned to
Uthman and asked him, ‘Will you pledge to
me that you will act according to the Book

229
00:28:13,319 --> 00:28:17,720
of Allah, the Sunnah of Allah’s Messenger
and the practice of the two Shaykhs?’

230
00:28:17,720 --> 00:28:23,200
He replied, ‘I pledge.’ Abd al-Rahman ibn
Awf then pledged allegiance to Uthman.

231
00:28:23,200 --> 00:28:26,640
The Companions gathered
and pledged allegiance to Uthman,

232
00:28:26,640 --> 00:28:33,104
and Ali, may Allah be pleased with him,
made his way through the rows
and also pledged allegiance to

233
00:28:33,104 --> 00:28:36,440
Uthman. [see The Islamic
Personality, vol. 1, pp. 170–171].

234
00:28:37,520 --> 00:28:41,865
This is evidence—from the
Companions’ consensus—that it is

235
00:28:41,865 --> 00:28:47,840
permissible for a mujtahid to relinquish
his own ijtihad in favour of another’s.

236
00:28:49,760 --> 00:28:54,560
The situation arose when
there was an effort to unite
the Muslims on a single position,

237
00:28:54,560 --> 00:29:00,760
particularly regarding the pledge
of allegiance for the caliphate
and uniting their ranks under one stance.

238
00:29:01,600 --> 00:29:05,840
Here, both Ali’s and Uthman’s
positions were approved.

239
00:29:05,840 --> 00:29:13,400
This means that a person may
adhere to his own ijtihad and not
set it aside for another’s,

240
00:29:13,400 --> 00:29:19,280
and that, in this situation, he may also
set aside his ijtihad for another’s.

241
00:29:19,280 --> 00:29:23,040
It was therefore permissible,
not obligatory.

242
00:29:24,320 --> 00:29:31,608
Therefore, the third case is this: it
is permissible for a mujtahid to abandon
his own opinion in favour of another’s

243
00:29:31,608 --> 00:29:35,640
ijtihad if the intention is to
unite Muslims upon a single view.

244
00:29:36,240 --> 00:29:40,880
What remains is one final issue—or rather,
what is that last case?

245
00:29:42,320 --> 00:29:46,828
When the Caliph of the
Muslims—the head of the Islamic

246
00:29:46,828 --> 00:29:52,880
state—adopts a particular ijtihad among
the various possible legal inquiries.

247
00:29:52,880 --> 00:29:59,326
We know that in matters where there
are no definite Shari’ah rulings,

248
00:29:59,326 --> 00:30:09,520
the Islamic state must rely upon one
such probable Shari’ah ruling and require
adherence to it from its subjects.

249
00:30:09,520 --> 00:30:19,200
This is necessary to ensure proper
relations among people within society and
to prevent conflicts arising between them.

250
00:30:20,560 --> 00:30:30,045
It is neither appropriate nor necessary
for the state—or the Caliph—to adopt
an ijtihad concerning how to pray,

251
00:30:30,045 --> 00:30:38,800
the rulings of fasting, the rulings
on converting something into fasting,
the rulings of Hajj, and so on.

252
00:30:40,160 --> 00:30:48,674
The Islamic State should not adopt
an ijtihad that compels people in matters
of worship generally, though there are

253
00:30:48,674 --> 00:30:56,480
exceptions—for these concern human
relations, the state’s governance system,
or the unity of Muslim speech.

254
00:30:56,480 --> 00:30:59,594
However, this does not
apply as a general rule.

255
00:30:59,594 --> 00:31:06,080
There are Shari’ah legal rulings where
the Islamic State has no need to adopt
any particular opinion through ijtihad.

256
00:31:06,320 --> 00:31:14,400
However, there are matters related
to human relations, the governance
system of the Islamic State,

257
00:31:14,400 --> 00:31:22,400
its economic system, foreign policy,
penal legal rulings, and family
social relationships—for example.

258
00:31:24,160 --> 00:31:28,000
During Abu Bakr’s time,
may Allah be pleased with him,

259
00:31:28,000 --> 00:31:35,040
he had ijtihads whose observance he
made binding on the state, the Muslims,
the citizens and the judges.

260
00:31:36,400 --> 00:31:40,160
For example, Abu Bakr,
may Allah be pleased with him,

261
00:31:40,160 --> 00:31:48,013
held that three pronouncements
of divorce in one sitting did not
count as three divorces but as one.

262
00:31:48,013 --> 00:31:56,160
If a man said to his wife in one sitting,
‘You are divorced, you are divorced,
you are divorced, you are divorced,’

263
00:31:56,160 --> 00:32:04,252
Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him,
held that these did not count as
three divorces but as one divorce.

264
00:32:04,252 --> 00:32:08,878
The man could therefore take his
wife back, return her to him,

265
00:32:08,878 --> 00:32:14,260
or marry her again after the waiting
period—after the waiting period.

266
00:32:14,260 --> 00:32:20,060
Umar ibn al-Khattab, may Allah be pleased
with him, had a different ijtihad.

267
00:32:20,060 --> 00:32:24,080
He held that three pronouncements of
divorce in one sitting counted as three.

268
00:32:24,080 --> 00:32:27,560
If a man said to his wife in one sitting,
‘You are divorced,

269
00:32:27,560 --> 00:32:35,800
you are divorced, you are divorced,
you are divorced,’ this constituted an
irrevocable divorce with major separation.

270
00:32:35,800 --> 00:32:43,040
He could not then take his wife
back or marry her again,
either before or after the waiting period,

271
00:32:43,040 --> 00:32:47,000
unless she married another man and that
man divorced her or died, and so on.

272
00:32:47,000 --> 00:32:53,341
Abu Bakr adhered to his ijtihad
and required the Muslims to adhere to it,

273
00:32:53,341 --> 00:32:58,500
so judges during his time ruled
according to that opinion.

274
00:32:58,500 --> 00:33:00,200
During Umar’s time,

275
00:33:00,200 --> 00:33:10,000
may Allah be pleased with him,
he adhered to his own ijtihad and required
the judges and the people to adhere to it.

276
00:33:11,440 --> 00:33:15,519
This is a matter where it
is permissible—and at times,

277
00:33:15,519 --> 00:33:24,340
even necessary for the sake of managing
public affairs—for the Caliph to adopt
one opinion that binds the people.

278
00:33:24,340 --> 00:33:28,808
The scholars have maxims on this:
‘The Imam’s opinion ends the dispute.’

279
00:33:28,808 --> 00:33:34,153
There is also another maxim:
‘The Imam’s opinion is binding
outwardly and inwardly.’

280
00:33:34,153 --> 00:33:41,174
And there is a maxim: ‘The Imam may
introduce among the rulings what he
introduces among judicial decisions’;

281
00:33:41,174 --> 00:33:46,200
‘he may introduce among judicial decisions
what he introduces among issues.’

282
00:33:46,200 --> 00:33:53,540
The state must necessarily adopt
legal rulings in many matters.

283
00:33:53,540 --> 00:33:58,378
For example, what does the state
say about agricultural land?

284
00:33:58,378 --> 00:34:03,700
The jurists differed on whether
leasing farmland is permissible:

285
00:34:03,700 --> 00:34:07,180
can a man lease his own cultivated
land to another for use?

286
00:34:07,180 --> 00:34:09,940
They disagreed.

287
00:34:09,940 --> 00:34:15,420
Some scholars—including
al-Shafi’i—ruled that leasing
agricultural land is permissible;

288
00:34:15,420 --> 00:34:19,568
it is lawful for its owner to lease it.

289
00:34:19,568 --> 00:34:26,720
Others, including the Hanafis, ruled
that leasing farmland is not permissible.

290
00:34:26,720 --> 00:34:31,760
These are two distinct Shari’ah legal
rulings, one of which must be correct.

291
00:34:31,760 --> 00:34:38,569
In all circumstances,
so long as the Islamic State
remains responsible for organising

292
00:34:38,569 --> 00:34:47,080
the affairs of its subjects and
maintaining sound relations among them,
it must adopt Shari’ah legal rulings.

293
00:34:47,080 --> 00:34:55,203
If the Islamic State—whose adopted
position is determined by its leader and
Caliph—adopts a ruling that agricultural

294
00:34:55,203 --> 00:35:03,160
land may not be leased, then it becomes
impermissible for people to lease such
land, even if their own opinion differs.

295
00:35:03,160 --> 00:35:09,655
In this case, if the Caliph
adopts an opinion—the Imam,
head of the Islamic State—and he

296
00:35:09,655 --> 00:35:19,162
accepts a particular ijtihad among them,
then everyone—including mujtahids—must
abandon acting upon their own opinions

297
00:35:19,162 --> 00:35:27,916
and instead follow what the Commander
of the Faithful has adopted, as well
as what the Islamic State has endorsed.

298
00:35:27,916 --> 00:35:31,305
Here, abandoning one’s
view is an obligation,

299
00:35:31,305 --> 00:35:37,800
not merely permissible; this falls under
the duty to obey the legitimate authority.

300
00:35:37,800 --> 00:35:39,642
﴿ يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ
ءَامَنُوٓا۟ أَطِيعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ

301
00:35:39,642 --> 00:35:41,554
وَأَطِيعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَ
وَأُو۟لِى ٱلْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ ﴾

302
00:35:41,554 --> 00:35:43,892
‘O you who believe,
obey Allah and obey the

303
00:35:43,892 --> 00:35:46,655
Messenger and those in
authority among you.’ [4:59]

304
00:35:46,655 --> 00:35:53,468
Thus, compliance with what the Caliph has
adopted falls under His, Exalted be He,
command to obey the one in authority,

305
00:35:53,468 --> 00:35:55,580
meaning the head of the Islamic State.

306
00:35:57,040 --> 00:36:03,895
However, it must be noted here
that the mujtahid’s abstention

307
00:36:03,895 --> 00:36:14,040
does not mean abandoning
his opinion or statement—rather,
he refrains from acting upon it.

308
00:36:16,040 --> 00:36:24,820
Let us suppose al-Shafi’i says—and
this is reality—that leasing
agricultural land is permissible;

309
00:36:24,820 --> 00:36:30,712
in my view and according to the ijtihad
of al-Shafi’i, such leasing is allowed.

310
00:36:30,712 --> 00:36:37,945
If the Caliph then adopts a ruling
that it may not be leased,
then if al-Shafi’i owns land,

311
00:36:37,945 --> 00:36:46,418
he may not lease it—because
adherence to the state’s adoption,
to the Caliph’s adoption, is obligatory.

312
00:36:46,418 --> 00:36:52,040
Practically speaking, he cannot
contravene what the state has adopted;

313
00:36:52,040 --> 00:37:01,040
yet this does not require him
to tell people that the correct
opinion is the Caliph’s view.

314
00:37:01,040 --> 00:37:07,394
Nor does it prevent him
from teaching in scholarly
gatherings or writing in his books

315
00:37:07,394 --> 00:37:15,040
and articles that the correct
opinion is that leasing
agricultural land is permissible.

316
00:37:16,040 --> 00:37:24,447
Abandoning ijtihad here means
abandoning its application,
not abandoning reasoned opinion or speech.

317
00:37:24,447 --> 00:37:34,040
He may always urge the state itself to
adopt his view and persuade it to abandon
its own, for he believes his is correct.

318
00:37:34,040 --> 00:37:39,513
He adheres to reasoned opinion in terms
of speech, teaching, and writing,

319
00:37:39,513 --> 00:37:43,465
but he commits himself to what
the state has adopted as practice.

320
00:37:43,465 --> 00:37:51,040
He calls upon people to commit themselves
in their deeds and transactions
to whatever the state has adopted.

321
00:37:51,040 --> 00:37:57,707
He may not say to people,
‘The Caliph’s opinion is wrong, and I
call on you to adhere to his opinion.’

322
00:37:57,707 --> 00:38:03,676
He says, ‘Yes, the opinion adopted by the
state is wrong and admits probability,

323
00:38:03,676 --> 00:38:07,404
but you must… wrong though
it may be right—excuse me.’

324
00:38:07,404 --> 00:38:12,767
He says, ‘The opinion adopted by the
Caliph is wrong though it may be right,

325
00:38:12,767 --> 00:38:20,040
but all of you—even if you imitate
me—must in practice adhere to what
the Islamic State has adopted.’

326
00:38:20,040 --> 00:38:28,040
Thus, these are the four cases where it is
permissible for a mujtahid to abandon his
own ijtihad and follow that of another.

327
00:38:28,040 --> 00:38:33,824
We ask Allah, the Exalted, to grant us
an Islamic state that resolves disputes,

328
00:38:33,824 --> 00:38:40,067
adopts Shari’ah legal rulings in matters
regulating human relations, and rescues

329
00:38:40,067 --> 00:38:49,340
us from submission to tyrannical rule and
man-made systems that have caused hardship
for people and led them into decline.

330
00:38:49,340 --> 00:38:55,314
We ask Allah, the Exalted and Most High,
to grant us this soon
and to assist us in upholding it.

331
00:38:55,314 --> 00:38:58,220
Verily, He is the All-Hearing,
the Responsive.

332
00:38:58,220 --> 00:39:03,175
I now turn to any questions that may
have arisen during this session.

333
00:39:03,175 --> 00:39:07,320
In the name of Allah,
the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.

334
00:39:07,320 --> 00:39:16,920
Brother Abu Ghazi Al-Zayn, peace and
blessings of Allah be upon you; and upon
you be peace and blessings of Allah.

335
00:39:16,920 --> 00:39:19,780
May Allah bless you and reward you well.

336
00:39:19,780 --> 00:39:25,260
Question: What is the legal ruling
for a Muslim regarding matters
in which scholars and mujtahids differ,

337
00:39:25,260 --> 00:39:30,840
such as the Shari’ah legal rulings
on smoking, growing a beard,
listening to music,

338
00:39:30,840 --> 00:39:34,840
and similar issues where there
is disagreement among mujtahids?

339
00:39:34,840 --> 00:39:37,520
May Allah bless you and reward you well.

340
00:39:37,520 --> 00:39:42,133
My dear brother, concerning
matters in which mujtahids have

341
00:39:42,133 --> 00:39:51,176
differed—beyond the examples mentioned
in this question—there are many other
issues that can serve as illustrations:

342
00:39:51,176 --> 00:39:57,250
a Muslim has the right to imitate any
mujtahid whose reasoning they trust.

343
00:39:57,250 --> 00:40:03,060
If one follows this opinion,
they have fulfilled their duty;
if another follows a different opinion,

344
00:40:03,060 --> 00:40:12,160
they too have fulfilled their duty—that
is, adopting the Shari’ah legal
ruling from among the mujtahids.

345
00:40:12,160 --> 00:40:18,304
In all cases, the topic
of imitation (taqlid) will be
addressed in our next session,

346
00:40:18,304 --> 00:40:22,640
where we shall elaborate upon
it with Allah’s permission.

347
00:40:22,640 --> 00:40:32,960
Hajj Hassan asks: Peace be upon you,
and Allah’s peace, mercy, and blessings be
upon you. May Allah reward you with good.

348
00:40:32,960 --> 00:40:36,485
My question: What is the legal
ruling on following and adopting

349
00:40:36,485 --> 00:40:40,960
the ijtihad of some Muslim scholars in
specific details of certain fiqh issues?

350
00:40:40,960 --> 00:40:44,676
It appears to be the same question:
certain fiqh issues such as prayer,

351
00:40:44,676 --> 00:40:49,630
fasting and Shari’ah-compliant clothing,
while this scholar… Ah, no,
the question is different.

352
00:40:49,630 --> 00:40:54,650
This scholar acts hypocritically
towards the rulers,
does not enjoin what is right or forbid

353
00:40:54,650 --> 00:41:00,712
what is wrong in political matters,
and sometimes even goes so far as to deny
the ruling concerning the Caliphate.

354
00:41:00,712 --> 00:41:03,320
May a Muslim adopt
his opinions on other matters?

355
00:41:03,320 --> 00:41:09,830
First, my dear brothers,
let us distinguish between
a mufti and a mujtahid.

356
00:41:09,830 --> 00:41:18,402
A mufti is not necessarily a mujtahid.
Every mujtahid is a mufti,
but not every mufti is a mujtahid.

357
00:41:18,402 --> 00:41:22,283
If a mufti lacks the ability
to perform ijtihad,

358
00:41:22,283 --> 00:41:33,049
he has no right to say—a mufti who is
not qualified for ijtihad has no right to
say—‘I have disagreed with every mujtahid,

359
00:41:33,049 --> 00:41:43,140
formed a new opinion and now give you
a new fatwa based on the developments
of the present age,’ or similar nonsense.

360
00:41:43,140 --> 00:41:48,170
Consequently, whether a mufti is
among the Sultan’s scholars or not,

361
00:41:48,170 --> 00:41:56,675
he may only issue legal rulings based
on definite Shari’ah rulings that he
has already established knowledge of,

362
00:41:56,675 --> 00:42:03,260
or upon the ijtihad of recognised
mujtahids who have been
attested as qualified for it.

363
00:42:03,260 --> 00:42:08,667
However, if he claims to exercise
ijtihad—and perhaps some claim

364
00:42:08,667 --> 00:42:18,154
that he possesses certain qualifications
for it—yet contradicts Shari’ah legal
rulings of the religion, such as

365
00:42:18,154 --> 00:42:26,000
when some muftis permitted interest-based
loans (as mentioned here), then
their fatwas are rejected against them.

366
00:42:26,000 --> 00:42:31,867
They will be held accountable
and punished by Allah, exalted is He,
with severe torment over this.

367
00:42:31,867 --> 00:42:33,511
﴿ فَوَيْلٌ لِّلَّذِينَ يَكْتُبُونَ
ٱلْكِتَـٰبَ بِأَيْدِيهِمْ

368
00:42:33,511 --> 00:42:35,155
ثُمَّ يَقُولُونَ هَـٰذَا مِنْ
عِندِ ٱللَّهِ لِيَشْتَرُوا۟

369
00:42:35,155 --> 00:42:36,553
بِهِۦ ثَمَنًا قَلِيلًا ۖ
فَوَيْلٌ لَّهُم مِّمَّا

370
00:42:36,553 --> 00:42:38,133
كَتَبَتْ أَيْدِيهِمْ وَوَيْلٌ
لَّهُم مِّمَّا يَكْسِبُونَ ﴾

371
00:42:38,133 --> 00:42:41,415
‘So woe to those who write the Book
with their own hands and then say,

372
00:42:41,415 --> 00:42:45,724
“This is from Allah,”
in order to gain a small price from it.
Woe to them for what their hands

373
00:42:45,724 --> 00:42:48,209
have written, and woe to them
for what they earn.’ [2:79]

374
00:42:48,209 --> 00:42:54,840
Whoever issues a legal ruling to rulers
regarding interest-based loans under
titles such as investment certificates,

375
00:42:54,840 --> 00:42:56,740
savings certificates,

376
00:42:56,740 --> 00:43:02,180
and the like—none of them are excused
for it, nor is anyone else excused
by imitating him in this matter.

377
00:43:02,180 --> 00:43:09,253
And if he is among the Sultan’s scholars,
then he cannot be trusted at all. Even if
one says, ‘What does that muqallid know?’

378
00:43:09,253 --> 00:43:16,252
it suffices to say to the muqallid:
you have adopted the opinion of a mufti
for the Sultan who rules contrary to what

379
00:43:16,252 --> 00:43:19,900
Allah has revealed—so you will
not be excused in this matter.

380
00:43:19,900 --> 00:43:24,392
This is the one who issued a
ruling permitting interest-based

381
00:43:24,392 --> 00:43:29,325
loans and a ruling permitting
reconciliation with a Jewish entity.

382
00:43:29,325 --> 00:43:36,100
He also ruled that assisting
non-Muslims in fighting Muslims
in Afghanistan and Iraq was permissible.

383
00:43:36,100 --> 00:43:43,473
He allowed women or girls to remove their
Islamic dress to enter European schools,

384
00:43:43,473 --> 00:43:51,082
and he issued rulings permitting
judgement by other than what Allah has
revealed under the pretext of gradually

385
00:43:51,082 --> 00:43:55,750
implementing Shari’ah laws and mixing
them with the laws of kufr.

386
00:43:55,750 --> 00:44:02,180
Neither those who issue such
fatwas nor anyone who follows
them can be excused in any way.

387
00:44:02,180 --> 00:44:06,272
Because these are not matters of
ijtihad, the definite evidence

388
00:44:06,272 --> 00:44:13,220
has established definitive Shari’ah
legal rulings that no one may ever
contravene under any circumstances.

389
00:44:13,220 --> 00:44:15,618
My dear brother, Wael Al-Sultan asks:

390
00:44:15,618 --> 00:44:23,555
Is it obligatory for a mujtahid to change
his earlier opinion to a new one in such
a way that this affects the muqallid?

391
00:44:23,555 --> 00:44:30,500
Or may the muqallid follow either
of these opinions since they both
originate from the same mujtahid?

392
00:44:30,500 --> 00:44:36,912
I believe my brother Wa’il
sent his question before I
could clarify this point.

393
00:44:36,912 --> 00:44:46,430
During my speech, I mentioned that if
someone imitates Imam al-Shafi’i and
becomes aware that he changed his ijtihad,

394
00:44:46,430 --> 00:44:49,636
then it is obligatory for them to shift

395
00:44:49,636 --> 00:44:59,355
their taqlid from the earlier opinion of
al-Shafi’i to his later one—because they
adopted his view based on trust in him.

396
00:44:59,355 --> 00:45:04,565
Consequently, due to this trust,
they must follow where he moved,

397
00:45:04,565 --> 00:45:12,480
since his change was based
on finding stronger evidence—not
out of personal preference or whim.

398
00:45:12,480 --> 00:45:20,010
Yes, it is obligatory upon the muqallid—if
he follows a particular mujtahid—to
shift to that mujtahid’s new ijtihad if

399
00:45:20,010 --> 00:45:23,540
he becomes aware that he has
adopted another position.

400
00:45:23,540 --> 00:45:36,100
Sister Aisha Zatari. Peace be upon you and
Allah’s mercy and blessings. And upon you
be peace and Allah’s mercy and blessings.

401
00:45:36,100 --> 00:45:42,697
Is the method of establishing
the caliphate that Hizb ut-Tahrir
adopts a matter of ijtihad,

402
00:45:42,697 --> 00:45:45,160
or is it a definite Shari’ah ruling?

403
00:45:45,160 --> 00:45:52,160
My dear sister,
the method of establishing the Caliphate
is not one Shari’ah legal ruling.

404
00:45:52,160 --> 00:45:55,554
It is a process extending
from the initial formation of the party

405
00:45:55,554 --> 00:46:01,200
bloc until the establishment
of the Islamic State—may Allah,
Exalted be He, hasten it.

406
00:46:01,200 --> 00:46:08,500
It comprises a collection
of Shari’ah legal rulings,
including obligations and prohibitions.

407
00:46:08,500 --> 00:46:10,857
Its obligations include
forming the party bloc,

408
00:46:10,857 --> 00:46:15,840
proclaiming the da’wah openly,
intellectual struggle
and political struggle.

409
00:46:15,840 --> 00:46:24,460
Its prohibitions include that the
disbeliever must not participate in ruling
by other than what Allah has revealed,

410
00:46:24,460 --> 00:46:29,500
that one must not appease,
and that one must not abandon
the word of truth, and so on.

411
00:46:29,500 --> 00:46:35,900
This collection of Shari’ah
legal rulings forms the method
of establishing the Islamic State.

412
00:46:35,900 --> 00:46:43,180
It is neither said that all
of them are definite rulings,
nor that all of them are probable ones.

413
00:46:43,180 --> 00:46:49,020
Within it are definite rulings—such
as the obligation to carry the da’wah,

414
00:46:49,020 --> 00:46:53,959
the prohibition of judging by anything
other than what Allah has revealed,

415
00:46:53,959 --> 00:47:02,000
and the prohibition of appointing
a ruler who governs by anything other
than what Allah has revealed—and so on.

416
00:47:02,000 --> 00:47:06,093
There are matters that can be
described as based on ijtihad.

417
00:47:06,093 --> 00:47:12,500
It is not correct to say—it is invalid to
claim—that the entire method is definite,

418
00:47:12,500 --> 00:47:16,060
nor is it valid to state
that the whole method is probable.

419
00:47:16,060 --> 00:47:18,789
Whatever is derived
from definitive evidence

420
00:47:18,789 --> 00:47:23,717
is definitive; whatever is derived
from probable evidence is probable.

421
00:47:23,717 --> 00:47:29,480
Consequently, disagreement is permissible
in matters that are subject to ijtihad.

422
00:47:29,480 --> 00:47:43,520
Brother Abdullah Khamees asks:
Could all Muslims be mujtahids
under the rule of a Caliphate?

423
00:47:43,520 --> 00:47:54,120
Or would they only be imitators?
Of course, it is inconceivable
that every Muslim could be a mujtahid.

424
00:47:54,120 --> 00:48:03,120
We know that people vary in their
abilities—some possess the capacity
for ijtihad, while others do not.

425
00:48:03,120 --> 00:48:09,120
Even among the Companions, some asked
other Companions for legal rulings.

426
00:48:09,120 --> 00:48:15,433
We said there were six; a short while ago,
we cited a hadith from al-Sha‘bi,
may Allah be pleased with him:

427
00:48:15,433 --> 00:48:23,220
‘Six Companions of Allah’s Messenger,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
used to issue legal rulings to people.’

428
00:48:23,220 --> 00:48:29,220
Thus, even during the Companions’ time,
some sought fatwas and others issued them.

429
00:48:29,220 --> 00:48:36,460
Another question from my brother Wael
Al-Sultan: The opinion of the imam is
binding both outwardly and inwardly.

430
00:48:36,460 --> 00:48:43,797
In which fields of jurisprudence does
this principle apply? Does it extend
to worships or only transactions?

431
00:48:43,797 --> 00:48:50,320
And if an imam adopts a ruling
in matters of worship, is that for every
legal ruling, or only for some?

432
00:48:50,320 --> 00:48:55,320
I have spoken on this matter before
and will now elaborate further upon it.

433
00:48:55,320 --> 00:48:59,183
Firstly, my dear brothers, we
must pay attention to the fact

434
00:48:59,183 --> 00:49:06,266
that dividing Shari’ah legal rulings
into categories is not a division
established by the Shari’ah itself.

435
00:49:06,266 --> 00:49:11,014
Rather, it is a terminological
classification—one that is permissible,

436
00:49:11,014 --> 00:49:14,038
of course—but not something
introduced by the Shari’ah.

437
00:49:14,038 --> 00:49:17,613
The Shari’ah did not
divide its legal rulings;

438
00:49:17,613 --> 00:49:22,442
it did not categorise them as worships,
transactions, or moral qualities.

439
00:49:22,442 --> 00:49:25,420
This classification
was devised by jurists.

440
00:49:25,420 --> 00:49:33,720
Jurists classified these divisions
to facilitate the organisation
and reference of fiqh rulings.

441
00:49:33,720 --> 00:49:36,420
Consequently, no Shari’ah considerations,

442
00:49:36,420 --> 00:49:44,520
divisions, foundational principles,
or rules are based
on this terminology—no, not at all.

443
00:49:44,520 --> 00:49:48,942
It is incorrect to say that
there are specific foundational

444
00:49:48,942 --> 00:49:54,426
principles governing worships alone
and others governing transactions.

445
00:49:54,426 --> 00:50:01,912
Rather, after examining Shari’ah legal
rulings—particularly those concerning
worships—one might conclude,

446
00:50:01,912 --> 00:50:10,613
for example, that the rulings of worships
do not admit reasoning because we
find them without a stated rationale.

447
00:50:10,613 --> 00:50:13,620
However, this is not
itself a legal ruling.

448
00:50:13,620 --> 00:50:22,281
This is because there is no Shari’ah
evidence specifying what constitutes
worships and what does not.

449
00:50:22,281 --> 00:50:27,746
To illustrate: zakat is classified as
a form of worship by technical definition,

450
00:50:27,746 --> 00:50:35,676
yet is it not also part of the Islamic
economic system’s legal rulings—that is,
a component of transactions?

451
00:50:35,676 --> 00:50:42,720
Zakat establishes
relationships between people,
between one human being and another.

452
00:50:42,720 --> 00:50:46,759
There are those who pay zakat
and those who receive it.

453
00:50:46,759 --> 00:50:55,021
A Muslim may give his zakat to the poor,
or to someone in debt, for jihad in
Allah’s cause, to those whose hearts are

454
00:50:55,021 --> 00:51:03,834
to be won over, spend it himself directly,
or even transfer it to the state, which
then determines how it is distributed.

455
00:51:03,834 --> 00:51:11,820
In this case, classification does
not depend on whether something
falls under worships or transactions.

456
00:51:11,820 --> 00:51:18,541
The distinction between what the state
must adopt and what it need not adopt

457
00:51:18,541 --> 00:51:28,995
depends on which relations among people
in the Islamic State and Islamic life
can proceed properly without adoption,

458
00:51:28,995 --> 00:51:33,796
and which can proceed properly
only through adoption.

459
00:51:33,796 --> 00:51:35,289
Matters that can

460
00:51:35,289 --> 00:51:45,559
be left to people without causing problems
in society when the Caliph does not adopt
a ruling are left to them as they wish.

461
00:51:45,559 --> 00:51:54,384
The Caliph and the Islamic
State have no reason to impose
a particular school regarding prayer,

462
00:51:54,384 --> 00:51:59,109
fasting or similar matters on the Muslims.

463
00:51:59,109 --> 00:52:05,052
Regarding zakat and its details, however,
he may prescribe a particular ruling.

464
00:52:05,052 --> 00:52:08,020
Do you not see that Umar ibn al-Khattab,

465
00:52:08,020 --> 00:52:16,680
may Allah be pleased with him,
suspended the share for those whose
hearts were to be reconciled?

466
00:52:16,680 --> 00:52:20,520
This was not because
Umar ibn al-Khattab had

467
00:52:20,520 --> 00:52:29,375
concluded through ijtihad
that this category did not exist or was
not among the recipients of zakat.

468
00:52:29,375 --> 00:52:35,650
Rather, he found that those who
received it in the Prophet’s time,

469
00:52:35,650 --> 00:52:43,989
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
met the description of those whose
hearts were to be reconciled,

470
00:52:43,989 --> 00:52:51,137
whereas that description no longer applied
to them in his time, so he suspended it.

471
00:52:51,137 --> 00:52:57,324
The Caliph may determine who belongs
to this category and who does not.

472
00:52:57,324 --> 00:53:02,765
He may also decide whether to pay
this category in a given year.

473
00:53:02,765 --> 00:53:11,405
He may distribute zakat among its
eight categories of recipients
or give it to some and not others.

474
00:53:11,405 --> 00:53:15,642
Zakat need not be distributed
to all eight categories.

475
00:53:15,642 --> 00:53:23,460
The Caliph chooses what is
most appropriate and obligatory
in the circumstances.

476
00:53:25,560 --> 00:53:32,521
Therefore, if Muslim relations
and societal care cannot proceed correctly
without the Caliph’s adoption of a ruling,

477
00:53:32,521 --> 00:53:40,260
then it becomes incumbent upon
him to adopt it—whether in matters
of worships or transactions.

478
00:53:41,580 --> 00:53:45,840
For example, fasting
is one of the worships.

479
00:53:45,840 --> 00:53:53,100
It does not befit the Islamic nation
to differ over its beginning or end.

480
00:53:55,620 --> 00:54:06,173
Here, no matter how those who disagree may
differ—and even if past disagreement was
justified regarding whether local times

481
00:54:06,173 --> 00:54:13,591
should vary or remain uniform—all jurists,
despite their differing
views on this matter,

482
00:54:13,591 --> 00:54:23,280
have unanimously agreed that if the Caliph
adopts a single day for the beginning
and end of Ramadan’s month of fasting,

483
00:54:23,280 --> 00:54:26,460
then all Muslims must adhere to it.

484
00:54:27,740 --> 00:54:34,240
Thus, one group of Muslims should
not fast on one day while another
group fasts on a different day;

485
00:54:34,240 --> 00:54:36,760
this is within the
authority of the Caliph.

486
00:54:38,320 --> 00:54:39,660
If the Caliph says,

487
00:54:39,660 --> 00:54:50,080
‘I have decided to unify the times of the
adhan,’ we know that the jurists differed,
for example, over the time of Asr:

488
00:54:50,080 --> 00:54:59,399
does it begin when an object’s shadow
equals its height, excluding the noon
shadow, or including the noon shadow?

489
00:54:59,399 --> 00:55:04,000
The jurists differed over
the time of Asr in this way.

490
00:55:04,240 --> 00:55:12,060
The state considers it inappropriate
for every mosque to issue the call
to prayer at different times.

491
00:55:12,060 --> 00:55:19,660
Instead, they say: ‘All of you must
give the call to prayer for Asr at this
specific time,’ and everyone complies.

492
00:55:19,660 --> 00:55:24,807
This concerns public life
and relations among people.

493
00:55:24,807 --> 00:55:33,615
Where relations cannot proceed properly
unless the Caliph adopts a ruling,
he must adopt one.

494
00:55:33,615 --> 00:55:42,271
During this halaqa, I gave the example
of agricultural land. May agricultural
land be leased, or may it not be leased?

495
00:55:42,271 --> 00:55:49,895
These are financial and economic
relations in which people may
have to appear before a judge.

496
00:55:49,895 --> 00:55:57,420
If they disagree, the judge rules
according to the legal ruling adopted
by the Commander of the Faithful.

497
00:55:57,420 --> 00:56:02,437
An example was given in divorce:
what Abu Bakr adopted,
what Umar adopted, and the issues

498
00:56:02,437 --> 00:56:09,220
regarding differences between
the Caliphs—matters each adopted are too
numerous to enumerate now in this session.

499
00:56:09,220 --> 00:56:14,540
These are the questions we have received
up to this moment, my dear brothers.

500
00:56:14,540 --> 00:56:19,505
We ask Allah, Exalted be He,
to benefit us through what He has
taught us, to increase us in knowledge,

501
00:56:19,505 --> 00:56:23,444
and to make our knowledge and deeds
sincere for His Generous Face.

502
00:56:23,444 --> 00:56:24,560
O Allah,

503
00:56:24,560 --> 00:56:30,957
we ask You for reward and recompense and
ask You to make what we present and will
present sincere for His Generous Face.

504
00:56:30,957 --> 00:56:37,231
I invoke blessings and peace upon
Allah’s Messenger, his family,
his Companions and those who follow them.

505
00:56:37,231 --> 00:56:40,440
May the peace, mercy and blessings
of Allah be upon you.
