1
00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:09,703
Peace be upon you, mercy and blessings
of Allah. In the name of Allah,
the Most Merciful, the Most Compassionate.

2
00:00:09,703 --> 00:00:17,913
All praise is due to Allah,
and peace and blessings be upon
His Messenger, his family, companions,

3
00:00:17,913 --> 00:00:19,915
and those who follow them in truth.

4
00:00:19,915 --> 00:00:27,880
Dear brothers, welcome to another
session of Halaqa Online.
We continue discussing the Sunnah.

5
00:00:29,080 --> 00:00:38,341
We discussed the definition of the Sunnah
and its authority as the second source
of legislation after the Book of Allah,

6
00:00:38,341 --> 00:00:40,493
glorified and exalted be He.

7
00:00:40,493 --> 00:00:48,911
We established the authority of the Sunnah
and dispelled the misconceptions
of those who call for limiting

8
00:00:48,911 --> 00:00:57,331
oneself to the Qur’an—the Book of Allah,
exalted be He—and claim that there is
no revelation other than the Qur’an.

9
00:00:57,331 --> 00:01:02,195
We proved with definitive evidence
that the Prophetic Sunnah,

10
00:01:02,195 --> 00:01:08,556
about which he, may Allah bless him and
grant him peace, said, «أُوتِيتُ القرآنَ
ومثلَه معه»—“I was given the Qur’an and

11
00:01:08,556 --> 00:01:13,046
something like it along with it”
[see Sunan Abi Dawud, 4604]—is

12
00:01:13,046 --> 00:01:20,600
revelation from Allah, exalted be He,
and a source of legislation
just like the Noble Qur’an.

13
00:01:20,600 --> 00:01:22,120
We discussed this in detail.

14
00:01:22,120 --> 00:01:27,324
To complete this topic today,
I would like to address some

15
00:01:27,324 --> 00:01:35,340
objections raised by those who
doubt the Sunnah and seek its
exclusion as a source of legislation.

16
00:01:35,340 --> 00:01:44,660
These are doubts they raise—doubts
that we would not have engaged with had
it not been for their agitation.

17
00:01:44,660 --> 00:01:56,331
They are thoroughly discussed in
specialised books, particularly in works
on the science of hadith terminology.

18
00:01:56,331 --> 00:02:06,295
However, since this matter is being
heavily scrutinised by doubters
of Islamic Shari’ah who aim to dismantle

19
00:02:06,295 --> 00:02:15,485
most of its legal rulings and abolish
them entirely, I intend to briefly
touch upon some of the issues

20
00:02:15,485 --> 00:02:25,560
and objections they raise concerning
the Sunnah—specifically regarding
the transmission of noble hadiths.

21
00:02:25,560 --> 00:02:37,380
They question whether the hadith heritage
in our hands has been transmitted
correctly from the Messenger of Allah,

22
00:02:37,380 --> 00:02:41,014
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

23
00:02:41,014 --> 00:02:50,552
After denying that the Prophet’s words,
actions and tacit approvals
are a source of legislation,

24
00:02:50,552 --> 00:02:54,500
they deny that they represent revelation.

25
00:02:54,500 --> 00:03:05,040
To continue their attack on the Prophetic
Sunnah, they therefore began
attacking the hadith heritage.

26
00:03:05,040 --> 00:03:13,560
Among the issues they raise about
what has been transmitted to us
and compiled in the Sahih collections,

27
00:03:13,560 --> 00:03:22,361
the Sunan works and hadith books generally
is the question of when the reports
were transmitted or written down.

28
00:03:22,361 --> 00:03:28,165
Most of the hadiths we read today
were compiled in the third century AH.

29
00:03:28,165 --> 00:03:37,158
They ask: How can we trust
that hadiths attributed to the Prophet,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

30
00:03:37,158 --> 00:03:45,436
are authentic after more than two
and a half centuries have passed—and
in the case of some books slightly longer?

31
00:03:45,436 --> 00:03:54,900
Or further still: how can we believe
that what was recorded approximately two
and a half centuries, or three centuries,

32
00:03:54,900 --> 00:04:02,051
after the time of the Prophet,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
actually reflects words spoken by him?

33
00:04:02,051 --> 00:04:11,293
Some resort to exaggeration,
relying on ordinary people’s limited
knowledge of Islamic history,

34
00:04:11,293 --> 00:04:15,977
hadith terminology and how
the hadiths were transmitted.

35
00:04:15,977 --> 00:04:23,140
They claim that the hadiths were recorded
only after the time of the Prophet,

36
00:04:23,140 --> 00:04:28,759
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
then the time of the Rightly
Guided Caliphs,

37
00:04:28,759 --> 00:04:39,000
followed by the Umayyad caliphs
and the Umayyad Caliphate, all the way
to the beginning of the Abbasid Caliphate.

38
00:04:39,000 --> 00:04:42,907
They depict many eras and generations
passing before authors

39
00:04:42,907 --> 00:04:52,469
appeared and wrote down reports that they
attributed to the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

40
00:04:52,469 --> 00:04:57,250
Some even go so far as to count
the caliphs who succeeded one

41
00:04:57,250 --> 00:05:03,104
another from the Prophet’s death until
the period of hadith compilation.

42
00:05:03,104 --> 00:05:11,496
They say: First came the periods
of the four Rightly Guided Caliphs,
then all the Umayyad caliphs, and so on.

43
00:05:11,496 --> 00:05:19,573
This gives people the false impression
that many eras and generations
separated the time of the Prophet,

44
00:05:19,573 --> 00:05:26,620
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
from the writing
and compilation of hadith.

45
00:05:26,620 --> 00:05:30,672
The truth is that this constitutes
a form of deception—indeed,

46
00:05:30,672 --> 00:05:36,440
more than mere deception; it is
a deliberate distortion and fabrication.

47
00:05:36,440 --> 00:05:42,033
The issue at stake is not how many
years have passed nor what number
of caliphs succeeded one another.

48
00:05:42,033 --> 00:05:45,846
A caliph’s reign might last months,
a year, or just a few years.

49
00:05:45,846 --> 00:05:48,944
Nor does the matter
concern which eras elapsed

50
00:05:48,944 --> 00:05:56,780
from the time of the Prophet may Allah
bless him and grant him peace through
that of the Rightly Guided Caliphs,

51
00:05:56,780 --> 00:06:00,940
then to the Umayyad era, and onward—this
is not what we are addressing here.

52
00:06:00,940 --> 00:06:14,564
The real question is simply this: through
which generations was the noble Prophetic
hadith transmitted before it was compiled?

53
00:06:14,564 --> 00:06:24,846
Dear brothers, compilation
took place by receiving reports
from the Followers of the Followers.

54
00:06:24,846 --> 00:06:33,069
In other words, the hadith passed through
three generations before it was compiled.

55
00:06:33,069 --> 00:06:43,371
The overwhelming majority of hadiths
were compiled through reports
from the Followers of the Followers,

56
00:06:43,371 --> 00:06:58,000
from the Followers, from the Companions
who narrated from the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

57
00:06:58,000 --> 00:06:59,220
Three generations.

58
00:06:59,220 --> 00:07:09,316
The sceptic relies on people’s
limited knowledge and leads
them to imagine that many eras

59
00:07:09,316 --> 00:07:22,040
and generations had passed and that the
chain he calls fabricated and imaginary
consists of a long series of narrators.

60
00:07:22,040 --> 00:07:28,391
The fact is that the period in which
the hadiths were compiled was the time
of the Followers of the Followers.

61
00:07:28,391 --> 00:07:31,674
This was the generation—or qarn,
as it is called in Arabic.

62
00:07:31,674 --> 00:07:33,387
In the original Arabic usage,

63
00:07:33,387 --> 00:07:39,025
a qarn does not mean one hundred years,
as it does by present-day convention;
it means a generation.

64
00:07:39,025 --> 00:07:42,522
The Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant
him peace, said, «خير الناس قرني»—“The

65
00:07:42,522 --> 00:07:48,040
best people are my generation”—meaning the
Companions; «ثم الذين يلونهم»—“then those
who follow them”—meaning the Followers;

66
00:07:48,040 --> 00:07:52,586
«ثم الذين يلونهم»—“then
those who follow them”—meaning
the Followers of the Followers;

67
00:07:52,586 --> 00:07:55,226
and «ثم يفشو الكذب بعد ذلك»—“then
lying will become widespread after

68
00:07:55,226 --> 00:07:58,509
that” [see Sahih al-Bukhari,
6695; Sahih Muslim, 2536]. Notice

69
00:07:58,509 --> 00:08:05,289
that the compilation took place through
receiving reports from the generation
of the Followers of the Followers,

70
00:08:05,289 --> 00:08:07,216
who narrated from the Followers.

71
00:08:07,216 --> 00:08:09,714
They, in turn, narrated
from the Companions,

72
00:08:09,714 --> 00:08:15,780
who transmitted what they had
heard from the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

73
00:08:15,780 --> 00:08:23,565
It is therefore not as they lead
people to believe—that the Prophetic
heritage was written down

74
00:08:23,565 --> 00:08:33,518
after many eras and generations had passed
since the time of the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

75
00:08:33,518 --> 00:08:33,715
No.

76
00:08:33,715 --> 00:08:36,869
Any one of you can open Sahih al-Bukhari,

77
00:08:36,869 --> 00:08:45,934
Sahih Muslim, Sunan al-Tirmidhi,
Musnad Imam Ahmad or another collection
and examine the chain of transmission.

78
00:08:45,934 --> 00:08:50,960
You will find that the narrators
belong to these generations.

79
00:08:50,960 --> 00:08:56,415
Yes, the chain may include more than
three narrators because a Successor

80
00:08:56,415 --> 00:09:04,599
to the Successors might transmit
from someone in his own generation among
them, who relates from a Successor.

81
00:09:04,599 --> 00:09:11,328
That Successor, in turn, might
relate from one of his contemporaries
among the Successors,

82
00:09:11,328 --> 00:09:18,511
who transmits from a Companion
of the Messenger of Allah may Allah
bless him and grant him peace.

83
00:09:18,511 --> 00:09:26,604
Thus sometimes the chain is
limited—directly connected: one Successor
to the Successors narrates from one

84
00:09:26,604 --> 00:09:35,242
Successor, who relates from one Companion,
who transmitted from the Prophet may
Allah bless him and grant him peace.

85
00:09:35,242 --> 00:09:39,515
Consequently, it is not as
some suggest that a long period

86
00:09:39,515 --> 00:09:48,245
separates those who recorded hadiths
from the time of the Messenger of Allah
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

87
00:09:48,245 --> 00:09:54,700
There are no intervening
centuries or generations between
them—this is the key point.

88
00:09:54,700 --> 00:09:57,250
The most important aspect—and

89
00:09:57,250 --> 00:10:07,348
the one we have mentioned in previous
sessions—is that transmission was never
confined merely to naming the narrators.

90
00:10:07,348 --> 00:10:16,500
Rather, strict conditions were imposed
on the chain connecting the compiler
back to the Messenger of Allah,

91
00:10:16,500 --> 00:10:19,689
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

92
00:10:19,689 --> 00:10:22,851
These are fundamental requirements

93
00:10:22,851 --> 00:10:32,660
distinct from those pertaining to the
hadith text itself and form part of what
is known as critical hadith analysis.

94
00:10:32,660 --> 00:10:40,905
As previously noted,
an authentic transmission must have
an unbroken chain from beginning to end.

95
00:10:40,905 --> 00:10:49,268
The compiler must be connected
to the Follower of the Followers
who transmitted to him, that person

96
00:10:49,268 --> 00:10:59,571
to the narrator above him, and so on until
the chain reaches the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

97
00:10:59,571 --> 00:11:04,160
The chain must be fully
connected without interruption.

98
00:11:04,160 --> 00:11:09,062
And that each one of these narrators
must be attested as trustworthy (thiqah).

99
00:11:09,062 --> 00:11:21,474
What does this term mean here? Certainly,
it is not what people might assume—that
we attribute infallibility to them.

100
00:11:21,474 --> 00:11:23,634
If they were infallible, there would have

101
00:11:23,634 --> 00:11:31,038
been no need for the science
of narrator criticism and accreditation
(al-jarh wa al-ta’dil),

102
00:11:31,038 --> 00:11:41,180
nor for studies on narrators that examine
their biographies in detail to determine
whether each was trustworthy or not.

103
00:11:41,180 --> 00:11:43,740
A trustworthy narrator is upright.

104
00:11:43,740 --> 00:11:49,360
Uprightness does not mean that a person is
infallible or has never committed a sin:
«كُلُّ ابْنِ آدَمَ خَطَّاءٌ،

105
00:11:49,360 --> 00:11:53,726
وَخَيْرُ الْخَطَّائِينَ
التَّوَّابُونَ»—“Every son of Adam
commits sins, and the best of

106
00:11:53,726 --> 00:11:57,667
those who commit sins are those
who repent” [al-Tirmidhi, 2499].

107
00:11:57,667 --> 00:12:02,480
No one is infallible except
the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

108
00:12:02,480 --> 00:12:09,971
Upright means that the person is
not known for immorality or lying
and is not known for anything

109
00:12:09,971 --> 00:12:15,260
that undermines honourable conduct;
he displays none of the traits
that undermine it.

110
00:12:15,260 --> 00:12:19,960
In addition to uprightness,
he must possess precision:

111
00:12:19,960 --> 00:12:25,300
he must be known to transmit hadith well
and to memorise and transmit accurately.

112
00:12:25,300 --> 00:12:29,300
If it is established that he
does not transmit accurately,

113
00:12:29,300 --> 00:12:34,982
that he becomes confused
while transmitting, forgets
and unintentionally distorts the report,

114
00:12:34,982 --> 00:12:42,140
or transmits it incorrectly,
he is excluded from the trustworthy
narrators from whom hadiths are accepted.

115
00:12:42,140 --> 00:12:50,316
Whoever examines the science
of hadith terminology will see how
scholars meticulously scrutinised

116
00:12:50,316 --> 00:13:00,140
these individuals, classifying them into
ranks: the highest layer being the most
trusted, followed by those below in rank.

117
00:13:00,140 --> 00:13:07,920
They categorised narrators between
those who deviated and those who
generally conformed, and so on.

118
00:13:07,920 --> 00:13:16,537
Through their rigorous examination of
these matters, they established principles
no other nation has ever applied within

119
00:13:16,537 --> 00:13:21,138
its cultural heritage—principles
that elevate the transmission

120
00:13:21,138 --> 00:13:29,003
of hadith to an exceptionally high level
of trustworthiness, even if it does
not reach definitive certainty (qat’i).

121
00:13:29,003 --> 00:13:31,740
As previously mentioned,

122
00:13:31,740 --> 00:13:39,460
definitive authenticity is unnecessary
for Shari’ah rulings and even for reports
that are not foundational to the religion.

123
00:13:39,460 --> 00:13:50,540
Scholars made an immense effort
to filter weak reports from hadith
through the science of transmission,

124
00:13:50,540 --> 00:13:56,060
but their work was not limited
to examining the chain of transmission.

125
00:13:56,060 --> 00:14:02,360
An authentic hadith has a continuous
chain in which every narrator,

126
00:14:02,360 --> 00:14:09,607
from the beginning of the chain
to its end, is upright and precise.

127
00:14:09,607 --> 00:14:16,016
It must also be neither irregular
nor affected by a hidden defect.

128
00:14:16,016 --> 00:14:26,929
An irregular report is one in which
someone narrates the same hadith
in a way that differs from other,

129
00:14:26,929 --> 00:14:28,478
more reliable narrations.

130
00:14:28,478 --> 00:14:33,819
That divergence can undermine
its authenticity even

131
00:14:33,819 --> 00:14:41,760
when examination of its chain
otherwise fulfils all the conditions.

132
00:14:41,760 --> 00:14:43,670
The hadith scholars therefore

133
00:14:43,670 --> 00:14:53,640
also required that a hadith contain
no irregularity and no defect
that undermines its authenticity.

134
00:14:53,640 --> 00:14:58,720
The defect may lie in the matn—the
text of the noble hadith itself.

135
00:14:58,720 --> 00:15:08,229
If, for example, a hadith conflicts
with verses from Allah’s Book that are
definitive in meaning—we say definitive

136
00:15:08,229 --> 00:15:16,922
in meaning, not in confirmation,
because the entire Qur’an is definitive
in confirmation—and the conflict

137
00:15:16,922 --> 00:15:27,860
cannot be reconciled with the Qur’an’s
definitive meanings, this constitutes
a defect for which the hadith is rejected.

138
00:15:27,860 --> 00:15:35,080
It has, for example,
been narrated from the Prophet,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

139
00:15:35,080 --> 00:15:37,807
that he said: “Allah,
glorified and exalted be He,

140
00:15:37,807 --> 00:15:46,600
provides for His servant in proportion
to his effort”—or words to that effect:
in proportion to his striving.

141
00:15:46,600 --> 00:15:56,235
This hadith is rejected outright—not only
because its chain of transmission fails to
meet the conditions for authenticity—but

142
00:15:56,235 --> 00:15:59,280
also due to its content alone.

143
00:15:59,280 --> 00:16:07,416
Scholars relied on this meaning to reject
it, as the Qur’an contains definitive
verses with clear indication that Allah,

144
00:16:07,416 --> 00:16:14,506
exalted is He, is the Provider
(Ar-Razzaq), and provision does not
depend upon a servant’s striving.

145
00:16:14,506 --> 00:16:19,051
A person may be provided while
striving or without striving;

146
00:16:19,051 --> 00:16:25,596
they may be denied provision
even if they strive,
or granted it without any effort at all.

147
00:16:25,596 --> 00:16:31,595
This content alone suffices to reject
this hadith, for its meaning contradicts

148
00:16:31,595 --> 00:16:40,140
the definitive verses of the Qur’an—so
much so that scholars of transmission
(muḥaddithūn) have indeed rejected it.

149
00:16:40,140 --> 00:16:49,500
I am not now listing examples,
as they would be lengthy;
each of us can consult hadith books.

150
00:16:49,500 --> 00:16:53,480
Here I refer to a valuable
work in this field:

151
00:16:53,480 --> 00:17:01,920
Manhaj al-Naqd fi ‘Ulum al-Hadith
by Shaykh Nur ad-Din ‘Itr, which is
highly regarded in this discipline.

152
00:17:01,920 --> 00:17:11,480
Dear brothers, no other nation
has known efforts like those made
by Muslim scholars in this field.

153
00:17:11,480 --> 00:17:22,100
The sceptics may say: “That is merely
what you Muslims say, because you insist
on relying on the Prophetic Sunnah.”

154
00:17:22,100 --> 00:17:30,640
The truth, however, is that objective
and fair non-Muslim researchers
have also recorded these facts.

155
00:17:30,640 --> 00:17:40,820
With complete confidence and clarity,
I have brought one of the finest
examples of this today.

156
00:17:40,820 --> 00:17:51,800
He was a professor specialising in history
who had studied at American universities
and lived in the twentieth century.

157
00:17:51,800 --> 00:18:03,000
He died in 1965. He was a Christian,
not a Muslim, from the Mount Lebanon
region, and his name was Asad Rustum.

158
00:18:03,000 --> 00:18:10,360
He wrote—and authored—a book outlining
methodology for historical writing,

159
00:18:10,360 --> 00:18:21,240
verifying reports of history,
and distinguishing between authentic
and unauthentic historical accounts.

160
00:18:21,240 --> 00:18:29,920
So deeply impressed was he by the science
of hadith terminology that he
titled his work Mustalah al-Tarikh.

161
00:18:29,920 --> 00:18:39,294
This book remains taught to this day;
it is still studied
in universities—though not Islamic

162
00:18:39,294 --> 00:18:50,400
ones—for they possess their own extensive
works on hadith terminology, rendering
reliance on this text unnecessary.

163
00:18:50,400 --> 00:18:59,160
However, this book is taught at
universities concerned with history—that
is, in university history departments.

164
00:18:59,160 --> 00:19:03,000
Personally, when I studied history
at the Lebanese University,

165
00:19:03,000 --> 00:19:09,320
Asad Rustum’s book Mustalah al-Tarikh
was among the works on my syllabus.

166
00:19:09,320 --> 00:19:17,440
Listen, I will read an excerpt
from the introduction to Professor
Asad Rustum’s book Mustalah al-Tarikh.

167
00:19:17,440 --> 00:19:24,800
He says: ‘I immersed myself
in studying books on terminology
and collected most of them.

168
00:19:24,800 --> 00:19:32,560
The more knowledge I gained about them,
the greater my admiration
for their authors became.

169
00:19:32,560 --> 00:19:35,704
I still recall an incident

170
00:19:35,704 --> 00:19:46,237
that occurred to me in 1936 in Damascus
when the Syrian government celebrated a
thousand years since al-Mutanabbi’s death.

171
00:19:46,237 --> 00:19:57,360
I was among those who arrived at the
Umayyad capital to commemorate the poet of
the Arabs and stayed there for some time,

172
00:19:57,360 --> 00:20:01,880
during which I examined manuscripts
in the Zahiriyah Library.’

173
00:20:01,880 --> 00:20:04,155
As soon as I began working,

174
00:20:04,155 --> 00:20:13,473
I realised that I was confronted
with the greatest collection of books
on Prophetic hadith in the world.

175
00:20:13,473 --> 00:20:19,360
Within this library’s archives are
numerous master manuscripts in this field,

176
00:20:19,360 --> 00:20:25,440
some bearing the handwriting
of leading authorities in hadith.

177
00:20:25,440 --> 00:20:35,143
Among what I found there was an ancient
copy of a treatise on the science
of hadith terminology by Qadi Iyad,

178
00:20:35,143 --> 00:20:37,308
who died in 544 AH.

179
00:20:37,308 --> 00:20:41,209
The copy had been made
by his nephew in 595 AH.

180
00:20:41,209 --> 00:20:47,493
I had previously read about the work
in some treatises on terminology,

181
00:20:47,493 --> 00:20:53,560
so I copied it and began studying
it and understanding its meanings.

182
00:20:53,560 --> 00:20:59,004
It is therefore among the most
valuable works written on its subject,

183
00:20:59,004 --> 00:21:06,358
and through it al-Qadi Iyad rose
to the highest levels of scholarship
and precision in his age.

184
00:21:06,358 --> 00:21:14,570
In fact—and these are still Asad
Rustum’s words—not even the leading
historians of Europe and America are

185
00:21:14,570 --> 00:21:24,120
capable of writing anything better than it
in some respects, despite seven centuries
having passed since it was written.

186
00:21:24,120 --> 00:21:33,115
The precision of thought and deduction
it displays under the heading “Verifying
the Report and Establishing the Wording”

187
00:21:33,115 --> 00:21:40,942
matches what appears on the same subject
in the most important European works
from Germany, France, America and England.

188
00:21:40,942 --> 00:21:44,693
We have quoted extensively from Qadi

189
00:21:44,693 --> 00:21:53,420
Iyad’s discussion of this subject in the
chapter of our book entitled “Verifying
the Text and Establishing the Wording”.

190
00:21:53,420 --> 00:21:57,874
I am reading directly from Asad
Rustum’s Mustalah al-Tarikh.

191
00:21:57,874 --> 00:22:06,874
At the beginning of his introduction, he
wrote the following with complete clarity:
«The first to organise the criticism

192
00:22:06,874 --> 00:22:15,020
of historical reports and establish
rules for it were the scholars
of the Islamic religion.

193
00:22:15,020 --> 00:22:20,238
They were compelled to pay
close attention to the Prophet’s
words and actions in order

194
00:22:20,238 --> 00:22:24,601
to understand the Qur’an and
administer justice. They said:

195
00:22:24,601 --> 00:22:25,874
﴿ إِنْ هُوَ إِلَّا وَحْىٌۭ يُوحَىٰ ﴾

196
00:22:25,874 --> 00:22:29,056
“It is nothing but
revelation revealed.” [53:4]

197
00:22:29,056 --> 00:22:35,328
What was recited from him is the Qur’an,
and what was not recited
from him is the Sunnah.

198
00:22:35,328 --> 00:22:42,600
They therefore set about collecting,
studying and scrutinising the hadiths,
thereby enriching

199
00:22:42,600 --> 00:22:51,510
the discipline of history with rules whose
foundations and essence remain respected
in academic circles to this day.»

200
00:22:51,510 --> 00:23:00,691
These are the words of a distinguished
historian, testifying to the science of
hadith terminology and to the immense role

201
00:23:00,691 --> 00:23:09,600
it played in scrutinising the reports
transmitted from the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

202
00:23:13,600 --> 00:23:16,038
I have answered one objection.

203
00:23:16,038 --> 00:23:25,260
I am not setting out everything
that distinguishes the science of hadith
terminology, for it is a vast discipline.

204
00:23:25,260 --> 00:23:31,400
I am now answering another objection they
raise about hadiths and their sources.

205
00:23:31,400 --> 00:23:40,000
This is extremely important, and the
subject must be examined carefully because
it is unknown even to many Muslims.

206
00:23:40,000 --> 00:23:49,440
When they hear the sceptics,
they become confused; some are surprised
and unsettled by the Prophetic heritage.

207
00:23:49,440 --> 00:23:51,151
As is well known,

208
00:23:51,151 --> 00:23:59,760
there are hundreds of thousands of hadith
reports from the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

209
00:23:59,760 --> 00:24:06,172
Anyone hearing this may naturally
be surprised and wonder: How could

210
00:24:06,172 --> 00:24:16,120
hundreds of thousands of hadiths have been
transmitted from the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace?

211
00:24:16,120 --> 00:24:26,266
It is reported of Imam al-Bukhari—although
he did not write this in his own
books—that he compiled his work after

212
00:24:26,266 --> 00:24:37,750
examining six hundred thousand hadiths, or
that he selected from six hundred thousand
hadiths narrated from the Messenger

213
00:24:37,750 --> 00:24:47,450
of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant
him peace, when he compiled al-Jami
al-Sahih, known as Sahih al-Bukhari.

214
00:24:47,450 --> 00:24:50,500
The sceptics then ask how
the Messenger of Allah,

215
00:24:50,500 --> 00:25:00,695
whose prophethood lasted twenty-three
years, could have narrated
six hundred thousand hadiths.

216
00:25:00,695 --> 00:25:09,360
They count the days of his prophethood,
subtract the nights
and the hours spent sleeping,

217
00:25:09,360 --> 00:25:21,020
working and so on, and then calculate
how many hours he could have spent
conveying these hadiths to his Companions.

218
00:25:21,020 --> 00:25:24,020
They conclude that the hours
of the Prophet’s life,

219
00:25:24,020 --> 00:25:34,500
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
would not have been enough for him to
utter all these hadiths, let alone more.

220
00:25:34,500 --> 00:25:48,230
How could al-Bukhari collect six hundred
thousand hadiths and then select the ones
he included in his book known as Sahih

221
00:25:48,230 --> 00:25:54,271
al-Bukhari, which contains
fewer than three thousand?

222
00:25:54,271 --> 00:25:57,340
Where did he get them from?

223
00:25:57,340 --> 00:26:08,000
There is, of course,
some deception in this claim. Let me
quickly refute or disprove that last idea.

224
00:26:08,000 --> 00:26:18,860
They attribute to al-Bukhari the claim
that he gathered these hadiths and then
selected from what he had gathered.

225
00:26:18,860 --> 00:26:20,720
Al-Bukhari did not say that.

226
00:26:20,720 --> 00:26:30,020
He said that he selected
these hadiths from six hundred
thousand that existed in his time,

227
00:26:30,020 --> 00:26:32,900
many of which had already
been written down.

228
00:26:32,900 --> 00:26:35,720
Here, another point must be made.

229
00:26:35,720 --> 00:26:41,948
Those who cast doubt create
the impression—often while
knowing the facts themselves—that

230
00:26:41,948 --> 00:26:50,840
hadith was first written down in the time
of Imam Ahmad, al-Bukhari and Muslim,
whose hadith collections we consult today.

231
00:26:50,840 --> 00:26:56,360
They rely on people’s ignorance and lead
them to believe something that is untrue.

232
00:26:56,360 --> 00:27:05,877
The hadiths of the Prophet,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
began to be written during his lifetime,

233
00:27:05,877 --> 00:27:11,220
although compilation was not
widespread either in his time
or in the time of the Companions.

234
00:27:11,220 --> 00:27:14,420
It is true that the Messenger of Allah,

235
00:27:14,420 --> 00:27:21,500
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
is reported to have prohibited writing
hadith, saying, «لا تكتبوا عني إلا القرآن،

236
00:27:21,500 --> 00:27:28,623
ومن كتب عني غير القرآن فليمحه»—“Do not
write anything from me except the Qur’an,
and whoever has written

237
00:27:28,623 --> 00:27:32,833
anything from me other than the
Qur’an should erase it” [see

238
00:27:32,833 --> 00:27:36,954
Sahih Muslim, 3004]. But it is
also established that he, may

239
00:27:36,954 --> 00:27:44,927
Allah bless him and grant him peace,
permitted hadith to be written and,
in some cases, ordered it to be written.

240
00:27:44,927 --> 00:27:50,840
The command and prohibition have been
reconciled in a completely clear manner.

241
00:27:50,840 --> 00:27:57,689
He prohibited the writing of hadith
when writing it could cause it
to be confused with the Qur’an.

242
00:27:57,689 --> 00:28:04,452
At that time, he was keen
for the Qur’an to be recorded without
being confused with anything else,

243
00:28:04,452 --> 00:28:08,683
especially his own hadith,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

244
00:28:08,683 --> 00:28:15,982
When the circumstances ensured
that the writing of hadith would
not be confused with the Qur’an,

245
00:28:15,982 --> 00:28:18,060
he permitted the writing of the Qur’an.

246
00:28:18,060 --> 00:28:19,900
There are hadiths concerning this.

247
00:28:19,900 --> 00:28:27,859
In any event, after the time
of the Companions had passed
and the era of the Followers had begun,

248
00:28:27,859 --> 00:28:33,582
increasing numbers of people started
collecting and writing down the hadiths.

249
00:28:33,582 --> 00:28:39,650
Al-Bukhari—and before him Imam Ahmad,
and others before him—as
well as Muslim, Ibn Majah,

250
00:28:39,650 --> 00:28:48,060
al-Tirmidhi and the rest were therefore
not the first people to compile hadiths,
contrary to what some people imagine.

251
00:28:48,060 --> 00:28:58,029
These scholars took upon themselves the
task of collecting hadiths from their time
that had been transmitted orally to them.

252
00:28:58,029 --> 00:29:03,113
They recorded both
these oral transmissions
and those already written down;

253
00:29:03,113 --> 00:29:11,065
some of their teachers would
pass on to them manuscripts
containing noble traditions.

254
00:29:11,065 --> 00:29:13,480
We know that books of hadith existed,

255
00:29:13,480 --> 00:29:21,700
as well as major works in jurisprudence
composed before this period
of systematic recording began.

256
00:29:21,700 --> 00:29:23,526
This jurisprudence

257
00:29:23,526 --> 00:29:32,345
was based upon the Book of Allah Most
High and the Sunnah of His Messenger
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

258
00:29:32,345 --> 00:29:40,380
Imam al-Shafi‘i—who passed away early in
the third century AH, in 205 AH—had works
recorded from him: al-Umm and ar-Risalah.

259
00:29:40,380 --> 00:29:47,682
If we read al-Umm,
which is a book of jurisprudence
by al-Shafi‘i, we find it filled

260
00:29:47,682 --> 00:29:56,980
with hundreds of hadiths about the Prophet
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
for he relied upon them as evidence.

261
00:29:56,980 --> 00:30:04,388
Hadiths were already present among
jurists, who used them as legal
evidence and transmitted them orally.

262
00:30:04,388 --> 00:30:10,263
Some traditions circulated
by word of mouth alone,
while most were recorded—either

263
00:30:10,263 --> 00:30:18,864
in dedicated manuscripts for hadith
compilation or within the jurisprudential
works that scholars had begun to author.

264
00:30:18,864 --> 00:30:24,980
Imam Malik composed al-Muwatta’,
which serves today as
a primary reference for hadith.

265
00:30:24,980 --> 00:30:28,980
However, he wrote it fundamentally
as a book of jurisprudence,

266
00:30:28,980 --> 00:30:35,080
arranging the traditions according
to legal topics based on fiqh chapters.

267
00:30:35,080 --> 00:30:42,789
Thus, the hadith was already widespread
and in circulation among people. Then
came the work of the famous compilers.

268
00:30:42,789 --> 00:30:48,546
The greatest and most authentic of these
works was the book of Imam al-Bukhari,

269
00:30:48,546 --> 00:30:54,200
followed by that of his student Muslim,
and then the other books.

270
00:30:54,200 --> 00:31:02,220
Some had been compiled before al-Bukhari
and Muslim, while others were compiled
afterwards and carried the work forward.

271
00:31:02,220 --> 00:31:11,853
The difference between al-Bukhari
and Muslim, on the one hand, and the other
books, on the other, is that al-Bukhari

272
00:31:11,853 --> 00:31:20,180
and Muslim, may Allah have mercy on them,
followed a very strict method when
compiling and selecting hadiths.

273
00:31:20,180 --> 00:31:26,675
They confined themselves
to hadiths of the highest strength.

274
00:31:26,675 --> 00:31:36,414
They were extremely meticulous when
assessing narrators, the form and
precision of the chain of transmission,

275
00:31:36,414 --> 00:31:42,872
whether a narrator’s report agreed
with those of other narrators, and so on.

276
00:31:42,872 --> 00:31:53,882
Al-Bukhari and Muslim were meticulous in
applying hadith terminology when selecting
narrators and chains of transmission

277
00:31:53,882 --> 00:31:59,705
and in examining the content
of the hadith through critical study.

278
00:31:59,705 --> 00:32:04,787
After Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih
Muslim had been compiled,

279
00:32:04,787 --> 00:32:12,640
scholars examined these two
collections thoroughly and subjected
them to extensive study.

280
00:32:12,640 --> 00:32:21,937
They concluded that the two books
represented the highest level
of precision in transmitting hadith.

281
00:32:21,937 --> 00:32:32,100
The majority of scholars therefore
agreed that almost everything contained
in al-Bukhari and Muslim is authentic.

282
00:32:32,100 --> 00:32:42,100
Everything contained in al-Bukhari
and Muslim is authentic—not out of
reverence or elevation for their persons,

283
00:32:42,100 --> 00:32:46,056
nor because they were
granted infallibility.

284
00:32:46,056 --> 00:32:50,240
Their status alone does
not account for it.

285
00:32:50,240 --> 00:32:54,440
Before them stood scholars
of even greater eminence:

286
00:32:54,440 --> 00:33:04,060
Imam al-Shafi‘i, Imam Malik, and Imam
Ahmad—these luminaries are stars in the
Islamic world, society, and culture.

287
00:33:04,060 --> 00:33:13,820
But why did al-Bukhari’s book—and
by extension Muslim’s—become the two
most authentic hadith collections?

288
00:33:13,820 --> 00:33:20,940
It was said that after Allah’s Book,
these are the next two most
authentic works of human authorship:

289
00:33:20,940 --> 00:33:24,360
those of al-Bukhari and then Muslim.

290
00:33:24,360 --> 00:33:28,964
This occurred after al-Bukhari
and Muslim compiled their books,

291
00:33:28,964 --> 00:33:35,720
when jurists, scholars,
and specialists in the science
of hadith terminology examined them.

292
00:33:35,720 --> 00:33:43,620
They found within them an unparalleled
precision and strictness in accepting
or verifying and scrutinising hadiths,

293
00:33:43,620 --> 00:33:46,600
ruling that these were authentic.

294
00:33:46,600 --> 00:33:55,804
For this reason, when classifying hadiths
by their strength, those reported by both
al-Bukhari and Muslim occupy the first

295
00:33:55,804 --> 00:34:05,434
rank; then what al-Bukhari alone reported
comes next in the second rank, followed by
what Muslim alone reported in the third.

296
00:34:05,434 --> 00:34:11,386
Then come those recorded
according to al-Bukhari’s
and Muslim’s conditions, followed

297
00:34:11,386 --> 00:34:19,380
by those written according to al-Bukhari’s
conditions and then those written and
compiled according to Muslim’s conditions.

298
00:34:19,380 --> 00:34:25,692
Thus, a precise standard and filter
emerged, providing a very high

299
00:34:25,692 --> 00:34:34,440
degree of purity in selecting authentic
hadiths from the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

300
00:34:34,440 --> 00:34:39,872
I now return to the claim about
the enormous number of hadiths.

301
00:34:39,872 --> 00:34:48,180
The claim attributed to Imam
al-Bukhari—that he collected six
hundred thousand hadiths—is false.

302
00:34:48,180 --> 00:34:49,671
He said that he

303
00:34:49,671 --> 00:34:59,460
selected and recorded from six hundred
thousand hadiths that existed in his time
when compiling al-Jami al-Sahih.

304
00:34:59,460 --> 00:35:05,620
But we must also pause over
the meaning of this number.

305
00:35:05,620 --> 00:35:10,868
When people hear of six hundred thousand
hadiths, or see the numbers found

306
00:35:10,868 --> 00:35:20,880
today in the books of the pure Sunnah
and noble hadith, they form a mistaken
impression about what is being counted.

307
00:35:20,880 --> 00:35:22,663
Now, we have—meaning

308
00:35:22,663 --> 00:35:32,340
most importantly—that the majority of
hadiths we derive for matters of fiqh and
beyond come from fourteen books in order:

309
00:35:32,340 --> 00:35:45,060
al-Bukhari and Muslim lead, followed
by four others known as ‘the six’ or ‘the
group’, then two more, making eight.

310
00:35:45,060 --> 00:35:49,800
Beyond these, there is generally
a limited number of other
reference works on hadiths.

311
00:35:49,800 --> 00:35:59,224
If we gather the narrations
within these books,
we find tens of thousands—indeed over

312
00:35:59,224 --> 00:36:08,980
hundreds of thousands—of reports
about the Messenger of Allah may
Allah bless him and grant him peace.

313
00:36:08,980 --> 00:36:16,390
But pay attention to this point:
those tens or even hundreds
of thousands ultimately

314
00:36:16,390 --> 00:36:26,040
reduce to a few thousand distinct
hadiths transmitted from the Prophet
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

315
00:36:26,040 --> 00:36:28,540
What is meant by this?

316
00:36:28,540 --> 00:36:34,130
Hadith scholars classify each
report as separate ahadith when it
reaches them from multiple sources.

317
00:36:34,130 --> 00:36:37,820
If a single tradition comes
to them from two transmitters,

318
00:36:37,820 --> 00:36:42,876
they categorise it as two ahadith;
if from three, then three ahadith;
and if from ten, then ten ahadith—even

319
00:36:42,876 --> 00:36:49,381
though it remains one single hadith
concerning the Messenger of Allah may
Allah bless him and grant him peace.

320
00:36:49,381 --> 00:36:51,947
As time progresses and narrators multiply,

321
00:36:51,947 --> 00:36:58,980
initially the Companions would transmit
from the Messenger of Allah may
Allah bless him and grant him peace:

322
00:36:58,980 --> 00:37:05,948
a single Companion might relate it alone,
or two, three, four—or even
more—of his Companions would do so.

323
00:37:05,948 --> 00:37:11,042
We know that some ahadith are classified
under mass transmission (tawatur),

324
00:37:11,042 --> 00:37:16,546
meaning they were transmitted continuously
since the top of their chain—that is,

325
00:37:16,546 --> 00:37:23,940
from the Companions who heard them
directly—and thus certain ahadith were
narrated by a group of Companions.

326
00:37:24,080 --> 00:37:31,542
From this starting point, each report is
classified as a hadith: every Companion’s
report from the Messenger of Allah,

327
00:37:31,542 --> 00:37:35,818
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
is classified as one hadith.

328
00:37:35,818 --> 00:37:39,782
Umar’s report from the Messenger
of Allah is called one hadith,

329
00:37:39,782 --> 00:37:43,902
while Abu Hurayrah’s report
of the same hadith is called another.

330
00:37:43,902 --> 00:37:49,032
That makes two. Ibn Umar’s report from the
Messenger of Allah is likewise a hadith.

331
00:37:49,032 --> 00:37:52,919
The count therefore increases
with the number of narrators.

332
00:37:52,919 --> 00:37:58,438
Imagine how this multiplies afterwards:
the Followers narrated
from the Companions,

333
00:37:58,438 --> 00:38:04,190
and each Companion was not necessarily
narrated from by only one Follower,
but by several.

334
00:38:04,190 --> 00:38:11,186
Every Follower’s report is counted as
a hadith. Imagine how many Followers
would narrate from each Companion.

335
00:38:11,186 --> 00:38:18,260
The number of reports from the Messenger
of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant
him peace, therefore increases.

336
00:38:18,260 --> 00:38:24,919
In the terminology of hadith scholars, all
these transmissions are called hadiths.

337
00:38:24,919 --> 00:38:33,607
The hadiths are counted according
to the number of narrations, not
according to the number of distinct texts.

338
00:38:33,607 --> 00:38:35,923
In the following generation,

339
00:38:35,923 --> 00:38:43,741
the Followers of the Followers
would in turn transmit the hadiths
narrated by the many Followers.

340
00:38:43,741 --> 00:38:52,620
A still greater number of Followers
of the Followers would transmit them
because each succeeding generation

341
00:38:52,620 --> 00:38:55,902
was larger and contained more narrators.

342
00:38:55,902 --> 00:39:01,500
A single hadith would therefore
acquire many routes of transmission.

343
00:39:01,500 --> 00:39:05,526
These numerous transmission
routes—through which a single hadith

344
00:39:05,526 --> 00:39:11,061
may be narrated via dozens
of distinct paths—are collectively
referred to as ahadith (plural).

345
00:39:11,061 --> 00:39:18,394
Consequently, once hundreds of thousands
of these transmissions reached the hands
of the scholars of hadith (muhaddithun),

346
00:39:18,394 --> 00:39:24,720
they represented hundreds of thousands
of reports converging upon a fixed
number of individual hadiths.

347
00:39:24,720 --> 00:39:27,860
Is this number unknown?
Is it an obscure secret? No.

348
00:39:27,860 --> 00:39:35,960
Earlier scholars stated that the authentic
hadiths of the Messenger of Allah,

349
00:39:35,960 --> 00:39:44,441
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
number no more than four thousand,
or perhaps slightly over four thousand.

350
00:39:44,441 --> 00:39:48,923
This is a perfectly natural
number—perfectly natural.

351
00:39:48,923 --> 00:39:55,197
I will now show you how modern research
has found even this number to be lower,

352
00:39:55,197 --> 00:39:59,480
and I will present the
matter clearly and precisely.

353
00:39:59,480 --> 00:40:08,094
Today, all our hadith sources
have been brought together,
and modern tools—computers

354
00:40:08,094 --> 00:40:18,800
and so on—have made it easier to consult
them, count the hadiths, sift through
them and perform similar work.

355
00:40:18,800 --> 00:40:26,953
Here I will give an example of excellent
work by a distinguished researcher.

356
00:40:26,953 --> 00:40:33,813
I believe his name is Salih Ahmad
al-Shami—or Ahmad Salih al-Shami.

357
00:40:33,813 --> 00:40:44,166
He authored a compilation entitled
Ma‘alim al-Hadith al-Sharif
or Ma‘alim al-Sunnah al-Nabawiyyah.

358
00:40:44,166 --> 00:40:46,884
What did he do in this book?

359
00:40:46,884 --> 00:40:56,332
He collected material from fourteen
sources of Prophetic hadith,
including al-Bukhari,

360
00:40:56,332 --> 00:41:07,980
Muslim, the Musnad of Imam Ahmad,
Abu Dawud, al-Nasa’i, Ibn Majah, al-Hakim
and others—a large collection of sources.

361
00:41:07,980 --> 00:41:16,909
These fourteen hadith sources
are so comprehensive that hardly
any hadith of the Prophet,

362
00:41:16,909 --> 00:41:22,504
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
lies outside them.

363
00:41:22,504 --> 00:41:31,790
If we find a hadith in another reference,
we will generally also find
it in these fourteen books.

364
00:41:31,790 --> 00:41:40,600
What did the author do?
He created a collection of the hadiths
contained in all these works.

365
00:41:40,600 --> 00:41:50,123
When the same hadith was repeated
in al-Bukhari, Muslim, Sunan Abi Dawud,
Musnad Imam Ahmad, al-Nasa’i,

366
00:41:50,123 --> 00:42:00,600
Ibn Majah, al-Hakim and elsewhere,
he brought those occurrences together
and recorded the hadith only once.

367
00:42:00,600 --> 00:42:08,263
However, he said that he did not
count a hadith narrated by two
Companions as only one hadith.

368
00:42:08,263 --> 00:42:17,561
When a hadith was narrated by two,
three or four Companions, he counted
each Companion’s narration as a separate

369
00:42:17,561 --> 00:42:27,676
hadith, even when all of them narrated the
same hadith from the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

370
00:42:27,676 --> 00:42:32,069
His book therefore still
contains some repetition.

371
00:42:32,069 --> 00:42:36,769
The same hadith might be
narrated by Umar ibn al-Khattab,

372
00:42:36,769 --> 00:42:43,615
may Allah be pleased with him,
and also by Abu Hurayrah,
Ibn Umar, Ibn Abbas or others.

373
00:42:43,615 --> 00:42:50,460
He counted these narrations of the same
hadith separately and included them all.

374
00:42:50,460 --> 00:42:53,840
However, he did not record repeated
narrations from generations

375
00:42:53,840 --> 00:42:57,847
after the Companions—those transmitted
by Successors or successors to them.

376
00:42:57,847 --> 00:43:04,107
A hadith narrated by a Companion directly
from the Prophet may Allah bless him and
grant him peace was recorded only once.

377
00:43:04,107 --> 00:43:05,421
And as mentioned earlier,

378
00:43:05,421 --> 00:43:11,180
there are hadiths reported by multiple
Companions from the Prophet; he
included all their versions in his work.

379
00:43:11,180 --> 00:43:16,115
What, then, was the total number of
these hadiths? Fewer than four thousand.

380
00:43:16,115 --> 00:43:24,092
This is the heritage of the Messenger of
Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him
peace. In fact, the number is lower still.

381
00:43:24,092 --> 00:43:30,178
If we remove the repetition
among the Companions’ narrations
from the Messenger of Allah,

382
00:43:30,178 --> 00:43:36,511
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
it falls considerably—perhaps
by hundreds of hadiths.

383
00:43:36,511 --> 00:43:41,610
We are therefore dealing with a little
over three thousand hadiths at most.

384
00:43:41,610 --> 00:43:46,792
These are the hadiths of the Messenger
of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant

385
00:43:46,792 --> 00:43:55,180
him peace—not the hundreds of thousands
of distinct hadith texts people are led to
imagine were actually narrated from him.

386
00:43:55,180 --> 00:44:02,800
Here is a very important point:
once counted, these hadiths do
not even reach four thousand.

387
00:44:02,800 --> 00:44:09,580
This should be made clear to those who
attack hadith, especially those who
target al-Bukhari and Muslim.

388
00:44:09,580 --> 00:44:14,960
They know that Muslims regard
Sahih al-Bukhari and then Sahih
Muslim as the most authentic books.

389
00:44:14,960 --> 00:44:18,346
If they undermine al-Bukhari,

390
00:44:18,346 --> 00:44:25,480
they undermine the entire Sunnah
of the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

391
00:44:25,480 --> 00:44:30,440
Fifty-five per cent
of these hadiths are found in Sahih
al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim.

392
00:44:30,440 --> 00:44:36,747
We are speaking, of course,
about the authentic hadiths,
after the weak ones have been excluded

393
00:44:36,747 --> 00:44:44,440
from this collection of the hadiths of the
Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him
and grant him peace, that has reached us.

394
00:44:44,440 --> 00:44:51,011
Fifty-five per cent of these hadiths
are contained in the two Sahih
collections of al-Bukhari and Muslim.

395
00:44:51,011 --> 00:44:53,220
Do you now recognise their value?

396
00:44:53,220 --> 00:44:57,406
If we add the fifty-five percent
of these hadiths that were

397
00:44:57,406 --> 00:45:06,388
documented in Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih
Muslim—the collection encompassed by those
two books—and further include what was

398
00:45:06,388 --> 00:45:15,021
gathered and recorded according to the
conditions set by al-Bukhari and Muslim,
then most of the hadiths we possess will

399
00:45:15,021 --> 00:45:21,300
be at the highest level
of authenticity established
by Imam al-Bukhari and Imam Muslim.

400
00:45:21,300 --> 00:45:22,820
Do not let these liars,

401
00:45:22,820 --> 00:45:30,280
who seek to make Muslims doubt the
heritage of their Prophet, may Allah bless
him and grant him peace, deceive you.

402
00:45:30,280 --> 00:45:38,520
They ask: How could the number of the
Prophet’s hadiths be small in the time
of the Companions and the Followers,

403
00:45:38,520 --> 00:45:44,580
then grow and multiply in the time
of the Followers of the Followers,
when compilation began?

404
00:45:44,580 --> 00:45:49,340
Is a spring not strongest at its
source—its flow most abundant there?

405
00:45:49,340 --> 00:45:53,900
How, then, could hadith become
more numerous in later generations?

406
00:45:53,900 --> 00:45:59,620
This argument relies on Muslims’ limited
knowledge and perhaps their ignorance.

407
00:45:59,620 --> 00:46:04,137
We do not even know whether the person
making it understands the matter.

408
00:46:04,137 --> 00:46:09,500
He boasts, speaks pretentiously to people
and presents himself as a researcher,

409
00:46:09,500 --> 00:46:14,680
editor and meticulous scholar,
saying: “This proves
that these reports are fabricated.

410
00:46:14,680 --> 00:46:21,280
How could the hadiths have
multiplied centuries after
the time of the Messenger of Allah,

411
00:46:21,280 --> 00:46:24,360
may Allah bless him and grant him peace?”

412
00:46:24,360 --> 00:46:32,620
The hadiths themselves did not multiply;
the number of their narrations increased
as the number of narrators grew over time.

413
00:46:32,620 --> 00:46:39,360
If each generation contains more
narrators than the preceding one,
and each generation transmits to the next,

414
00:46:39,360 --> 00:46:44,980
the number of narrations of the same
hadiths naturally expands.

415
00:46:44,980 --> 00:46:50,448
It is not as the sceptics say:
“Where did hundreds of thousands
of hadiths of the Messenger of Allah,

416
00:46:50,448 --> 00:46:58,248
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
come from in the third century when their
number was much smaller in the first?”

417
00:46:58,248 --> 00:47:01,540
Either these people are ignorant
intruders into this discipline,

418
00:47:01,540 --> 00:47:06,860
or they are liars who know the truth
but want to mislead people.

419
00:47:06,860 --> 00:47:11,654
These are the hadiths
of the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace:

420
00:47:11,654 --> 00:47:16,650
several thousand established
through authentic routes,
with the weak reports excluded

421
00:47:16,650 --> 00:47:23,063
according to the precise and remarkable
science of hadith terminology, the like
of which no other nation has known.

422
00:47:23,063 --> 00:47:29,208
The hadiths of the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
therefore form a rich and immense

423
00:47:29,208 --> 00:47:35,757
body of material that produced the
broadest and greatest Shari’ah in history,
because it rests on the two revelations:

424
00:47:35,757 --> 00:47:41,019
the Book of Allah, exalted be He,
and the Sunnah of His Messenger,
may Allah bless him and grant him

425
00:47:41,019 --> 00:47:41,853
peace.

426
00:47:41,853 --> 00:47:48,556
This is my response to some of the doubts
repeated by those who call themselves
People of the Qur’an or Quranists,

427
00:47:48,556 --> 00:47:51,180
as well as by those who doubt
the Prophetic tradition.

428
00:47:51,180 --> 00:47:57,082
Unfortunately, it is not only these
individuals who launch campaigns against

429
00:47:57,082 --> 00:48:03,340
al-Bukhari and Muslim to cast
doubt on the source and authority
of the Prophetic tradition;

430
00:48:03,340 --> 00:48:09,754
there is also a massive effort
from some who operate from sectarian
backgrounds—meaning they claim to be

431
00:48:09,754 --> 00:48:15,820
Muslims, acknowledge, and affirm that
the two primary sources for legislation
are indeed the Book and the Sunnah.

432
00:48:15,820 --> 00:48:23,520
Yet they seek to undermine this vast
heritage because it does not align
with their school of thought.

433
00:48:23,520 --> 00:48:29,815
They eagerly adopted these fallacies
from secularists and liars
against Allah’s religion,

434
00:48:29,815 --> 00:48:37,260
using them to vent their sectarian
frustrations by repeating such
claims about al-Bukhari and Muslim.

435
00:48:37,260 --> 00:48:41,163
Yet this criticism does not apply
only to al-Bukhari and Muslim;

436
00:48:41,163 --> 00:48:49,363
it extends to every scholar engaged
in the Prophetic legacy—whether those who
exercised rigorous precision in hadith

437
00:48:49,363 --> 00:48:56,900
scrutiny like al-Bukhari and Muslim,
or others whose works were filled
with fabricated, false, and weak reports.

438
00:48:56,900 --> 00:49:05,216
Dear brothers, I have devoted this halaqa
to the subject because I know how
dangerous and fierce this attack

439
00:49:05,216 --> 00:49:13,345
is and what it seeks to achieve:
to destroy Muslims’ trust in their
Prophetic heritage and the noble hadith.

440
00:49:13,345 --> 00:49:17,899
Its aim is to open the way to removing
three-quarters of the Shari’ah,

441
00:49:17,899 --> 00:49:26,425
because most of its details come
from the hadiths of the Prophet,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

442
00:49:26,425 --> 00:49:32,120
We know that the Qur’an contains
the broad outlines and foundations.

443
00:49:32,120 --> 00:49:39,880
As I mentioned in an earlier halaqa,
the Prophetic Sunnah came to clarify,
specify and explain them, and so on.

444
00:49:39,880 --> 00:49:45,761
I ask Allah, the Exalted,
to frustrate the schemes of these people,
turning their plots against them,

445
00:49:45,761 --> 00:49:53,280
and causing them to fail utterly in this
world before the Hereafter—so that they
fall into ruin while all can see.

446
00:49:53,280 --> 00:49:58,260
I also ask Allah, the Exalted,
to enlighten the minds of Muslims
with Islamic culture, His Book,

447
00:49:58,260 --> 00:50:04,641
and the noble legacy of their Prophet
through his authentic hadiths may
Allah bless him and grant him peace—and

448
00:50:04,641 --> 00:50:08,707
thus restore this magnificent
edifice as a beacon for all humanity:

449
00:50:08,707 --> 00:50:13,920
legislation governing Muslim life
while carrying a message to the world.

450
00:50:13,920 --> 00:50:18,800
I send prayers upon the Messenger
of Allah, his family, his Companions,
and those who follow them.

451
00:50:18,800 --> 00:50:27,380
A brother named al-Abid from Jerusalem
asks about recent calls to authenticate
and filter the noble hadiths.

452
00:50:27,380 --> 00:50:35,171
Strangely, those making these calls are
followers of Salafism, who call day and
night for the Sunnah to be authenticated.

453
00:50:35,171 --> 00:50:40,649
Will what has already been
authenticated be authenticated again,

454
00:50:40,649 --> 00:50:45,843
or will what they previously classified
as weak now become authentic?

455
00:50:45,843 --> 00:50:50,768
Do you not see in such calls a veiled
attack on the Prophetic Sunnah?

456
00:50:50,768 --> 00:50:54,860
My dear brother,
regardless of whom you are referring to,

457
00:50:54,860 --> 00:51:03,120
the effort to authenticate hadiths
or classify them as weak has never
been confined to a particular period.

458
00:51:03,120 --> 00:51:10,440
Earlier scholars certainly made immense
efforts to examine which hadiths
were authentic and which were weak,

459
00:51:10,440 --> 00:51:16,020
but that does not mean the work has
ended or its door has been closed.

460
00:51:16,020 --> 00:51:19,960
Examining this matter is
comparable to ijtihad.

461
00:51:19,960 --> 00:51:31,200
Just as the door of ijtihad
may not be closed in any age,
and there must be mujtahids in every age,

462
00:51:31,200 --> 00:51:41,280
so too may no one close the door
to filtering and scrutinising hadiths
and examining whether they are authentic.

463
00:51:41,280 --> 00:51:53,320
This is especially so because
hadith scholars continue to disagree
about a proportion of the hadiths.

464
00:51:53,320 --> 00:51:59,540
We know that there is broad
agreement about a very large
proportion of the hadiths:

465
00:51:59,540 --> 00:52:03,189
this one is authentic
and that one is weak.

466
00:52:03,189 --> 00:52:08,800
But there is disagreement even over
some applications of these rules.

467
00:52:08,800 --> 00:52:17,121
The hasan hadith, for example,
is accepted by jurists, yet one scholar
may classify a particular hadith as

468
00:52:17,121 --> 00:52:24,820
hasan while another considers
that it has not reached that level
and classifies it as weak.

469
00:52:24,820 --> 00:52:27,952
Just as mujtahids continue
to differ in their ijtihad,

470
00:52:27,952 --> 00:52:35,503
scholars who study hadith terminology and
examine hadiths also continue to differ.

471
00:52:35,503 --> 00:52:38,700
They are entitled to state
their conclusions:

472
00:52:38,700 --> 00:52:46,920
one authenticates a hadith while
another does not; one calls it
hasan while another calls it weak.

473
00:52:46,920 --> 00:52:56,381
Yet here, we must note that some have
gone too far in dismissing the hadith
classified as hasan (good)—the

474
00:52:56,381 --> 00:53:06,240
very type relied upon by jurists in their
foundational works of jurisprudence,
such as those of al-Shafi‘i and Malik.

475
00:53:06,240 --> 00:53:18,116
This hadith does not fully meet all the
criteria of a sahih (authentic) tradition
regarding meticulous scrutiny of its

476
00:53:18,116 --> 00:53:28,816
chain; some argue that major jurists’
reliance on it elevates it to the rank
of hasan hadith, one worthy of acceptance.

477
00:53:28,816 --> 00:53:33,771
Others have exaggerated
in weakening these reports,

478
00:53:33,771 --> 00:53:44,020
excluding them from the realm
of accepted transmissions and severing
their connection with authentic ones.

479
00:53:44,020 --> 00:53:46,160
In any event, this remains an open field.

480
00:53:46,160 --> 00:53:51,860
There are still scholars examining
hadiths, and scholars in every
age will continue to do so.

481
00:53:51,860 --> 00:53:58,100
They are entitled to differ over
the authenticity or weakness
of particular hadiths.

482
00:53:58,100 --> 00:54:05,240
Brother Abd al-Fattah al-Najjar asks:
“You know that a hadith has more
than one version from its narrators,

483
00:54:05,240 --> 00:54:09,020
so how do we settle on one version
that establishes the point at issue?”

484
00:54:09,020 --> 00:54:13,037
The question is not
entirely clear, of course.

485
00:54:13,037 --> 00:54:14,680
As far as I can understand it,

486
00:54:14,680 --> 00:54:21,298
the questioner is asking:
when a hadith has more than one narration,
how do we adopt one of them?

487
00:54:21,298 --> 00:54:25,140
Multiple narrations do not
all take the same form.

488
00:54:25,140 --> 00:54:31,062
Sometimes a single hadith is
narrated through more than one
route and the narrations match.

489
00:54:31,062 --> 00:54:36,236
At other times, there is a slight
difference in the wording and expressions.

490
00:54:36,236 --> 00:54:42,578
Take, for example,
the hadith of the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

491
00:54:42,578 --> 00:54:46,480
narrated by al-Bukhari and Muslim:
«كانت بنو إسرائيل تسوسهم
الأنبياء كلما هلك نبي خلفه نبي،

492
00:54:46,480 --> 00:54:52,758
وإنه لا نبي من بعد وستكون خلفاء
فتكثر»—“The Children of Israel
were governed by the prophets.

493
00:54:52,758 --> 00:54:56,220
Whenever one prophet died,
another succeeded him.

494
00:54:56,220 --> 00:55:02,800
There will be no prophet after me,
but there will be caliphs,
and they will be many.”

495
00:55:02,800 --> 00:55:07,779
This is al-Bukhari’s narration. Imam
Muslim’s narration says: «وسيكون خلفاء
فيكثرون»—“There will be caliphs, and they

496
00:55:07,779 --> 00:55:11,617
will become many” [see Sahih
al-Bukhari, 3455; Sahih Muslim,

497
00:55:11,617 --> 00:55:15,539
1842]. This does not mean... The
wording differs slightly, and

498
00:55:15,539 --> 00:55:20,380
we know that it is permissible
to narrate a hadith by meaning, provided

499
00:55:20,380 --> 00:55:28,140
the person transmitting it knows the
language and does not alter the meaning
by narrating it in different words.

500
00:55:28,140 --> 00:55:34,480
When several narrations
reinforce the same meaning,
there is no real conflict between them.

501
00:55:34,480 --> 00:55:40,276
But when the differences between
narrations lead to differences in content,
number or another matter,

502
00:55:40,276 --> 00:55:42,220
the scholars apply preference.

503
00:55:42,220 --> 00:55:47,513
This belongs to the science
of hadith terminology,
and the scholars have rules for it.

504
00:55:47,513 --> 00:55:51,131
If we were to discuss those rules now,
we would never finish.

505
00:55:51,131 --> 00:55:54,599
The science of hadith
terminology is recorded in large

506
00:55:54,599 --> 00:55:58,820
and extensive works containing
many examples that one can consult.

507
00:55:58,820 --> 00:56:03,380
What do the scholars do, then? First,
they try to reconcile the narrations.

508
00:56:03,380 --> 00:56:10,900
This follows the well-known principle:
applying a statement is
preferable to disregarding it.

509
00:56:10,900 --> 00:56:14,780
If the two narrations can be reconciled
in some way, both are acted upon.

510
00:56:14,780 --> 00:56:21,023
If the two—or several—narrations
cannot be reconciled, preference is
then given to one over the others.

511
00:56:21,023 --> 00:56:28,080
This process has established principles
recorded in the relevant books, and we
are not going to discuss it in detail now.

512
00:56:28,080 --> 00:56:31,886
Peace be upon you and Allah’s
mercy and blessings.

513
00:56:31,886 --> 00:56:37,720
Sahih al-Bukhari is regarded as one
of the most authentic books relied upon,

514
00:56:37,720 --> 00:56:41,686
and al-Bukhari divided it
into numerous chapters.

515
00:56:41,686 --> 00:56:46,919
My question is: Does repeating
hadiths that address the same issue

516
00:56:46,919 --> 00:56:53,373
in different chapters of al-Bukhari’s book
not make matters harder for researchers?

517
00:56:53,373 --> 00:56:55,577
If the opposite is true, how?

518
00:56:55,577 --> 00:57:01,680
In fact, al-Bukhari arranged his book
according to a jurisprudential method,

519
00:57:01,680 --> 00:57:05,187
like Imam Malik’s al-Muwatta
and similar works.

520
00:57:05,187 --> 00:57:09,340
Imam Ahmad’s Musnad, for example,
is arranged by narrator.

521
00:57:09,340 --> 00:57:16,796
He gathered all the hadiths
narrated by a particular Companion
from the Messenger of Allah,

522
00:57:16,796 --> 00:57:22,800
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
regardless of their content.

523
00:57:22,800 --> 00:57:28,760
He made one section or book
for one person’s narrations
and another for someone else’s,

524
00:57:28,760 --> 00:57:32,780
devoting a section
to the hadiths of each narrator.

525
00:57:32,780 --> 00:57:37,180
This compilation is not
jurisprudential in nature.

526
00:57:37,180 --> 00:57:43,120
Al-Bukhari, however,
compiled his hadiths according
to a jurisprudential arrangement.

527
00:57:43,120 --> 00:57:49,181
He began with the Book of Revelation
and made separate books for faith,

528
00:57:49,181 --> 00:57:55,580
prayer, and so on—that is, he
structured his work as a legal treatise.

529
00:57:55,580 --> 00:58:00,748
Sometimes a single hadith
contains evidence for an issue
in faith (eemaan) and also

530
00:58:00,748 --> 00:58:08,060
evidence for matters of rulings—whether
in worships, transactions,
inheritance, or punishments.

531
00:58:08,060 --> 00:58:15,443
Thus, he would place that hadith
under the chapter where it
serves as proof regarding faith,

532
00:58:15,443 --> 00:58:23,520
but if the same narration also indicates
a legal ruling in another chapter,
he would include it there too.

533
00:58:23,520 --> 00:58:31,560
This is not difficult at all; rather,
during his time, this method made
understanding easier for people.

534
00:58:31,560 --> 00:58:37,601
Someone looking for hadiths about
prayer can go directly to the hadiths

535
00:58:37,601 --> 00:58:47,366
classified under the heading and chapter
on prayer and find them there, instead
of searching through the entire book.

536
00:58:47,366 --> 00:58:55,320
Al-Bukhari’s classification
and arrangement of these subjects
therefore made matters easier.

537
00:58:55,320 --> 00:59:04,160
It helps anyone consulting the work
to find in each chapter what
they are seeking on that subject.

538
00:59:04,160 --> 00:59:07,400
It is a matter of making
things easier, not harder.

539
00:59:07,400 --> 00:59:13,660
Brother Abdullah asks: Is the Prophetic
biography part of the Sunnah?

540
00:59:13,660 --> 00:59:17,283
If so, then what appears in biographical

541
00:59:17,283 --> 00:59:27,057
works like that of Ibn Hisham would
be added to the transmitted corpus
of the Sunnah and increase its volume.

542
00:59:27,057 --> 00:59:35,184
Yes; the Prophet’s biography
consists of his actions,
and his actions are part of his Sunnah.

543
00:59:35,184 --> 00:59:43,860
The Sunnah encompasses everything
attributed to him—whether speech,
action or tacit approval.

544
00:59:43,860 --> 00:59:51,825
The part of the Prophet’s biography
that contains his actions after revelation
descended belongs to the Sunnah.

545
00:59:51,825 --> 01:00:00,133
The biography also contains sections
about his birth and upbringing, as well
as reports from before his prophethood.

546
01:00:00,133 --> 01:00:07,241
Those reports are not a basis
for evidence or legislation,
because revelation had not yet descended;

547
01:00:07,241 --> 01:00:10,120
there was no revelation
before prophethood.

548
01:00:10,120 --> 01:00:16,576
Every reported action
of the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

549
01:00:16,576 --> 01:00:25,360
after revelation descended is part
of the Sunnah—the practical Sunnah—and
his actions are evidence for legislation.

550
01:00:25,360 --> 01:00:27,111
Of course, it is not as my brother

551
01:00:27,111 --> 01:00:34,063
suggests that adding Ibn Hisham’s
biography to the transmitted
Sunnah greatly increases its size.

552
01:00:34,063 --> 01:00:42,013
In terms of number and volume,
the biography represents only a proportion
of what is reported about the Prophet,

553
01:00:42,013 --> 01:00:46,638
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
in the hadith collections.

554
01:00:46,638 --> 01:00:53,060
Consider Sahih al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim
and the thousands of hadiths they contain:

555
01:00:53,060 --> 01:01:01,626
close to four thousand distinct hadiths of
the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant
him peace, each with multiple narrations.

556
01:01:01,626 --> 01:01:03,853
The biography is added to these.

557
01:01:03,853 --> 01:01:10,619
It should also be noted that scholars
disagreed about the biography
transmitted by Ibn Hisham,

558
01:01:10,619 --> 01:01:15,000
not about Ibn Hisham himself,
may Allah have mercy on him.

559
01:01:15,000 --> 01:01:18,327
Ibn Hisham transmitted
his biography from Ibn Ishaq.

560
01:01:18,327 --> 01:01:22,400
Only parts of Ibn Ishaq’s
book have reached us,

561
01:01:22,400 --> 01:01:26,800
as most of it was lost,
but it was preserved in what
Ibn Hisham transmitted from him.

562
01:01:26,800 --> 01:01:33,800
If you read Ibn Hisham’s Sirah,
you will find him saying, “Ibn Ishaq
informed us” and “Ibn Ishaq said”.

563
01:01:33,800 --> 01:01:40,680
He narrates most of the biography
from Ibn Ishaq; Ibn Ishaq is
the source of Ibn Hisham’s narration.

564
01:01:40,680 --> 01:01:42,680
Scholars differed over Ibn Ishaq.

565
01:01:42,680 --> 01:01:49,571
Some accepted him as a narrator,
while others rejected him
and refused to take reports from him.

566
01:01:49,571 --> 01:01:57,121
Most scholars accepted Ibn Ishaq’s
narrations on condition that they did
not concern matters in which he was

567
01:01:57,121 --> 01:01:58,680
accused of Shi‘i tendencies.

568
01:01:58,680 --> 01:02:03,900
They transmitted some matters from him and
left others. This points to another issue.

569
01:02:03,900 --> 01:02:13,060
We have long said that the biography
of the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless
him and grant him peace, must be followed

570
01:02:13,060 --> 01:02:21,028
as an example in the work to establish
Islamic life, bring an Islamic society
into being and build the Islamic state.

571
01:02:21,028 --> 01:02:27,403
Some people responded that the obligatory
example is found in the Sunnah,
not the biography.

572
01:02:27,403 --> 01:02:31,160
They separated the Sunnah
from the biography and said:

573
01:02:31,160 --> 01:02:35,540
“We are not bound by the biography;
we are only bound by the Sunnah.”

574
01:02:35,540 --> 01:02:36,580
This is false.

575
01:02:36,580 --> 01:02:44,590
The Prophetic biography cannot be
excluded from the Sunnah, because it is a
collection of the actions of the Prophet,

576
01:02:44,590 --> 01:02:49,919
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
and his actions are part of the Sunnah.

577
01:02:49,919 --> 01:02:52,118
A person is certainly entitled

578
01:02:52,118 --> 01:02:58,820
to scrutinise the reports
in the biography and say that one
is authentic and another is not.

579
01:02:58,820 --> 01:03:00,408
It is worth noting that some

580
01:03:00,408 --> 01:03:07,343
scholars made an immense effort
to collect the narrations
that complete the Prophetic biography.

581
01:03:07,343 --> 01:03:14,810
If we comb through—if the expression is
appropriate—the collections of Sunnah
by al-Bukhari, Muslim, Abu Dawud,

582
01:03:14,810 --> 01:03:22,380
Ibn Majah, al-Darimi and others, we find
reports from the life of the Prophet,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

583
01:03:22,380 --> 01:03:28,320
that together provide an almost complete
picture of the Prophetic biography.

584
01:03:28,880 --> 01:03:35,804
One scholar of our time made an immense
effort and compiled a book entitled
The Authentic Prophetic Biography.

585
01:03:35,804 --> 01:03:39,160
He excluded the weak reports
and gathered the authentic ones.

586
01:03:39,160 --> 01:03:44,084
It was an excellent piece of work:
he brought together material from Ibn

587
01:03:44,084 --> 01:03:49,000
Hisham’s biography and the hadith
collections and, after great effort,
produced this book for us.

588
01:03:49,000 --> 01:03:54,860
I believe the author was Shaykh Akram Diya
al-Umari, may Allah have mercy on him.

589
01:03:54,860 --> 01:03:55,976
Shaykh Akram Diya

590
01:03:55,976 --> 01:04:02,900
al-Umari made an immense contribution
concerning the Prophetic Sunnah—or
The Authentic Prophetic Biography.

591
01:04:02,900 --> 01:04:07,977
Our respected brother Abbasi Amjad asks:
“Peace be upon you and Allah’s
mercy and blessings.

592
01:04:07,977 --> 01:04:10,858
Our esteemed teacher,
has anyone rejected a hadith,

593
01:04:10,858 --> 01:04:16,620
or some of al-Bukhari’s hadiths,
even though his collection is one
of the most authentic books of hadith?”

594
01:04:16,620 --> 01:04:19,433
My dear brother,
in principle no one is infallible.

595
01:04:19,433 --> 01:04:24,234
Everyone’s words may be
accepted or rejected except
those of the infallible Prophet,

596
01:04:24,234 --> 01:04:26,430
may Allah bless him and grant him peace.

597
01:04:26,430 --> 01:04:30,408
Al-Bukhari, Muslim, Abu Dawud,
Imam Ahmad, everyone who compiled hadiths,

598
01:04:30,408 --> 01:04:35,578
and everyone who used hadiths
as evidence before the period
of compilation were human beings.

599
01:04:35,578 --> 01:04:37,680
They could be mistaken or correct.

600
01:04:37,680 --> 01:04:47,095
In principle, there is nothing to prevent
someone from saying: “After scrutinising
this hadith narrated by al-Bukhari,

601
01:04:47,095 --> 01:04:52,918
or that hadith narrated by Muslim, I found
it to be weak, so I do not accept it.”

602
01:04:52,918 --> 01:04:55,345
Al-Bukhari was a man, and so is he.

603
01:04:55,345 --> 01:05:03,692
If he has reached the required level
and considers himself a scholar
in this field, he is entitled to do so.

604
01:05:03,692 --> 01:05:09,806
The reality, however, is that after Sahih
al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim had been

605
01:05:09,806 --> 01:05:19,706
compiled—and even before centuries had
passed—almost every recognised scholar
who examined these two great works agreed

606
01:05:19,706 --> 01:05:27,956
that all the hadiths collected
by al-Bukhari and Muslim in their two
Sahih collections were authentic.

607
01:05:27,956 --> 01:05:31,353
It is therefore not
easy to challenge them.

608
01:05:31,353 --> 01:05:40,088
This broad agreement has continued
across the centuries: the majority
of scholars remain in near-consensus

609
01:05:40,088 --> 01:05:46,300
that everything contained in Sahih
al-Bukhari and Sahih Muslim is authentic.

610
01:05:46,300 --> 01:05:52,873
However, if a specialist says that after
scrutinising a particular hadith
in al-Bukhari or Muslim he found it weak,

611
01:05:52,873 --> 01:05:58,398
do we say to him: ‘You have sinned;
you have disobeyed; you have
contradicted the Messenger of Allah’?

612
01:05:58,398 --> 01:05:58,678
No, no.

613
01:05:58,678 --> 01:06:02,734
There is no Shari’ah evidence stating
that one may not declare a hadith

614
01:06:02,734 --> 01:06:06,440
recorded by al-Bukhari as weak—yet
this matter is far from simple.

615
01:06:06,440 --> 01:06:11,403
Some people have taken risks in this
matter, gone to extremes and overstepped

616
01:06:11,403 --> 01:06:18,459
the limits to some extent by classifying
hadiths in al-Bukhari and Muslim as weak;
we will not mention names now.

617
01:06:18,459 --> 01:06:22,647
But in principle, doing so is not
a sin or a violation of the Shari’ah.

618
01:06:22,647 --> 01:06:29,083
There is no Shari’ah evidence
stating that no hadith in al-Bukhari
or Muslim may be classified as weak.

619
01:06:29,083 --> 01:06:36,760
Rather, after thoroughly examining the two
books, the majority of scholars agreed
that everything in them is authentic.

620
01:06:36,760 --> 01:06:42,760
Brother Muhammad Samara asks:
Does the biography of Ibn Hisham
or Ibn Ishaq reach the level of hadith?

621
01:06:42,760 --> 01:06:46,912
Does it consist entirely
of individual reports?

622
01:06:46,912 --> 01:06:54,092
Does it contain weak or mass-transmitted
material? Ibn Hisham’s biography
is not itself mass-transmitted.

623
01:06:54,092 --> 01:06:58,640
Ibn Hisham narrates from Ibn Ishaq, and
Ibn Ishaq narrated from those before him.

624
01:06:58,640 --> 01:07:03,171
But could parts of the biography
be mass-transmitted?

625
01:07:03,171 --> 01:07:08,454
Could a report narrated by Ibn Hisham
coincide with a narration by al-Bukhari,

626
01:07:08,454 --> 01:07:16,459
another by Muslim and another independent
route, so that the separate routes
together establish mass transmission?

627
01:07:16,459 --> 01:07:24,300
That is theoretically possible.
Some parts of the biography may have been
transmitted through mass transmission.

628
01:07:24,300 --> 01:07:28,025
I am not investigating this subject
or reaching a judgement on it now.

629
01:07:28,025 --> 01:07:34,297
But if we assume that the reports in the
biography about the Prophet’s actions,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

630
01:07:34,297 --> 01:07:37,956
during congregational prayer or
the pilgrimage describe actions

631
01:07:37,956 --> 01:07:41,354
that were witnessed, then parts
of the biography are mutawatir.

632
01:07:41,354 --> 01:07:43,510
In practice, they have been transmitted

633
01:07:43,510 --> 01:07:49,260
continuously by the masses from the time
of the Prophet, may Allah bless him
and grant him peace, until today.

634
01:07:49,260 --> 01:07:52,326
As for Ibn Hisham’s Sirah, it
does reach the level of hadith.

635
01:07:52,326 --> 01:07:56,305
When a report about an action is narrated
from the Prophet, may Allah bless

636
01:07:56,305 --> 01:08:02,308
him and grant him peace—when a Companion
says that the Messenger of Allah,
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,

637
01:08:02,308 --> 01:08:06,940
did something, approved something
or remained silent about
it—that report is a hadith.

638
01:08:06,940 --> 01:08:10,060
Even if it does not contain
words spoken by the Prophet,

639
01:08:10,060 --> 01:08:15,290
may Allah bless him and grant him peace,
it belongs to the Prophetic Sunnah,
which is Shari’ah evidence.

640
01:08:15,290 --> 01:08:18,260
The biography is therefore
part of the Prophetic Sunnah.

641
01:08:18,260 --> 01:08:23,967
If its reports meet the conditions
of authenticity established
by the scholars of hadith terminology,

642
01:08:23,967 --> 01:08:27,620
they belong to the Sunnah from which
Shari’ah rulings may be derived.

643
01:08:27,620 --> 01:08:30,680
These are all the questions
we have received so far.

644
01:08:30,680 --> 01:08:35,123
I ask Allah, glorified and exalted be He,
to let us benefit from this session.

645
01:08:35,123 --> 01:08:41,679
If I have made an error, it is from me;
if I have been correct, it is by the grace
of Allah, glorified and exalted be He.

646
01:08:41,679 --> 01:08:43,791
I ask Allah, the Mighty and Majestic,

647
01:08:43,791 --> 01:08:49,546
to increase us in knowledge
and make our knowledge and deeds
sincere for His Noble Countenance.

648
01:08:49,546 --> 01:08:52,460
Peace be upon you and Allah’s
mercy and blessings.
