1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:07,058
In the name of Allah, the Most Merciful.
Peace and blessings be upon you all.

2
00:00:07,058 --> 00:00:19,673
We praise Allah, exalted be He, and send
prayers and peace upon His Messenger,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

3
00:00:19,673 --> 00:00:23,880
Welcome, dear brothers,
to this new episode of Halaqa Online.

4
00:00:25,080 --> 00:00:31,079
In today’s session—part
of our series on the question:

5
00:00:31,079 --> 00:00:42,740
How do we follow Shari’ah?—we
discussed Shari’ah legal rulings,
their types and classifications;

6
00:00:42,740 --> 00:00:54,420
we examined ijtihad (diligent legal
inquiry) and its practitioners, including
the different categories of mujtahids.

7
00:00:54,420 --> 00:01:03,880
In the previous halaqa, we turned
to the topic of muqallidun (imitators).

8
00:01:03,880 --> 00:01:15,040
We defined imitation (taqlid),
distinguished it from ijtihad,
and outlined the ranks among followers.

9
00:01:15,040 --> 00:01:22,900
This session addresses two key
matters concerning imitators:

10
00:01:22,900 --> 00:01:29,327
how does an individual choose
which mujtahid to follow?

11
00:01:29,327 --> 00:01:40,340
And once they have followed one mujtahid,
may they later switch
to following another?

12
00:01:40,340 --> 00:01:45,460
These are the two focal points
of our discussion today.

13
00:01:45,460 --> 00:01:55,460
But before addressing these two points,
let me correct an omission from last
time—by way of clarification:

14
00:01:55,460 --> 00:02:06,467
imitation (taqlid) is only permissible
in matters of probabilistic
Shari’ah legal rulings.

15
00:02:06,467 --> 00:02:17,749
The Muslim who lacks the capacity
for ijtihad because he does not
possess the necessary qualifications

16
00:02:17,749 --> 00:02:20,900
must necessarily imitate—but what?

17
00:02:20,900 --> 00:02:33,180
He imitates secondary Shari’ah legal
rulings that require diligent inquiry,
which he himself cannot derive.

18
00:02:33,180 --> 00:02:38,902
In the field of creed and belief,
imitation is entirely invalid.

19
00:02:38,902 --> 00:02:44,183
It is never permissible for faith
to be based on imitation.

20
00:02:44,183 --> 00:02:52,920
Faith—belief—is a firm conviction
that aligns with reality
and is supported by evidence.

21
00:02:52,920 --> 00:03:00,510
If a person lacks evidence
for what they believe in,
then this is not true faith at all.

22
00:03:00,510 --> 00:03:09,272
Allah, exalted is He, commanded people
regarding matters of belief and creed
to bring forth proof. He said:

23
00:03:09,272 --> 00:03:11,913
﴿ قُلْ هَاتُوا۟ بُرْهَـٰنَكُمْ
إِن كُنتُمْ صَـٰدِقِينَ ﴾

24
00:03:11,913 --> 00:03:16,095
‘Bring your proof, if you
are truthful.’ [2:111; 27:64]

25
00:03:16,095 --> 00:03:17,085
, and He said:

26
00:03:17,085 --> 00:03:19,726
﴿ قُلْ هَلْ عِندَكُم مِّنْ
عِلْمٍ فَتُخْرِجُوهُ لَنَآ ﴾

27
00:03:19,726 --> 00:03:22,807
‘Say: Do you have any knowledge that

28
00:03:22,807 --> 00:03:25,228
you can produce for us?’ [6:148]

29
00:03:25,228 --> 00:03:27,208
, and He further stated:

30
00:03:27,208 --> 00:03:28,859
﴿ فَأْتُونَا بِسُلْطَـٰنٍ مُّبِينٍ ﴾

31
00:03:28,859 --> 00:03:31,720
‘Then bring us a clear proof.’ [14:10]

32
00:03:31,720 --> 00:03:39,056
Allah, exalted is He, condemned
those who inherit the religions of their
forefathers, refusing to accept any

33
00:03:39,056 --> 00:03:46,475
new faith or belief—no matter how
strong its evidence—if it contradicts
what they found their ancestors upon.

34
00:03:46,475 --> 00:03:49,030
﴿ وَإِذَا قِيلَ لَهُمُ ٱتَّبِعُوا۟
مَآ أَنزَلَ ٱللَّهُ قَالُوا۟

35
00:03:49,030 --> 00:03:51,173
بَلْ نَتَّبِعُ مَآ أَلْفَيْنَا
عَلَيْهِ ءَابَآءَنَآ ۗ

36
00:03:51,173 --> 00:03:53,481
أَوَلَوْ كَانَ ءَابَآؤُهُمْ
لَا يَعْقِلُونَ شَيْـًٔا وَلَا

37
00:03:53,481 --> 00:03:53,976
يَهْتَدُونَ ﴾

38
00:03:53,976 --> 00:03:57,980
‘When it is said to them,
‘Follow what Allah has revealed,’

39
00:03:57,980 --> 00:04:03,950
they say, ‘No, we follow what we
found our forefathers following.’
Even though their forefathers

40
00:04:03,950 --> 00:04:07,000
understood nothing and
were not guided?’ [2:170]

41
00:04:07,000 --> 00:04:18,827
Whoever follows parents, leaders, scholars
or anyone else they trust in matters
of iman and creed has wronged himself.

42
00:04:18,827 --> 00:04:27,320
He is not following the Shari’ah of Allah,
Glorified and Exalted,
His religion or His Messenger.

43
00:04:27,320 --> 00:04:37,680
He has made imitation his foundation,
although iman can never be
valid through imitation.

44
00:04:37,680 --> 00:04:48,960
In that case, he does not follow
the creed itself; he follows the person
whom he imitates in matters of creed.

45
00:04:48,960 --> 00:04:54,157
It cannot be said that imitation
is permissible in creed just as

46
00:04:54,157 --> 00:04:59,380
it is permissible in Shari’ah
legal rulings that require ijtihad.

47
00:04:59,380 --> 00:05:05,300
This is entirely excluded, because iman
is the foundation of human thought,

48
00:05:05,300 --> 00:05:13,940
the basis of one’s religion and life,
and the foundation of one’s
culture and entire way of life.

49
00:05:13,940 --> 00:05:17,380
It must therefore be firmly
rooted with complete certainty.

50
00:05:17,380 --> 00:05:23,920
That is possible only when a person has
personally derived the evidence for it.

51
00:05:23,920 --> 00:05:26,615
Allah, Glorified and Exalted,

52
00:05:26,615 --> 00:05:34,040
has therefore required
people to establish evidence
for the creed and iman they adopt.

53
00:05:34,040 --> 00:05:38,480
We have already recited some
of the verses concerning this.

54
00:05:38,480 --> 00:05:47,780
Nor can it be said that it may be
difficult for an untrained person
to derive evidence for faith on their own;

55
00:05:47,780 --> 00:05:54,330
such a claim is invalid because the
matters we are commanded to believe in—to

56
00:05:54,330 --> 00:06:03,540
hold as conviction and thereby
become Muslims—are easily
demonstrable by every human being.

57
00:06:03,540 --> 00:06:07,976
Therefore, no one may imitate
another regarding belief in Allah,

58
00:06:07,976 --> 00:06:17,280
saying: “I am a believer in Allah
because I trust so-and-so,
who told me that Almighty Allah exists.”

59
00:06:17,280 --> 00:06:20,363
This is not faith; rather,
he must possess evidence

60
00:06:20,363 --> 00:06:28,760
from his own reasoning and thought
that Allah is true—something
accessible to every human being.

61
00:06:28,760 --> 00:06:36,600
Likewise, it is impermissible to say:
‘I believe in the Book of Allah
and in Muhammad as the Messenger of Allah,

62
00:06:36,600 --> 00:06:41,343
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
because I trust the person
who told me this.’

63
00:06:41,343 --> 00:06:42,398
This is not iman.

64
00:06:42,398 --> 00:06:47,760
One must personally derive
the evidence that the Qur’an
is the speech of Allah and,

65
00:06:47,760 --> 00:06:51,166
consequently, that Muhammad
is Allah’s Messenger.

66
00:06:51,166 --> 00:06:58,940
Through the definitive texts in Allah’s
Book and the Sunnah of His Messenger,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

67
00:06:58,940 --> 00:07:04,723
one must personally derive
the evidence for belief in Allah,
the angels and the Last Day.

68
00:07:04,723 --> 00:07:11,260
Such iman is therefore valid
only on the basis of evidence.
There is no faith in imitation.

69
00:07:11,260 --> 00:07:18,600
Whoever imitates in matters of faith has
not truly walked the path of faith—that
is what I wished to highlight.

70
00:07:18,600 --> 00:07:28,280
We now turn to our topic:
whom does a Muslim who lacks
the qualifications for ijtihad follow?

71
00:07:28,280 --> 00:07:36,320
He must practise imitation (taqlid),
because he cannot perform ijtihad himself.
But whom does he follow?

72
00:07:36,320 --> 00:07:46,960
There is this mujtahid and that mujtahid,
and there have been many mujtahids,
although today we remember only

73
00:07:46,960 --> 00:07:55,040
a few famous names: al-Shafi‘i,
Malik, Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Abu Hanifa,
Zayd, Ja‘far and al-Awza‘i.

74
00:07:55,040 --> 00:08:01,900
The madhahib of some of these mujtahids
have reached us almost in full,

75
00:08:01,900 --> 00:08:08,100
while only individual issues have
been transmitted from others.

76
00:08:08,100 --> 00:08:16,800
In every case, the Muslim
faces several madhahib—that is,
several mujtahids. Whom should he choose?

77
00:08:16,800 --> 00:08:23,500
In fact, whether the Muslim muqallid
follows this mujtahid or that one,

78
00:08:23,500 --> 00:08:29,860
he has adopted a Shari’ah legal
ruling derived by a mujtahid,
and his obligation is discharged.

79
00:08:29,860 --> 00:08:34,500
Whether he takes from one
mujtahid or another,

80
00:08:34,500 --> 00:08:43,740
Imam al-Shafi‘i’s ijtihad is
a Shari’ah legal ruling, Abu Hanifa’s
ijtihad is a Shari’ah legal ruling,

81
00:08:43,740 --> 00:08:50,020
and the same applies to the ijtihad
of Malik, Ahmad, al-Awza‘i,
al-Thawri, Zayd and Ja‘far.

82
00:08:50,020 --> 00:08:55,880
All of them were mujtahid
Imams who performed ijtihad.

83
00:08:55,880 --> 00:09:00,040
What they derived through ijtihad
constitutes Shari’ah legal rulings,

84
00:09:00,040 --> 00:09:05,580
whether they were correct
or mistaken in their ijtihad.

85
00:09:05,580 --> 00:09:10,340
We have already said,
in a meaning-based quotation,

86
00:09:10,340 --> 00:09:17,900
that when a mujtahid performs ijtihad
and is correct, he receives two rewards;
and when he performs

87
00:09:17,900 --> 00:09:22,648
ijtihad and errs, he receives
one reward. [al-Bukhari, 7352;

88
00:09:22,648 --> 00:09:23,680
Muslim, 1716].

89
00:09:23,680 --> 00:09:35,560
The reality is that most Muslims
naturally find people around them
who follow a particular madhhab,

90
00:09:35,560 --> 00:09:44,040
so they find no one to teach them
except according to that madhhab.

91
00:09:44,040 --> 00:09:52,937
Look at many Muslim lands today:
in many of them,
one madhhab has become widespread.

92
00:09:52,937 --> 00:10:03,380
In Morocco, most people follow
the madhhab of Imam Malik.
In Indonesia, most people are Shafi‘i.

93
00:10:03,380 --> 00:10:15,740
In Turkey, most are Hanafi.
In the Arabian Peninsula, most people
follow Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, and so on.

94
00:10:15,740 --> 00:10:27,320
When a Muslim becomes legally responsible,
he finds someone who teaches him
according to the prevailing madhhab.

95
00:10:27,320 --> 00:10:37,960
By learning from him, he acquires a
Shari’ah legal ruling. Of course, he does
not imitate the person who taught him.

96
00:10:37,960 --> 00:10:44,020
If you studied under a shaykh and learned
Shari’ah legal rulings from him,

97
00:10:44,020 --> 00:10:50,780
you did not imitate that shaykh,
because he is not the mujtahid.

98
00:10:50,780 --> 00:10:57,480
He is a teacher or mufti who transmitted
to you the ijtihad of a mujtahid.

99
00:10:57,480 --> 00:11:05,700
Once a Muslim has studied Shari’ah legal
rulings according to a particular madhhab,

100
00:11:05,700 --> 00:11:14,880
his obligation is discharged and he
has acquired a Shari’ah legal
ruling through a valid ijtihad.

101
00:11:14,880 --> 00:11:22,536
Once he acts upon the ruling he learned,
it becomes Allah’s ruling
for him, and he will

102
00:11:22,536 --> 00:11:35,000
be held accountable before Allah according
to it, because he adopted it through
a valid Shari’ah method and acted upon it.

103
00:11:35,000 --> 00:11:44,243
Thus, if he learns how to pray according
to the madhhab of Imam Abu Hanifa,
adheres to it and prays accordingly,

104
00:11:44,243 --> 00:11:53,480
the Shari’ah legal rulings he took
through Imam Abu Hanifa’s madhhab
become Allah’s ruling for him.

105
00:11:53,480 --> 00:12:01,590
However, before moving
on to the transition from one
madhhab to another, I would say this:

106
00:12:01,590 --> 00:12:09,516
if a Muslim has learned Shari’ah legal
rulings but has not yet acted upon
them—that is, he has not practically

107
00:12:09,516 --> 00:12:19,200
applied them—he may, if he is confident
in another mujtahid’s reasoning, adopt
that mujtahid’s legal rulings instead.

108
00:12:19,200 --> 00:12:27,757
For example, suppose someone learns
the Shari’ah legal rulings of Hajj
according to a particular madhhab

109
00:12:27,757 --> 00:12:29,962
but has yet to perform Hajj.

110
00:12:29,962 --> 00:12:37,579
Later, they encounter a scholar
who teaches the rules of Hajj
based on another school and are

111
00:12:37,579 --> 00:12:45,020
reassured by this scholar’s greater
knowledge, higher trustworthiness,
and stronger moral integrity.

112
00:12:45,020 --> 00:12:50,608
They become convinced that it
is appropriate for them

113
00:12:50,608 --> 00:13:00,831
to take their rulings—on Hajj and other
matters—from this jurist or teacher rather
than the one they initially learned from.

114
00:13:00,831 --> 00:13:10,320
In such a case, since they have not
yet acted upon the legal rulings
of the first madhhab they studied,

115
00:13:10,320 --> 00:13:13,660
there is no harm in shifting
to another school’s rulings.

116
00:13:13,660 --> 00:13:17,177
Once someone has begun
acting upon Shari’ah

117
00:13:17,177 --> 00:13:25,540
legal rulings and adopted a particular
madhhab as their source of imitation,
Allah’s ruling becomes binding for them.

118
00:13:25,540 --> 00:13:31,540
Is it then permissible for them
to switch to another madhhab?

119
00:13:31,540 --> 00:13:34,880
Similarly, someone might ask:

120
00:13:34,880 --> 00:13:43,275
what if this learner has not yet
committed to a particular madhhab and is
presented with two options—one scholar

121
00:13:43,275 --> 00:13:53,105
teaching according to one school (for
example, the Shafi’i) and another teaching
according to another (such as the Hanafi)?

122
00:13:53,105 --> 00:13:59,980
How should they choose between
these two scholars—and thus
between these two schools?

123
00:13:59,980 --> 00:14:05,743
One teaches the Shafi’i rulings
while the other teaches the Hanafi.

124
00:14:05,743 --> 00:14:14,060
Now, if this person wishes to learn
Shari’ah legal rulings, how do they decide
which madhhab—or even a third—to imitate?

125
00:14:14,060 --> 00:14:24,600
May he choose freely, as one may choose
between a concession and a firm ruling,
or between two permissible options?

126
00:14:24,600 --> 00:14:32,076
No, the situation of the imitator
is similar to that of a mujtahid
presented with two pieces of evidence.

127
00:14:32,076 --> 00:14:36,060
He weighs them against each other
until he reaches what is stronger.

128
00:14:36,060 --> 00:14:45,720
The mujtahid does not accept either
piece of evidence outright but instead
seeks reconciliation between them.

129
00:14:45,720 --> 00:14:47,204
If he cannot reconcile them,

130
00:14:47,204 --> 00:14:54,680
it becomes obligatory upon him
to prefer one over the other based
on his capacity and tools for ijtihad.

131
00:14:54,680 --> 00:14:59,464
Similarly, the imitator has
criteria for preference; however,

132
00:14:59,464 --> 00:15:06,874
these are not based on the strength
of evidence because he lacks
the ability to perform ijtihad.

133
00:15:06,874 --> 00:15:14,003
What he possesses is the ability
to prefer between those who
study these schools of thought:

134
00:15:14,003 --> 00:15:21,740
if he finds someone whom people
testify as trustworthy and just,
then he prefers that person over another.

135
00:15:21,740 --> 00:15:30,460
If he finds both are just and trustworthy,
he takes from the one he trusts more
in terms of justice and reliability.

136
00:15:30,460 --> 00:15:35,040
Here, he prefers among
those who study them.

137
00:15:35,040 --> 00:15:41,780
If he trusts a particular
teacher or shaykh who advises him
to go and study with so-and-so,

138
00:15:41,780 --> 00:15:43,644
this becomes his preferred choice.

139
00:15:43,644 --> 00:15:49,920
If he finds that one individual
is more pious than another,
this also influences his preference.

140
00:15:49,920 --> 00:15:59,340
If he knows that a particular shaykh
is one of the ruler’s scholars,
he leaves him and goes to someone else.

141
00:15:59,340 --> 00:16:04,560
Integrity is the basis
for receiving knowledge
and for choosing among the mujtahids.

142
00:16:04,560 --> 00:16:12,500
It is also the basis for choosing
those who transmit from the mujtahids,

143
00:16:12,500 --> 00:16:17,740
because whoever transmits from a mujtahid
testifies that a particular
mujtahid said such-and-such.

144
00:16:17,740 --> 00:16:25,480
He therefore bears testimony,
and an essential condition
of a witness is integrity.

145
00:16:25,480 --> 00:16:34,180
When he is faced with several madhahib,
he must therefore rely on criteria
recognised by the Shari’ah.

146
00:16:34,180 --> 00:16:45,740
One such criterion may be that he
has previously studied the Shafi‘i,
Hanafi, Maliki and Hanbali madhahib,

147
00:16:45,740 --> 00:16:55,205
among others, and examined the legal
principles of each to the extent
of his ability and knowledge.

148
00:16:55,205 --> 00:17:07,452
He may then conclude that one madhhab—for
example, the Shafi‘i madhhab—has stronger,
firmer and more deeply rooted principles.

149
00:17:07,452 --> 00:17:14,705
This becomes a valid criterion
for choosing someone who teaches Shari’ah

150
00:17:14,705 --> 00:17:26,120
legal rulings according to the Shafi‘i
madhhab, or according to another madhhab
whose principles he finds stronger.

151
00:17:26,120 --> 00:17:30,400
In this way, he has chosen
a madhhab to follow.

152
00:17:30,400 --> 00:17:36,527
There is no requirement for a person
to follow one madhhab in every issue.

153
00:17:36,527 --> 00:17:43,300
He may say, ‘I trust the Shafi‘i madhhab
and will follow it in all matters.’

154
00:17:43,300 --> 00:17:50,747
But he may also say, ‘I know a trustworthy
shaykh who teaches the rulings of worship
according to the Shafi‘i madhhab,

155
00:17:50,747 --> 00:17:53,887
so I will learn from him.

156
00:17:53,887 --> 00:18:01,954
However, I find that another person
is stronger and more proficient
in matters of transactions,

157
00:18:01,954 --> 00:18:08,780
even though he teaches them
according to another madhhab,
so I will take those rulings from him.’

158
00:18:08,780 --> 00:18:18,803
The Companions would sometimes seek
a fatwa from one mujtahid Companion
and at other times from another.

159
00:18:18,803 --> 00:18:27,789
Neither the Companions nor the Followers
relied upon a single senior
Companion of the Messenger of Allah,

160
00:18:27,789 --> 00:18:32,691
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
for every question.

161
00:18:32,691 --> 00:18:42,334
People sought a fatwa on one issue
from one Companion and on another
issue from a different Companion.

162
00:18:42,334 --> 00:18:49,540
No one said—and no evidence
indicates—that a Muslim must follow
a single madhhab in all his actions.

163
00:18:51,540 --> 00:18:56,109
However, if a person’s work becomes bound
by the imitation of a particular school,

164
00:18:56,109 --> 00:19:02,651
then Allah’s ruling applies to him,
and it becomes obligatory
upon him to adhere to it.

165
00:19:02,651 --> 00:19:07,918
He may not shift to another school unless
there are valid grounds for doing so.

166
00:19:07,918 --> 00:19:11,540
We shall now begin enumerating
some of these grounds.

167
00:19:11,540 --> 00:19:16,618
Suppose, for example, that he
learned Shari’ah legal rulings

168
00:19:16,618 --> 00:19:25,401
from a teacher who taught him
according to a particular madhhab
without giving him the evidence.

169
00:19:25,401 --> 00:19:28,120
He thereby became a lay muqallid (‘ammi).

170
00:19:28,120 --> 00:19:35,248
We previously explained that imitation
has two levels: the lay muqallid
and the follower (muttabi‘),

171
00:19:35,248 --> 00:19:39,540
with the follower being
the higher of the two.

172
00:19:39,540 --> 00:19:47,913
If he studies legal issues
under a shaykh who teaches
according to a particular madhhab

173
00:19:47,913 --> 00:19:54,540
without giving him the evidence for
those issues, he remains a lay muqallid.

174
00:19:54,540 --> 00:20:04,383
If he then finds someone who teaches him
the issues together with their evidence
according to another madhhab,

175
00:20:04,383 --> 00:20:08,949
he becomes a follower rather
than remaining a lay muqallid.

176
00:20:08,949 --> 00:20:19,540
This permits him to move from one madhhab
to another, provided that he is confident
in taking rulings from that teacher.

177
00:20:19,540 --> 00:20:26,980
We previously discussed
the grounds for such confidence:
integrity, knowledge and so forth.

178
00:20:26,980 --> 00:20:33,540
If he is confident in taking
these Shari’ah legal rulings,
together with their evidence,

179
00:20:33,540 --> 00:20:42,732
from another teacher of a different
madhhab, this is preferable
to what he took without evidence.

180
00:20:42,732 --> 00:20:51,540
It therefore permits him to move
from one madhhab to another. This is
one of the valid grounds for moving.

181
00:20:51,540 --> 00:20:59,943
Naturally, there are circumstances
where the muqallid must shift
from following one school to another.

182
00:20:59,943 --> 00:21:08,540
As we previously stated regarding
the mujtahid—if it is obligatory upon him,
then it is even more so for the follower.

183
00:21:08,540 --> 00:21:16,944
We have already mentioned that among
the cases requiring a mujtahid
to abandon his own ijtihad

184
00:21:16,944 --> 00:21:24,540
in favour of another’s is when
the Caliph—or rather, when the Islamic
state—adopts an opinion contrary to his.

185
00:21:24,540 --> 00:21:32,540
If the Caliph or the Islamic
state adopts an ijtihad differing
from that of Imam al-Shafi’i,

186
00:21:32,540 --> 00:21:36,388
then it becomes obligatory
upon him to cease

187
00:21:36,388 --> 00:21:46,257
acting according to his own reasoning and
instead follow the ijtihad adopted by the
Caliph—or rather, by the Islamic state.

188
00:21:46,257 --> 00:21:51,240
It is even more incumbent upon
the muqallid to stop following

189
00:21:51,240 --> 00:21:59,540
al-Shafi‘i’s madhhab and instead follow
and adhere to what the Caliph—or rather,
the Islamic State—has adopted.

190
00:21:59,540 --> 00:22:07,540
This is because the Imam’s view
resolves the dispute and is binding
both outwardly and inwardly.

191
00:22:07,540 --> 00:22:12,540
This is therefore a case in which
moving becomes obligatory.

192
00:22:12,540 --> 00:22:22,229
We now turn to another scenario
that permits the muqallid to shift
from following one madhhab to another.

193
00:22:22,229 --> 00:22:30,693
Suppose the muqallid began
his imitation and studied under
a particular school of thought

194
00:22:30,693 --> 00:22:41,510
while possessing only a certain level
of religious knowledge and understanding
of jurisprudential principles.

195
00:22:41,510 --> 00:22:51,741
Later, he devoted himself to reading
books on fiqh and also read works on usul
al-fiqh, thereby gaining familiarity

196
00:22:51,741 --> 00:22:59,540
with the foundational
principles of Imam al-Shafi’i,
Abu Hanifah, Malik, and others.

197
00:22:59,540 --> 00:23:08,669
After studying these texts
and acquiring some meaningful knowledge
in ijtihad and legal derivation,

198
00:23:08,669 --> 00:23:16,540
he developed an intellectual
inclination—meaning that,
based on what he had learned,

199
00:23:16,540 --> 00:23:26,540
he concluded that the strongest among them
in terms of principles, jurisprudence,
and reasoning was Imam al-Shafi’i.

200
00:23:26,540 --> 00:23:38,181
In this case, it is permissible—and indeed
preferable—for him to transition from
his previous imitation to following the

201
00:23:38,181 --> 00:23:49,540
ijtihad of another school, specifically
to follow Imam al-Shafi’i’s madhhab, since
he has inclined toward it intellectually.

202
00:23:49,540 --> 00:23:57,569
Similarly, let us assume
that someone initially believed
in the strength of al-Shafi’i’s

203
00:23:57,569 --> 00:24:09,389
principles—principles being the foundation
of legal rulings, their source and pathway
from evidence to Shari’ah legal rulings.

204
00:24:09,389 --> 00:24:17,195
Suppose he was confident
from the beginning in the strength
of a particular school’s

205
00:24:17,195 --> 00:24:24,443
principles but found no one teaching him
that school when he sought knowledge.

206
00:24:24,443 --> 00:24:33,475
Perhaps his teachers were not
themselves trained in the very
madhhab whose principles and rules

207
00:24:33,475 --> 00:24:43,540
of derivation he trusted, or perhaps there
was simply no one available to instruct
him according to that original school.

208
00:24:43,540 --> 00:24:51,540
In such a case, it is permissible for him
to shift from one madhhab to another.

209
00:24:51,540 --> 00:24:53,945
These are the cases where

210
00:24:53,945 --> 00:25:04,540
it is permissible for a Muslim to shift
from imitating one madhhab to another
based on valid Shari’ah considerations.

211
00:25:04,540 --> 00:25:16,060
Among them, as stated regarding
the mujtahid himself: if the intention is
to unite Muslims under a single position,

212
00:25:16,060 --> 00:25:18,797
then it is lawful for a follower

213
00:25:18,797 --> 00:25:30,135
(muqallid) to abandon his imitation just
as it was permissible for the mujtahid
to cease his ijtihad in favour of another.

214
00:25:30,135 --> 00:25:37,540
Thus, a muqallid may lawfully leave
following one madhhab and adopt another.

215
00:25:37,540 --> 00:25:47,540
For example, suppose the Imam—the
head of state—is not a mujtahid
and follows a particular madhhab.

216
00:25:47,540 --> 00:25:54,873
If uniting the Muslims requires him
to move from that madhhab to another,
he may do so, just

217
00:25:54,873 --> 00:26:06,325
as occurred with the pledge of allegiance
to ‘Uthman, may Allah be pleased with him,
which we discussed in an earlier halaqa.

218
00:26:06,325 --> 00:26:13,540
This is also a valid ground for a muqallid
to move from one madhhab to another.

219
00:26:13,540 --> 00:26:18,320
What I have just said, dear
brothers, brings together some

220
00:26:18,320 --> 00:26:27,676
of the Shari’ah grounds and considerations
that allow a muqallid to move
from following one madhhab to another.

221
00:26:27,676 --> 00:26:37,743
Other grounds may also exist, provided
that the consideration leading him to move
proceeds from following Allah’s Book

222
00:26:37,743 --> 00:26:46,387
and the Sunnah of His Messenger,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
because Allah, exalted is He, says:

223
00:26:46,387 --> 00:26:47,811
﴿ فَإِن تَنَـٰزَعْتُمْ فِى شَىْءٍ

224
00:26:47,811 --> 00:26:49,743
فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَٱلرَّسُولِ ﴾

225
00:26:49,743 --> 00:26:52,794
‘If you disagree over anything, refer

226
00:26:52,794 --> 00:26:55,540
it to Allah and the Messenger.’ [4:59]

227
00:26:55,540 --> 00:27:04,255
The rejected case in any transition from
one madhhab to another is when it occurs
out of personal inclination or desire—when

228
00:27:04,255 --> 00:27:12,971
someone finds a particular madhhab easier
than the one he previously followed and
thus shifts from imitating his original

229
00:27:12,971 --> 00:27:19,402
school to following another
simply because it is simpler,
more convenient, or more pleasing.

230
00:27:19,402 --> 00:27:25,540
In doing so, he becomes a follower
of his own desires (muttabi’
al-hawa), whereas Allah,

231
00:27:25,540 --> 00:27:28,540
exalted is He, has forbidden
following mere whims.

232
00:27:28,540 --> 00:27:40,540
A final point I wish to highlight:
if you study the Shari’ah legal rulings
of an obligatory act—such as prayer,

233
00:27:40,540 --> 00:27:53,806
for example—you will find that prayer
itself is a comprehensive Shari’ah
legal ruling encompassing many others.

234
00:27:53,806 --> 00:27:59,540
It includes rules on purity
and ablution, ghusl,

235
00:27:59,540 --> 00:28:12,540
nullifiers of ablution, nullifiers of
purity, conditions for validity, pillars,
recommended acts, and invalidators.

236
00:28:12,540 --> 00:28:23,540
Here we have an issue containing
numerous sub-issues—each one
a distinct Shari’ah legal ruling.

237
00:28:23,540 --> 00:28:29,646
The validity of prayer therefore depends
on a set of Shari’ah legal rulings.

238
00:28:29,646 --> 00:28:37,540
For one mujtahid,
this set includes definitive rulings
and rulings based on ijtihad.

239
00:28:37,540 --> 00:28:45,540
The second mujtahid likewise has a set:
some rulings are definitive
and agree with the first mujtahid,

240
00:28:45,540 --> 00:28:47,540
while others are probable and differ.

241
00:28:47,540 --> 00:28:51,540
If you imitate one of the mujtahids,

242
00:28:51,540 --> 00:28:57,540
you must take the entire issue from him,
because you did not
perform ijtihad yourself.

243
00:28:57,540 --> 00:29:03,521
Your prayer is not valid, your obligation
is not discharged and your duty

244
00:29:03,521 --> 00:29:12,482
is not fulfilled on the basis of your own
ijtihad, but on the basis of the ijtihad
of the mujtahid whom you follow.

245
00:29:12,482 --> 00:29:18,095
You have placed your responsibility
like a necklace around his neck.

246
00:29:18,095 --> 00:29:27,647
Your prayer must therefore be valid
according to that mujtahid—or according
to whichever other mujtahid you follow.

247
00:29:27,647 --> 00:29:34,540
It is not valid to mix
different Shari’ah legal rulings
relating to this single issue.

248
00:29:34,540 --> 00:29:42,540
You perform ablution in accordance
with the madhhab of Imam al-Shafi‘i,
then pray following Abu Hanifa’s school.

249
00:29:42,540 --> 00:29:45,996
Or you simply say,
‘I have performed ablution.’

250
00:29:45,996 --> 00:29:47,530
If a woman touches me,

251
00:29:47,530 --> 00:29:54,698
I declare: ‘I follow Abu Hanifa’s
opinion because he holds that touching
a woman does not invalidate ablution.’

252
00:29:54,698 --> 00:29:59,540
But if I then come to pray
according to the Shafi‘i madhhab,

253
00:29:59,540 --> 00:30:07,540
my prayer is invalid under Imam
al-Shafi‘i’s rulings—because my ablution
was incorrect; I touched a woman.

254
00:30:07,540 --> 00:30:15,540
In this case, I have not prayed
validly in accordance with either
the Shafi‘i or Abu Hanifa schools of law,

255
00:30:15,540 --> 00:30:17,540
nor based on my own ijtihad.

256
00:30:17,540 --> 00:30:21,540
So whose ruling makes my prayer valid?
It is valid under none.

257
00:30:21,540 --> 00:30:29,181
It is correct that you may follow
more than one mujtahid, taking each
matter from a different scholar.

258
00:30:29,181 --> 00:30:32,540
However, when addressing a single issue,

259
00:30:32,540 --> 00:30:39,940
it is obligatory to take the entire
question—including all its Shari’ah
legal rulings—from one mujtahid alone.

260
00:30:39,940 --> 00:30:46,540
You must derive prayer
and everything related to it
from one madhhab—for example,

261
00:30:46,540 --> 00:30:53,210
the Shafi’i school—and
take fasting rules entirely
from that same scholar or another.

262
00:30:53,210 --> 00:31:02,140
Likewise, you should learn all pilgrimage
regulations from a single madhhab
among those of the qualified mujtahids.

263
00:31:02,140 --> 00:31:10,794
In this way, if you are not yourself a
mujtahid but rather a follower (muqallid),
you will have truly followed someone

264
00:31:10,794 --> 00:31:19,540
and adopted a Shari’ah legal ruling
that is Allah’s command upon you according
to the ijtihad of one of the mujtahids.

265
00:31:19,540 --> 00:31:26,540
This was our topic for today.
I ask Allah, the Exalted, that He has
guided me in clarifying this idea.

266
00:31:26,540 --> 00:31:32,540
If I have succeeded, then praise is due
to Allah alone by His grace and guidance;

267
00:31:32,540 --> 00:31:36,603
if I have erred or fallen short,
it is from myself.

268
00:31:36,603 --> 00:31:40,540
I ask Allah to forgive us
and accept our repentance.

269
00:31:40,540 --> 00:31:48,460
Dear brothers, we have one question
from Brother al-‘Abid. He says:
many Muslims face a serious problem.

270
00:31:48,460 --> 00:31:55,157
They love particular shaykhs and regard
everything they say as correct,
so they follow them,

271
00:31:55,157 --> 00:32:02,540
believing that they should
not question someone more
knowledgeable than themselves.

272
00:32:02,540 --> 00:32:06,540
Does this discharge their obligation?

273
00:32:06,540 --> 00:32:14,540
I will illustrate the matter through
the issues of participating in elections,
ruling and obeying the ruler.

274
00:32:14,540 --> 00:32:23,540
Dear brothers, I discussed this matter
in previous halaqaat: what is called
blind imitation is never permissible.

275
00:32:23,540 --> 00:32:29,540
All the more so,
blindly seeking a fatwa is impermissible.

276
00:32:29,540 --> 00:32:37,540
Even a mujtahid is followed only in
speculative matters that require ijtihad.

277
00:32:37,540 --> 00:32:42,826
As I said, the mujtahid is chosen on the
basis of trust in his piety and integrity.

278
00:32:42,826 --> 00:32:48,540
All the more must we
examine the integrity,

279
00:32:48,540 --> 00:32:57,284
trustworthiness and piety of a mufti,
shaykh or teacher who is not himself
a mujtahid but transmits from one.

280
00:32:57,284 --> 00:33:02,911
Even if we trust him and are
satisfied that he is among the pious,

281
00:33:02,911 --> 00:33:12,867
he must not become an authority regarded
as infallible, so that everything he
says is treated as certainly true.

282
00:33:12,867 --> 00:33:16,540
Otherwise, this would be
following human beings,

283
00:33:16,540 --> 00:33:24,012
while we are commanded to follow the
Shari’ah of Allah, Glorified and Exalted:

284
00:33:24,012 --> 00:33:26,718
﴿ قُلْ إِن كُنتُمْ تُحِبُّونَ
ٱللَّهَ فَٱتَّبِعُونِى ﴾

285
00:33:26,718 --> 00:33:29,748
‘Say: If you love Allah,
follow me.’ [3:31]

286
00:33:29,748 --> 00:33:35,591
That is, we follow Muhammad,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace:

287
00:33:35,591 --> 00:33:38,297
﴿ قُلْ إِن كُنتُمْ تُحِبُّونَ
ٱللَّهَ فَٱتَّبِعُونِى

288
00:33:38,297 --> 00:33:40,894
يُحْبِبْكُمُ ٱللَّهُ
وَيَغْفِرْ لَكُمْ ذُنُوبَكُمْ ﴾

289
00:33:40,894 --> 00:33:44,140
‘Say: If you love Allah, follow me; Allah

290
00:33:44,140 --> 00:33:47,603
will love you and forgive
your sins.’ [3:31]

291
00:33:47,603 --> 00:33:49,551
We follow the Shari’ah:

292
00:33:49,551 --> 00:33:51,931
﴿ ثُمَّ جَعَلْنَـٰكَ عَلَىٰ
شَرِيعَةٍ مِّنَ ٱلْأَمْرِ

293
00:33:51,931 --> 00:33:54,745
فَٱتَّبِعْهَا وَلَا تَتَّبِعْ
أَهْوَآءَ ٱلَّذِينَ لَا

294
00:33:54,745 --> 00:33:55,394
يَعْلَمُونَ ﴾

295
00:33:55,394 --> 00:34:03,294
‘Then We placed you upon
a Shari’ah concerning the matter,
so follow it and do not follow the

296
00:34:03,294 --> 00:34:06,540
desires of those who do not know.’ [45:18]

297
00:34:06,540 --> 00:34:12,733
If you have trusted a shaykh for
a day—or perhaps for years—and

298
00:34:12,733 --> 00:34:22,540
he then surprises us with a fatwa
that clearly contradicts the Shari’ah
evidence, may we continue to follow him?

299
00:34:22,540 --> 00:34:26,540
What if, after trusting a shaykh,

300
00:34:26,540 --> 00:34:38,991
it later becomes clear that he now issues
fatwas to please the sultan, the ruler,
the king, the prince or the president?

301
00:34:38,991 --> 00:34:48,653
Must we maintain our trust in him
on the grounds that trust cannot waver?
Indeed, trust can waver.

302
00:34:48,653 --> 00:34:57,540
Trust in Allah’s Book and Allah’s
Messenger, may Allah bless him
and grant him peace, does not waver.

303
00:34:57,540 --> 00:35:04,135
But trust in any shaykh,
teacher or instructor can waver.

304
00:35:04,135 --> 00:35:14,540
Trust in any human being other than
Allah’s Messenger, may Allah bless
him and grant him peace, can waver.

305
00:35:14,540 --> 00:35:21,769
Our motto must be:
truth is not known through men; rather,
men are known through the truth.

306
00:35:21,769 --> 00:35:29,100
It is reported from Imam ‘Ali,
may Allah be pleased with him:
‘Truth is not known through men.

307
00:35:29,100 --> 00:35:33,540
Know the truth,
and you will know its people.’

308
00:35:33,540 --> 00:35:42,540
We are unable to perform ijtihad in
speculative matters that require ijtihad,
so we take them from those whom we trust.

309
00:35:42,540 --> 00:35:51,271
But if it is established one day that a
shaykh has violated a definitive ruling,
does our trust in him then fall away?

310
00:35:51,271 --> 00:35:53,540
We may have learned at
his hands for years,

311
00:35:53,540 --> 00:36:01,023
but one day he issues a fatwa
permitting interest-bearing
loans from riba-based banks.

312
00:36:01,023 --> 00:36:09,540
This is not an issue open to ijtihad.
It is a definitive matter on which
no earlier mujtahid disagreed.

313
00:36:09,540 --> 00:36:13,540
No one can say, ‘I leave my responsibility
with him; I placed my trust in him.’

314
00:36:13,540 --> 00:36:20,527
Why continue trusting him after he has
violated what the earlier scholars agreed

315
00:36:20,527 --> 00:36:29,540
upon and what is established in Allah’s
Book and the Sunnah of His Messenger,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace?

316
00:36:29,540 --> 00:36:32,973
This is not an occasion
to continue trusting him.

317
00:36:32,973 --> 00:36:38,268
It is an occasion to sever that trust
and move from seeking his fatwas

318
00:36:38,268 --> 00:36:42,540
to seeking fatwas from someone
else who is trustworthy.

319
00:36:42,540 --> 00:36:50,376
Today we have a large group of scholars
calling people to submit to tyrants
who rule by other than what Allah has

320
00:36:50,376 --> 00:36:57,361
revealed, under the pretext
that Allah—exalted is He—has commanded
obedience to those in authority.

321
00:36:57,361 --> 00:37:00,342
Are they obeyed
and trusted in this matter?

322
00:37:00,342 --> 00:37:02,898
Of course not, for no single evidence

323
00:37:02,898 --> 00:37:10,309
indicates it is permissible to submit
to a ruler who rules by anything
other than what Allah has sent down.

324
00:37:10,309 --> 00:37:14,567
Allah has named such a ruler
taghut in His Book. What is taghut?

325
00:37:14,567 --> 00:37:17,293
Any law other than Allah’s Law is taghut,

326
00:37:17,293 --> 00:37:25,129
and any ruler who governs by anything
other than what Allah has revealed is
ruling by a law other than Allah’s Law.

327
00:37:25,129 --> 00:37:27,599
He is therefore a taghut. Allah says:

328
00:37:27,599 --> 00:37:29,559
﴿ أَلَمْ تَرَ إِلَى ٱلَّذِينَ
يَزْعُمُونَ أَنَّهُمْ

329
00:37:29,559 --> 00:37:31,773
ءَامَنُوا۟ بِمَآ أُنزِلَ
إِلَيْكَ وَمَآ أُنزِلَ مِن

330
00:37:31,773 --> 00:37:34,243
قَبْلِكَ يُرِيدُونَ أَن
يَتَحَاكَمُوٓا۟ إِلَى ٱلطَّـٰغُوتِ

331
00:37:34,243 --> 00:37:36,288
وَقَدْ أُمِرُوٓا۟ أَن
يَكْفُرُوا۟ بِهِۦ وَيُرِيدُ

332
00:37:36,288 --> 00:37:38,162
ٱلشَّيْطَـٰنُ أَن يُضِلَّهُمْ
ضَلَـٰلًۢا بَعِيدًا ﴾

333
00:37:38,162 --> 00:37:45,090
‘Have you not seen those who claim
to believe in what was revealed to you
and what was revealed before you?

334
00:37:45,090 --> 00:37:50,427
They wish to seek judgement from the
taghut, though they were commanded

335
00:37:50,427 --> 00:37:54,090
to reject it. Satan wishes to
lead them far astray.’ [4:60]

336
00:37:55,090 --> 00:37:58,175
This is an explicit verse
showing that referring judgement

337
00:37:58,175 --> 00:38:03,174
to the taghut and submitting to the rule
of the taghut is far-reaching
misguidance caused by Satan.

338
00:38:03,174 --> 00:38:07,863
When a shaykh comes to you
and tells you that you must submit
to a ruler who rules by something

339
00:38:07,863 --> 00:38:13,664
other than what Allah has revealed—that
is, submit to the taghut—and calls him
one in authority, he must not be obeyed.

340
00:38:13,664 --> 00:38:19,589
Those in authority are those who rule
the Muslims by what Allah has revealed,
because these are the people whom Allah,

341
00:38:19,589 --> 00:38:23,970
Glorified and Exalted,
commanded us to obey. Allah,
Exalted is He, says—listen carefully:

342
00:38:23,970 --> 00:38:25,142
﴿ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ
يَأْمُرُكُمْ أَن تُؤَدُّوا۟

343
00:38:25,142 --> 00:38:26,562
ٱلْأَمَـٰنَـٰتِ إِلَىٰٓ
أَهْلِهَا وَإِذَا حَكَمْتُم

344
00:38:26,562 --> 00:38:27,919
بَيْنَ ٱلنَّاسِ أَن
تَحْكُمُوا۟ بِٱلْعَدْلِ ﴾

345
00:38:27,919 --> 00:38:32,424
‘Indeed, Allah commands you to deliver
trusts to their rightful owners,
and when you judge

346
00:38:32,424 --> 00:38:34,522
between people, to judge
with justice.’ [4:58]

347
00:38:34,522 --> 00:38:37,484
, and justice is the Shari’ah
of Allah, Glorified and Exalted.

348
00:38:37,484 --> 00:38:38,595
﴿ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ نِعِمَّا يَعِظُكُم بِهِۦٓ

349
00:38:38,595 --> 00:38:39,829
ۗ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ كَانَ سَمِيعًۢا بَصِيرًا ﴾

350
00:38:39,829 --> 00:38:42,482
‘Excellent indeed is what
Allah admonishes you with.

351
00:38:42,482 --> 00:38:44,642
Indeed, Allah is All-Hearing,
All-Seeing.’ [4:58]

352
00:38:44,642 --> 00:38:46,247
﴿ يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ
ءَامَنُوٓا۟ أَطِيعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ

353
00:38:46,247 --> 00:38:47,913
وَأَطِيعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَ
وَأُو۟لِى ٱلْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ ﴾

354
00:38:47,913 --> 00:38:50,319
‘O you who believe, obey
Allah, obey the Messenger

355
00:38:50,319 --> 00:38:52,171
and those in authority among you.’ [4:59]

356
00:38:52,171 --> 00:38:53,282
Here Allah, Glorified

357
00:38:53,282 --> 00:38:58,526
and Exalted, commanded obedience
to those in authority as part
of obedience to Allah and His Messenger.

358
00:38:58,526 --> 00:39:00,563
In obedience to Allah and His Messenger,

359
00:39:00,563 --> 00:39:06,487
you therefore obey the person in authority
who rules you by the Book of Allah
and the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah.

360
00:39:06,487 --> 00:39:09,449
How can obedience to someone
who rules by something other

361
00:39:09,449 --> 00:39:14,941
than what Allah has revealed be combined
with obedience to Allah and His Messenger?
Allah, Exalted is He, says:

362
00:39:14,941 --> 00:39:16,546
﴿ يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ
ءَامَنُوٓا۟ أَطِيعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ

363
00:39:16,546 --> 00:39:18,212
وَأَطِيعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَ
وَأُو۟لِى ٱلْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ ﴾

364
00:39:18,212 --> 00:39:20,618
‘O you who believe, obey
Allah, obey the Messenger

365
00:39:20,618 --> 00:39:22,470
and those in authority among you.’ [4:59]

366
00:39:22,470 --> 00:39:27,653
—meaning those in authority among you
who rule by what Allah, Exalted is He,
and His Messenger have ruled.

367
00:39:27,653 --> 00:39:29,381
﴿ أَطِيعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ
وَأَطِيعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَ وَأُو۟لِى

368
00:39:29,381 --> 00:39:30,677
ٱلْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ ۖ
فَإِن تَنَـٰزَعْتُمْ فِى

369
00:39:30,677 --> 00:39:32,035
شَىْءٍ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى
ٱللَّهِ وَٱلرَّسُولِ ﴾

370
00:39:32,035 --> 00:39:36,786
‘Obey Allah, obey the Messenger
and those in authority among you.
If you disagree over anything,

371
00:39:36,786 --> 00:39:38,761
refer it to Allah and
the Messenger.’ [4:59]

372
00:39:38,761 --> 00:39:42,278
, not to the taghut, not to a man-made
constitution and not to man-made law.

373
00:39:42,278 --> 00:39:43,821
﴿ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ
وَٱلرَّسُولِ إِن كُنتُمْ

374
00:39:43,821 --> 00:39:45,179
تُؤْمِنُونَ بِٱللَّهِ
وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْـَٔاخِرِ ﴾

375
00:39:45,179 --> 00:39:47,277
‘Refer it to Allah and
the Messenger, if you

376
00:39:47,277 --> 00:39:49,128
believe in Allah and the Last Day.’ [4:59]

377
00:39:49,128 --> 00:39:50,177
﴿ ذَٰلِكَ خَيْرٌ وَأَحْسَنُ تَأْوِيلًا ﴾

378
00:39:50,177 --> 00:39:52,090
‘That is better and
best in outcome.’ [4:59]

379
00:39:53,090 --> 00:39:56,674
When the Messenger, may Allah
bless him and grant him peace,

380
00:39:56,674 --> 00:40:03,393
commanded obedience to the ruler,
he made it conditional upon the ruler
governing by what Allah has revealed.

381
00:40:03,393 --> 00:40:07,090
Listen to this hadith narrated
by ‘Ubadah ibn al-Samit,

382
00:40:07,090 --> 00:40:12,090
may Allah be pleased with him:
«بايعنا رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم
على السمع والطاعة في يسرنا وعسرنا،

383
00:40:12,090 --> 00:40:18,251
ومنشطنا ومكرهنا، وعلى أثرة منا،
وأن لا ننازع الأمر أهله إلا أن تروا
كفراً بواحاً عندكم من الله فيه برهان» —

384
00:40:18,251 --> 00:40:23,626
‘We pledged allegiance
to the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

385
00:40:23,626 --> 00:40:30,495
to hear and obey in ease and hardship,
in what we liked and disliked, and when
others were given preference over us;

386
00:40:30,495 --> 00:40:36,468
and not to dispute authority
with those entrusted with it,
unless you see manifest disbelief for

387
00:40:36,468 --> 00:40:39,678
which you have proof from
Allah.’ [al-Bukhari, 7055–7056;

388
00:40:39,678 --> 00:40:43,262
Muslim, 1709]. What does it mean
to see manifest disbelief? It

389
00:40:43,262 --> 00:40:48,281
means that the ruler openly establishes
a law other than Allah’s Law,

390
00:40:48,281 --> 00:40:53,090
because every law other than the Law of
Allah is a law of disbelief; it is taghut.

391
00:40:53,090 --> 00:40:59,175
When a ruler governs by something other
than what Allah has revealed, he has made
manifest disbelief appear in the land.

392
00:40:59,175 --> 00:41:06,407
This includes introducing capitalist
or socialist laws, United Nations
legislation, man-made constitutions

393
00:41:06,407 --> 00:41:13,276
and laws, or convening a constituent
assembly or legislature to legislate
and then adopting that legislation.

394
00:41:13,276 --> 00:41:16,113
He has thereby established
a law of disbelief.

395
00:41:16,113 --> 00:41:22,825
This is the appearance of manifest
disbelief. In that case, obedience is not
obligatory; rather, it is impermissible.

396
00:41:22,825 --> 00:41:28,282
More than that, the Muslims are obliged to
contest the ruler’s authority and remove

397
00:41:28,282 --> 00:41:32,090
him so that they may restore
ruling by what Allah has revealed.

398
00:41:33,090 --> 00:41:37,219
This is how his statement, may
Allah bless him and grant him

399
00:41:37,219 --> 00:41:40,402
peace, is understood. In one
narration: «لا، ما صلّوا» [Muslim,

400
00:41:40,402 --> 00:41:44,101
1854] — ‘No, as long as they
pray’; and in another narration:

401
00:41:44,101 --> 00:41:46,165
«لا، ما أقاموا فيكم الصلاة»
[Muslim, 1855] — ‘No, as long as

402
00:41:46,165 --> 00:41:48,488
they establish prayer among you.’

403
00:41:48,488 --> 00:41:53,034
No, as long as they establish prayer among
you. Does prayer here mean prayer alone?

404
00:41:53,034 --> 00:41:59,327
Suppose they established prayer but
suspended zakat or suspended Hajj.

405
00:41:59,327 --> 00:42:03,456
Would they then have made
obedience obligatory upon them?

406
00:42:03,456 --> 00:42:08,627
Would they thereby have made obedience
to themselves obligatory? Certainly not.

407
00:42:08,627 --> 00:42:10,090
When the Prophet,

408
00:42:10,090 --> 00:42:18,090
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
mentions prayer here, he mentions
it as a part standing for the whole.

409
00:42:18,090 --> 00:42:22,552
Have you not seen that Abu Bakr,
may Allah be pleased with him,
said: «لأقاتلن من فرّق بين الصلاة

410
00:42:22,552 --> 00:42:25,563
والزكاة» [Muslim, 20; al-Bukhari,
1399–1400] — ‘I will fight

411
00:42:25,563 --> 00:42:29,090
whoever separates prayer from zakat’?

412
00:42:29,090 --> 00:42:37,090
Some of the Companions said to him,
‘These people have continued to pray.’
They said, ‘But they have withheld zakat.’

413
00:42:37,090 --> 00:42:42,337
And I will fight them over
a camel’s tether which they used
to give to the Messenger of Allah,

414
00:42:42,337 --> 00:42:45,090
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

415
00:42:46,090 --> 00:42:51,076
Here, the establishment of prayer is
a metaphor for establishing religion.

416
00:42:51,076 --> 00:42:59,412
This is proven by how the Prophet,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
referred to the governor sent to judge

417
00:42:59,412 --> 00:43:09,235
between people according to what Allah has
revealed as wali over prayer—that is, one
who governs them on behalf of the Imam.

418
00:43:09,235 --> 00:43:12,090
Is this Imam’s role merely
to lead people in prayer?

419
00:43:12,090 --> 00:43:18,090
No; he is called a wali over prayer
because he establishes Islam among them.

420
00:43:18,090 --> 00:43:26,090
If others are appointed, one may be
designated wali over zakat and another
over judicial matters, and so forth.

421
00:43:26,090 --> 00:43:31,541
However, the ruler entrusted
with all executive authority was
named wali over prayer—that is,

422
00:43:31,541 --> 00:43:39,900
a governor responsible for implementing
Islamic rule—so Allah, exalted is He,
described prayer in the Qur’an as faith:

423
00:43:39,900 --> 00:43:41,729
﴿ وَمَا كَانَ ٱللَّهُ
لِيُضِيعَ إِيمَـٰنَكُمْ ﴾

424
00:43:41,729 --> 00:43:45,211
‘Allah would never let your
faith go to waste.’ [2:143]

425
00:43:45,211 --> 00:43:52,090
Thus, in this hadith,
prayer is used in the statement: ‘No, as
long as they establish prayer among you.’

426
00:43:53,090 --> 00:43:57,555
This does not mean that a ruler
may spread every form of evil

427
00:43:57,555 --> 00:44:03,090
while we refrain from rising against him
simply because he establishes prayer.

428
00:44:03,090 --> 00:44:06,484
This has nothing to do with Allah’s deen.

429
00:44:06,484 --> 00:44:09,946
Suppose a ruler permits
fornication and riba,

430
00:44:09,946 --> 00:44:18,147
spreads prohibited acts and legislates
by other than what Allah has revealed,
yet still establishes prayer.

431
00:44:18,147 --> 00:44:20,972
Would obedience to him be obligatory?

432
00:44:20,972 --> 00:44:25,254
If he established prayer while
suspending zakah or Hajj,

433
00:44:25,254 --> 00:44:33,090
permitting riba or permitting fornication,
would he still be the person
in authority who must be obeyed?

434
00:44:34,090 --> 00:44:40,753
So what do ‘as long as they establish
prayer’ and ‘as long as they pray’ signify
here? They signify ruling by Islam.

435
00:44:40,753 --> 00:44:44,945
That is, as long as they rule by Islam,
obedience to them is obligatory,

436
00:44:44,945 --> 00:44:50,260
even if they act unjustly,
even if they lash your back,
even if they mistreat you, and so on.

437
00:44:50,260 --> 00:44:56,398
As long as the ruler rules by what
Allah has revealed, obedience to him
in what is right is obligatory.

438
00:44:56,398 --> 00:44:59,617
He is obeyed in what
constitutes obedience to Allah,

439
00:44:59,617 --> 00:45:05,090
Glorified and Exalted, and is not obeyed
if he commands an act of disobedience.

440
00:45:05,090 --> 00:45:10,090
But as long as he rules by what
Allah has revealed, it is not
permissible to rebel against him.

441
00:45:10,090 --> 00:45:16,311
He remains the person in authority
even if he mistreats people,
acts unjustly and falls short, and so on.

442
00:45:16,311 --> 00:45:22,525
When he acts unjustly, falls short,
mistreats people or makes a mistake,
he must be denounced verbally,

443
00:45:22,525 --> 00:45:29,861
and his case must be brought before the
Court of Injustices in obedience to the
command of Allah, Glorified and Exalted:

444
00:45:29,861 --> 00:45:31,807
﴿ فَإِن تَنَـٰزَعْتُمْ فِى
شَىْءٍ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ

445
00:45:31,807 --> 00:45:34,053
وَٱلرَّسُولِ إِن كُنتُمْ
تُؤْمِنُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ

446
00:45:34,053 --> 00:45:34,427
ٱلْـَٔاخِرِ ﴾

447
00:45:34,427 --> 00:45:37,796
‘If you disagree over anything,
refer it to Allah and the

448
00:45:37,796 --> 00:45:41,090
Messenger, if you believe in
Allah and the Last Day.’ [4:59]

449
00:45:42,090 --> 00:45:46,090
As long as the ruler declares that he
governs by what Allah has revealed,

450
00:45:46,090 --> 00:45:51,799
and the Shari’ah by which he governs is
Allah’s Shari’ah, he remains the person
in authority, even if he falls short,

451
00:45:51,799 --> 00:45:56,090
mistreats people, acts unjustly or at
times unjustly lashes their backs.

452
00:45:56,090 --> 00:46:00,407
In that case, he is held to account
through speech and his actions
are denounced verbally;

453
00:46:00,407 --> 00:46:02,090
he is not opposed with the sword.

454
00:46:03,090 --> 00:46:09,237
But if he rules by other than what Allah
has revealed, he has manifested open kufr.
He then cannot be the Muslims’ ruler.

455
00:46:09,237 --> 00:46:14,090
Moreover, work to remove him
becomes obligatory, to restore
rule by what Allah has revealed.

456
00:46:15,090 --> 00:46:23,027
Shaykhs today who say that obedience to
the ruler is obligatory regardless of his
conduct are neither obeyed nor followed.

457
00:46:23,027 --> 00:46:27,696
Some went so far as to say that Bremer
was the Muslims’ person in authority,

458
00:46:27,696 --> 00:46:33,532
and that whoever Bremer
appointed was the Muslims’ person
in authority and had to be obeyed.

459
00:46:33,532 --> 00:46:40,090
They also said that those who rose
against Bashar’s regime in Syria had
rebelled against the person in authority,

460
00:46:40,090 --> 00:46:44,426
and that those who rose against
Gaddafi had done the same.

461
00:46:44,426 --> 00:46:46,605
This fatwa alone is enough to show

462
00:46:46,605 --> 00:46:53,842
that such shaykhs are not trustworthy
references to whom one turns for fatwas
or to learn Shari’ah legal rulings.

463
00:46:53,842 --> 00:46:57,343
It is enough to destroy
confidence in their knowledge,

464
00:46:57,343 --> 00:47:02,090
so one stops seeking their fatwas
and instead asks and learns from others.

465
00:47:03,090 --> 00:47:10,690
Brother Abdullah asks:
if a lay Muslim learns from his shaykh
that a particular scholar is ignorant,

466
00:47:10,690 --> 00:47:16,090
or that there is a flaw in his creed
because, as the shaykh claims,

467
00:47:16,090 --> 00:47:25,381
it does not conform to the methodology
of the Salaf, does imitating his shaykh
discharge his obligation before Allah?

468
00:47:25,381 --> 00:47:34,067
If not, what should he do? I have said
before, dear brothers, that imitation
in matters of creed is impermissible.

469
00:47:34,067 --> 00:47:41,691
You therefore cannot rely upon
a shaykh’s claim that a particular
person or group follows bid‘ah

470
00:47:41,691 --> 00:47:49,590
and that their creed
contradicts the Islamic creed,
the creed of the Salaf or the like.

471
00:47:49,590 --> 00:47:58,090
By imitating him, you declare one person’s
creed corrupt and another person’s
creed corrupt solely through imitation.

472
00:47:58,090 --> 00:48:05,527
Shari’ah legal rulings are learned
from muftis and teachers so
that one may follow the mujtahids,

473
00:48:05,527 --> 00:48:09,966
but only in Shari’ah legal
rulings that require ijtihad.

474
00:48:09,966 --> 00:48:18,090
If you want to know whether a particular
person holds the true creed,
return to the Islamic creed itself.

475
00:48:18,090 --> 00:48:23,090
Do not content yourself
with imitating one person or another.

476
00:48:24,090 --> 00:48:31,938
How often have some shaykhs issued a fatwa
that a particular person is an innovator?

477
00:48:31,938 --> 00:48:41,150
Someone listens to them, follows them
and simply accepts their statement:
‘So-and-so is an innovator.’

478
00:48:41,150 --> 00:48:48,202
Then, if he returns to that person’s
books or listens to what he actually says,

479
00:48:48,202 --> 00:48:57,414
he finds that his shaykh has
spoken presumptuously about him,
falsely accused him and wronged him.

480
00:48:57,414 --> 00:49:03,101
Why return to your shaykh to ask
about another person’s creed,

481
00:49:03,101 --> 00:49:14,090
iman or madhhab when that person has
his own books, views and lectures in which
he expresses his opinion directly?

482
00:49:14,090 --> 00:49:17,090
Why go to your shaykh to ask about him?

483
00:49:18,090 --> 00:49:27,090
How often have some shaykhs falsely
accused others? Let me take you
deep into history, dear brothers.

484
00:49:27,090 --> 00:49:28,090
You know Abu Hanifa,

485
00:49:28,090 --> 00:49:37,090
that towering figure whose madhhab
was—and still is—followed by millions,
indeed hundreds of millions, of Muslims.

486
00:49:37,090 --> 00:49:44,177
What campaign did many shaykhs,
scholars and jurists wage against him?

487
00:49:44,177 --> 00:49:49,090
The works written about
this remain preserved to this day.

488
00:49:49,090 --> 00:49:55,029
Abu Hanifa was branded a Magian,
a heretic, an innovator and much else.

489
00:49:55,029 --> 00:50:01,090
Had people continued listening
to those who falsely accused Abu Hanifa,

490
00:50:01,090 --> 00:50:09,951
he would still be regarded today as
a heretic, an innovator, a deviant
and a person with a corrupt creed.

491
00:50:09,951 --> 00:50:16,090
All that happened was that someone
took it upon himself to tell people,

492
00:50:16,090 --> 00:50:20,908
‘So-and-so says such-and-such,’
although that claim was false.

493
00:50:20,908 --> 00:50:30,090
Had they returned to his own words
and books, they would have found that he
did not say what they had been told.

494
00:50:31,090 --> 00:50:37,628
A shaykh may come to you today and say,
‘So-and-so’s creed is corrupt;
he holds the position of the Mu‘tazilah.’

495
00:50:37,628 --> 00:50:43,063
You then go to that person,
listen to him and find that he does
not hold the Mu‘tazilah’s position.

496
00:50:43,063 --> 00:50:50,546
This alone should be enough for you
to lose confidence in the person who
told you that his creed was Mu‘tazili.

497
00:50:50,546 --> 00:50:54,359
Likewise, a shaykh may tell you,
‘Every Ash‘ari is an innovator.’

498
00:50:54,359 --> 00:51:01,131
You may disagree with the Ash‘aris,
as we did in earlier halaqaat, but
that does not mean that you may dismiss

499
00:51:01,131 --> 00:51:07,512
the integrity of al-Nawawi,
al-‘Asqalani and other leading scholars
of fiqh and call them innovators.

500
00:51:07,512 --> 00:51:13,090
You have every right to say,
‘I am not convinced by the Ash‘aris’
position on this or that issue,

501
00:51:13,090 --> 00:51:16,540
and I am not convinced
by their theological method.’

502
00:51:16,540 --> 00:51:23,933
But that does not mean that we dismiss
the integrity of al-Nawawi, al-‘Asqalani
and others merely because a fanatical

503
00:51:23,933 --> 00:51:29,090
shaykh tells you that all Ash‘aris
are innovators and that all
of them are in the Fire.

504
00:51:29,090 --> 00:51:36,090
Such a person claims that one group alone
is upon the truth and that everything else
is false: whatever he says is the truth,

505
00:51:36,090 --> 00:51:44,090
he is among those who will be saved,
and anyone who disagrees with him
on subsidiary questions is an innovator.

506
00:51:45,090 --> 00:51:48,090
This is a grave affliction
from which we suffer today.

507
00:51:48,090 --> 00:51:52,410
A group of shaykhs adopts a particular
position on theological questions

508
00:51:52,410 --> 00:51:57,130
and then declares that anyone
who disagrees with them has
a corrupt creed and is in the Fire.

509
00:51:57,130 --> 00:52:04,358
In this way, Imams, scholars, mujtahids,
jurists and even Muslim leaders whom we
hold in the highest regard are dismissed

510
00:52:04,358 --> 00:52:11,090
and sent to the Fire merely because
they disagreed on subsidiary questions
that scholars have debated for many years.

511
00:52:11,090 --> 00:52:15,090
Thus Salah al-Din al-Ayyubi is
dismissed because he was Ash‘ari,

512
00:52:15,090 --> 00:52:20,090
and Sultan Muhammad al-Fatih is
dismissed because he may have been Sufi,
Ash‘ari or Maturidi, and so on.

513
00:52:20,090 --> 00:52:22,866
People are stripped
wholesale of integrity,

514
00:52:22,866 --> 00:52:27,907
trustworthiness and iman,
placed among the misguided sects
and expelled from the saved

515
00:52:27,907 --> 00:52:35,090
group solely because they differed with
these shaykhs on subsidiary questions that
scholars have discussed for many years.

516
00:52:36,090 --> 00:52:41,476
You may not imitate a shaykh
in these matters, nor may you
take such questions from shaykhs.

517
00:52:41,476 --> 00:52:45,260
If you trust a shaykh, then learn
Shari’ah legal rulings from him.

518
00:52:45,260 --> 00:52:50,647
But if you want to know
the condition of a particular person,
return to that person himself.

519
00:52:50,647 --> 00:52:55,090
Ask him directly, read what he has
written and listen to what he has said.

520
00:52:55,090 --> 00:52:59,090
In this way, you become a person who
respects his own thought and reason.

521
00:53:00,090 --> 00:53:07,090
As for suspending your intellect so
that you always think with someone else’s
mind, this is not praiseworthy imitation;

522
00:53:07,090 --> 00:53:09,345
it is blameworthy imitation.

523
00:53:09,345 --> 00:53:16,324
It means cancelling your own intellect
and treating everything a particular
person or shaykh says as correct.

524
00:53:16,324 --> 00:53:22,014
Allah, Glorified and Exalted,
has made the Muslim one of the most
elevated people in thought.

525
00:53:22,014 --> 00:53:25,090
O Muslim, Allah has described
you as a follower of the truth,

526
00:53:25,090 --> 00:53:33,090
so you may not imprison yourself in the
cage of a particular shaykh and return
to him whenever you want to know anything.

527
00:53:34,090 --> 00:53:41,057
Imitation is of mujtahids, not muftis, and
it is restricted to Shari’ah legal rulings
that require ijtihad and in which you

528
00:53:41,057 --> 00:53:43,704
lack the ability to perform
ijtihad yourself.

529
00:53:43,704 --> 00:53:45,515
Only here does imitation apply.

530
00:53:45,515 --> 00:53:48,441
In these matters,
one seeks a fatwa in order to reach,

531
00:53:48,441 --> 00:53:53,179
through asking the mufti,
the Shari’ah legal ruling
derived by one of the mujtahids.

532
00:53:53,179 --> 00:53:57,149
But if you make the mufti control
your intellect in every area of life,

533
00:53:57,149 --> 00:54:00,424
so that you hate whomever he hates,
love whomever he loves,

534
00:54:00,424 --> 00:54:07,112
elevate whomever he elevates and lower
whomever he lowers, you have degraded
both your humanity and your intellect.

535
00:54:07,112 --> 00:54:11,919
Allah, Glorified and Exalted,
made the intellect the basis
of legal responsibility.

536
00:54:11,919 --> 00:54:16,168
On the Day of Resurrection, you will
be questioned before Allah because He

537
00:54:16,168 --> 00:54:22,090
gave you an intellect with which
to think—not because you thought
with the mind of one person or another.

538
00:54:23,090 --> 00:54:27,090
The Muslims must free
themselves from this affliction.

539
00:54:27,090 --> 00:54:32,552
It does not befit them; it befits only
degraded and declining nations: a person

540
00:54:32,552 --> 00:54:40,380
appoints a shaykh to guide him even
in matters of his own profession, although
the shaykh has no expertise in it.

541
00:54:40,380 --> 00:54:47,090
Unfortunately, this is one
of the afflictions that struck
the Ummah during periods of decline.

542
00:54:48,090 --> 00:54:50,853
Dear brothers, we shall
conclude today’s questions here.

543
00:54:50,853 --> 00:54:55,898
I ask Allah, Glorified and Exalted,
to teach us what benefits us,
benefit us through what He has taught us,

544
00:54:55,898 --> 00:55:00,282
increase us in knowledge and deeds,
and make our actions sincere
for His Noble Face alone.

545
00:55:00,282 --> 00:55:05,448
I send prayers and peace upon
the Messenger of Allah, his family,
his Companions and those who support him.

546
00:55:05,448 --> 00:55:08,090
May the peace, mercy and blessings
of Allah be upon you.
