All Halaqaat
EN

Halaqa 2

The Measuring Scales of Creeds

About this Halaqa

Full title: The System of Islam — Halaqa 2: The Way to Belief and the Measuring Scales of Creeds

Lecturer: Sheikh Ahmad al-Qasas
Series: Commentary on The System of Islam
Date: 5 June 2017 — 10 Ramadan 1438 AH

Video with subtitles

Full transcript

Introduction: Creeds and the Measure of Truth

Peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be upon you, my dear brothers. People have their own creeds; there are many creeds, and we have our creed to which we invite the entire world. What is the measure we adopt to prove to people that our creed is the truth and that all other creeds are false? This is the subject of this episode.

From the bookThe System of IslamSixth edition · 2001pp. 7–8

Opening Text of the Book “The System of Islam”

Thought about this worldly life will not be productively consolidated, unless the thought about the universe, man and life, and about what preceded this worldly life, as well as what comes afterlife and its relationship with what is before and after it, is generated. This can be achieved by giving the universal idea (al-fikrah al kulliyah) about what exists beyond the universe, man and life, because it is the intellectual basis (al-qaa’idah al-fikriyyah) upon which all thoughts about life are built. Giving this universal idea about these matters is the solution to man’s biggest knot (al-‘uqdat ul-qubra). Once this knot is solved all other knots are solved, because they are either partial relative to it, or branches from it. This solution wouldn’t lead to the correct revival (Nahdhah), unless it is a correct solution, which agree to man’s innateness (fiTrah) and convinces the mind and thus fills one’s heart with tranquillity.

The true solution cannot be reached except through the enlightened thought (al-fikr ul-mustaneer) about universe, man and life. Consequently, those who yearn for revival (Nahdha) and pursue the path of elevation (ruqiy), must first solve this knot correctly via enlightened thought. This solution is none other than the creed (‘Aqeedah) which is the intellectual basis (al-qaa‘idah al-fikriyyah) upon which every detailed thought about man’s behaviour and the systems of life are built.

View book source

Summary of the Previous Halaqa

Peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be upon you. In the name of Allah, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful. My dear brothers, in the previous episode we conducted a broad study that demonstrated the human being’s need for a creed: the universal idea about the universe, the human being, and life; what existed before this worldly life and comes after it; and the relationship of this life to both. We established that this universal idea is the human being’s starting point for understanding the meaning of his existence. Once that meaning is determined, his view of worldly life enables him to form concepts about the things he encounters in his conduct. When he adopts these concepts, they produce a particular conduct—a particular way of life. A correct way of life requires correct concepts, and these concepts arise from correct thought about worldly life as part of a universal idea about the universe, the human being, and life. If this universal idea is also correct, the result is correct conduct: a balanced way of life that gives the human being happiness in this life, together with psychological stability and peace. This is what we summarised in the previous episode. We also established that the human being needs a creed as the foundation of life. It is the intellectual basis upon which all thoughts about life are built and the intellectual leadership that guides the human being through life. It solves the biggest knot in every human being. Once this knot is solved, all other knots in life are also solved.

How Do We Distinguish the Correct Creed?

This leads us to the following subject. We have become convinced that the human being needs a creed—the universal idea about the universe, the human being, and life. But people hold many different views and schools of thought. Throughout history and until the Day of Resurrection, creeds will remain numerous and conflicting. Each rejects the others and claims to be true. Amid these creeds, philosophies, and principles, how can we convince people that the creed we carry—the Islamic creed—is the correct one? How do we proceed step by step with a person who listens to us, so that we convince him and guide him to the correct creed? What scale and criterion allow us to declare this creed true and all others false? We say, with Allah’s help.

The Two Measures of the Correct Creed

The correct creed, in order to be proven true and for people to accept that it is true, must satisfy two conditions: first, it must accord with human innateness (fitrah); second, it must be based on reason. These are two conditions. If they are present in a creed, then it is the correct creed. Accordance with fitrah and establishment upon reason—why must the creed be based on reason? Someone might ask, “Why this assumption? Where did this assumption come from? Where did these two criteria or measures originate?” The two criteria you have set for the creed? We say, and may Allah grant us success.

The First Measure: Accordance with Fitrah

Regarding accordance with fitrah, the creed must accord with fitrah. By fitrah, my dear brothers, we mean the true nature of the human soul, especially its most prominent aspect, which is called the instinct of religiousness. Allah, the Exalted and Glorious, said concerning it:

﴿ فَأَقِمْ وَجْهَكَ لِلدِّينِ حَنِيفًا ۚ فِطْرَتَ ٱللَّهِ ٱلَّتِى فَطَرَ ٱلنَّاسَ عَلَيْهَا ۚ لَا تَبْدِيلَ لِخَلْقِ ٱللَّهِ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ ٱلدِّينُ ٱلْقَيِّمُ وَلَـٰكِنَّ أَكْثَرَ ٱلنَّاسِ لَا يَعْلَمُونَ ﴾
“So direct your face towards the religion, inclining to truth—the innate nature of Allah upon which He created mankind. There is no changing Allah’s creation. That is the upright religion, but most people do not know.” [30:30]

However, when we address a person who has no creed, or who holds a creed other than the Islamic creed, we do not begin with this verse, because he has not yet believed in the Qur’an.

But we can agree with him on a fact that every rational person can recognise: The human being is religious by nature, through his fitrah and his instinct—what is innate within him. Everyone can see that the human being naturally feels a need for the Creator and Arranger. This feeling arises from the human being’s natural weakness and need. Especially in moments of weakness, the human being instinctively seeks the Creator who created him and arranges his affairs, to seek His help and turn to Him. Throughout history, therefore, the human being has been religious and worshipful, whether following the true religion or a false one. He is religious by nature. Why did the human being turn to the worship of things besides Allah when messengers had not reached him or when he rejected them? He worshipped a homeland, an idol, a river, a sea, a star, the sun, the moon, a king, a philosopher, or a prophet. Why has the human being always been religious, and why have all peoples and nations practised some form of religion? Quite simply: It is innate. The human being has a pressing need for the Creator and Arranger. If he does not come to know his Creator and Arranger, the Glorified and Exalted, and does not believe in Him with correct belief, he satisfies his instinct of religiousness incorrectly through the worship of idols and images or deities besides Allah, the Glorified and Exalted.

The human being is religious by nature; this is innate within him. We therefore said that the instinct of religiousness is one of his prominent instincts. Any creed that tells him, “There is no deity, no religion, no sanctification, and no worship,” conflicts with his fitrah.

The creed is meant to solve the biggest knot for the human being and open the way for him to solve his problems and satisfy his drives correctly. Yet a creed may say, for example: “There is no deity, and life is only matter.” It then says: “Religion is the opium of the people,” and so on. When a creed blocks the path of the human being’s fitrah and prevents him from satisfying his innate needs, it has failed both in its result and its application. Its application faces many obstacles. A creed must solve the human being’s problem, not make it worse. That is the creed’s task. If it conflicts with the human being’s fitrah and obstructs its natural course, it is undoubtedly false.

That is one side of the matter. The other is that fitrah is real. It is a fundamental part of the human being’s constitution—indeed, part of his very nature. The creed—the universal idea about the universe, the human being, and life—must also be true and correspond to reality if it is to be correct. One truth cannot contradict another; truths do not contradict one another. If we establish that fitrah is real, but a creed presents a different conception of the reality of the universe, the human being, and life, then it presents a false idea that does not correspond to reality because it contradicts reality. It is therefore a false creed. The correct creed acknowledges the human being’s fitrah, satisfies it, and guides it along its correct path. This leads the human being to correct satisfaction and therefore correct conduct. That concerns fitrah: the creed must accord with fitrah. We therefore immediately judge creeds based on materialism and denial of the Creator, the Glorified and Exalted, to be false. The Marxist creed is among the best known. In practice, it proved unable to survive and unable to shape peoples and nations effectively over a long period. The human being cannot live in harmony with a creed that conflicts with his fitrah. A creed that denies the Creator’s existence denies religion and obstructs the human being’s natural need for worship and religiousness. It is therefore false.

The Second Criterion: A Creed Based on Reason

We have now reached the second criterion, which is that the creed must be based on reason.

What do we mean by saying that the creed must be based on reason? We mean that reason must judge whether this creed is true or false. Why? Because the creed is a judgment about reality—the reality of the universe, the human being, and life. It is a thought, an idea. The criterion for an idea’s truth is whether it corresponds to reality, because it is a judgment about reality. The universal idea about the universe, the human being, and life determines whether they are limited or unlimited and therefore created or uncreated. We are thus judging their reality. When is this judgment true or false? If it corresponds to reality, it is true; if it conflicts with reality, it is false. What determines whether it corresponds to the truth? Reason. Reason is the human being’s tool for perceiving things. Without it, he could not perceive anything. It is the faculty of perception that allows him to distinguish truth from falsehood and perceive things, their existence, and their attributes. Reason enables the human being to engage with this life consciously and perceptively. Hence the saying: “Reason is the condition for legal responsibility.”

Critique of Materialist Creed

And one might ask: Is there anyone who holds that…

that the creed can be founded not upon reason? Are you merely Muslims? Are you merely those who deduce your creed through reason? Do not others claim that their creed is rational? Yes, many indeed claim it; in fact, most proponents of creeds assert that their creed is rational and built upon reason. However, mere assertion is not the criterion. For instance, when Marxist communists determined that matter is the basis of everything, that nothing exists prior to matter, that nothing exists subsequent to matter, and that matter is the Necessary Existent—imagining its non-existence as impossible, thus deeming it uncreated—and that the mind is a product of matter, what did these individuals actually accomplish? In truth, they constructed their creed upon matter, not upon reason, because they presupposed from the outset that matter is the fundamental reality.

And matter precedes the mind; therefore, their creed was built upon matter. This is one example. Another example is the creed currently dominating the world: the Western civilisation creed, the creed of separating religion from life. Did reason determine that religion must be separated from life? Did reason conclude that if there is a Creator of the universe, humanity, and life, then there is no connection between them, and that it is humanity that determines the meaning of its life, rather than the Creator determining the meaning of life? Of course not. Reason states that the Creator of something is the one who determines the purpose of its creation. Reason asserts that whoever brings something into existence and creates it is the one who, from the outset, determined the purpose of its existence. Thus, when we confront the reality that Allah, the Exalted and Glorious, is the One who created the heavens and the earth, the One who created the universe, humanity, and life, can reason then say that the Creator has no right to intervene in the reality of life? Of course not; it cannot say so.

The Creed of Separating Religion from Life

Reason is thus the basis; therefore, when Westerners claim that their creed—the creed of separating religion from life—is built upon reason, they are in fact lying to themselves and deceiving people. The truth is that the Western creed is the creed of separating religion from life, the capitalist creed. The capitalist principle is the creed of liberalism. Call it whatever you wish: this creed, which separates religion from life, is in reality not built upon reason, but upon a compromise.

Yes, upon a compromise. What do we mean by that? The emergence of the creed of separating religion from life in history, over more than two centuries. How did this creed arise? It emerged following a conflict between the Church, which dominated European society for hundreds of years—approximately a thousand years—and emerging philosophers who dared to oppose the Church, stating that the Church and religiousness were the cause of the calamities Europe suffered for hundreds of years. Thus, a conflict arose between the Church, which sought to impose Christianity upon society, and atheist philosophers, whether they denied Allah, the Exalted and Glorious, or denied revelation, rejecting the scriptures and the prophets. A conflict emerged between these two groups: one group held that society must be founded upon the Christian religion, while the other group concluded that society must be founded upon atheistic materialist thought.

Then some philosophers and thinkers said: Let us find a compromise between the two groups. We do not wish for life to be founded upon religion and religiousness, nor do we wish for it to be founded upon atheism. Rather, let us separate this subject from life, and let us all live together, despite our differing creeds, religions, and philosophies, in one single mode of living: we shall separate all these researches entirely from religion and from anti-religious philosophy, separating them from life, and thereafter we can continue to engage in this discussion and debate between religion and atheism, between religion and philosophers, independent of people’s lives. From here emerged the creed of separating religion from life.

From life, and it was founded upon the criterion of compromise. This is what established two modes of thinking in the West that still govern their way of thinking to this day: what they call pragmatism, translated into Arabic as the instrumentalist method of thinking, or instrumentalist pragmatism.

Thus, these are creeds whose proponents claim they built them upon reason, yet in truth they did not found them upon reason. It is worth noting that there are proponents of creeds who openly state that religion and reason do not meet. This is the case, for example, with the Church, which views reason as an enemy of religion and an enemy of faith. They argue that if a person insists on following his reason and logical thinking, as they say, he exits from faith.

And that faith is merely submission. Indeed, there are those who hold that reason is the source of vices and the source of error, and that humanity has no path to faith except by opening the heart. So, what is the criterion in such a case? One opens his heart to that creed, another to a different religion, and a third to another philosophy, and so on. What is the criterion if the matter is left to human feeling, as they call it? Naturally, here lies the error, and the standards and criteria are lost.

Thus, reason is humanity’s path to apprehending realities. Humanity uses its reason and judges daily in many, indeed in most, of the details of life that confront it. How, then, can it rely upon its reason to apprehend daily and momentary realities, only to set aside its reason when deciding to adopt a creed that forms the foundation of its life, leaving the matter to feeling, tradition, and following society and parents, of course?

The Qur’an and the Application of Reason

This is precisely the error. Indeed, the Qur’an was extremely explicit when it addressed human minds, stating that those endowed with intellect and understanding are the ones who arrive at the truth.

They arrive at true faith when they use their minds. Allah says:

﴿ إِنَّ فِى خَلْقِ ٱلسَّمَـٰوَٰتِ وَٱلْأَرْضِ وَٱخْتِلَـٰفِ ٱلَّيْلِ وَٱلنَّهَارِ وَٱلْفُلْكِ ٱلَّتِى تَجْرِى فِى ٱلْبَحْرِ بِمَا يَنفَعُ ٱلنَّاسَ وَمَآ أَنزَلَ ٱللَّهُ مِنَ ٱلسَّمَآءِ مِن مَّآءٍ فَأَحْيَا بِهِ ٱلْأَرْضَ بَعْدَ مَوْتِهَا وَبَثَّ فِيهَا مِن كُلِّ دَآبَّةٍ وَتَصْرِيفِ ٱلرِّيَـٰحِ وَٱلسَّحَابِ ٱلْمُسَخَّرِ بَيْنَ ٱلسَّمَآءِ وَٱلْأَرْضِ لَـَٔايَـٰتٍ لِّقَوْمٍ يَعْقِلُونَ ﴾
“Indeed, in the creation of the heavens and the earth, the alternation of night and day, the ships that sail the sea for people’s benefit, the water Allah sends down from the sky—reviving the earth with it after its death and spreading every kind of creature throughout it—the changing of the winds, and the clouds held between heaven and earth, are signs for people who use their reason.” [2:164]

They use reason, think, perceive, and use their minds to reach the truths. Other verses address people of understanding:

﴿ أَفَلَا يَتَدَبَّرُونَ ﴾
“Will they not reflect?” [47:24]

“Will they not think?”

﴿ أَمْ عَلَىٰ قُلُوبٍ أَقْفَالُهَآ ﴾
“Or are there locks upon their hearts?” [47:24]

And so on.

The Qur’an is therefore very clear in calling on people to use their reason in order to reach the correct creed. And at its end—at its end— These are the two criteria we must adopt and present to everyone in order to distinguish the correct creed from a false one. The creed must answer the major questions that form the biggest knot for the human being: What is the reality of the universe, the human being, and life? Were they created or not? If they were created, what existed before them, and what will come after them? If something existed before them, what is their relationship to it? And if something comes after them, what is their relationship to it?

This is the creed’s task. A human being cannot answer these questions by disabling reason and setting it aside. Reason must therefore be used in this field. Here, someone raises an objection.

Yes, reason is a tool for knowing the truth. But you want the creed to tell you what existed before this worldly life and what comes after it. You want it to answer whether the universe, the human being, and life were created or not—that is, whether a Creator created them. If this Creator exists, as some put it, how can reason know and prove His existence when He cannot be sensed or seen? Can reason judge matters that cannot be sensed? Can reason prove the existence of something or some entity that cannot be sensed? Some people boast that the scientific method produces knowledge about sensible facts in sensible things. They claim that the only method of rational thought proven in this age is the scientific method, which subjects matter to observation and experimentation, and so on. Since the Creator cannot be sensed, they say that science cannot prove His existence. If science is unable to do so, they conclude that reason is also unable. We say to them: You have gone astray and led others astray. Why? Because you have confined the mind’s perception to only one of its aspects.

You have neglected everything else. This is why the passage we read at the beginning of this episode states that reaching the creed—the universal idea about the universe, the human being, and life—requires enlightened thinking.

The Mind and the Limits of Perception

What do we mean by enlightened thinking? Before I explain the expression, let us listen together to a story that some tell as a joke, although it contains a fundamental rule of thinking. An atheist teacher is said to have stood before his students in class to convince them that the Creator’s existence could not be proven—indeed, that no Creator existed. He led their minds step by step and asked: “Can you see this table?” They said: “Yes.” He replied: “Then the table exists. Can you see this board?” They said: “Yes.” He replied: “Then the board exists. Can you see this lamp?” They said: “Yes.” He replied: “Then there is a lamp in the room.” He continued in this way until he asked them: “Can you see Allah?”

They said: “No.” He replied: “Then Allah does not exist. How can we affirm the existence of something we cannot see?” One student asked permission to speak and asked his classmates: “Can you see the teacher’s mind?” They said: “No.” He replied: “Then the teacher has no mind”—according to the teacher’s rule, of course. The student made his teacher a laughing stock before the class, but that is not the only lesson in this story.

The student made his teacher look foolish before his classmates. Yet the story contains an important principle of thinking: we do not affirm or deny the existence of something merely because we cannot see it.

Methods of Perceiving the Existence of Things

There are things in this world whose existence we affirm without seeing them. How? With Allah’s help, reason has three ways to perceive that things exist. Each is a rational path. First, the senses perceive the thing itself. You see something; if it did not exist, you could not see it. When the senses perceive a thing, this proves that it exists. You see water in front of you, so water is present. You see a man in front of you, so the man exists. You see the sun rise and set every day, so something called the sun exists. Sensory perception of the thing itself proves its existence. No two people disagree about this.

Perceiving a Thing Through Its Effect

Is this the only way to perceive the existence of things? Of course not.

There is another way to perceive that things exist: the senses perceive a thing’s effect rather than the thing itself. The senses perceive its effect—the senses perceive its effect. The nearest example is the one we mentioned a moment ago. You judge that a person is intelligent and possesses a mind without seeing anything called a mind. Who claims to have seen a mind? The mind cannot be seen.

Someone may immediately reply: “But the brain can be perceived.” The brain is not the mind. The brain is one of the conditions required for the mind, but a brain can exist without a developed mind. A newborn child has a brain but has not yet developed a mind. A donkey has a brain but does not think, as do other animals. A person with severe mental incapacity has a brain that performs the body’s biological functions, but the rational process does not function properly.

Such a person has a brain but is not rational. How, then, do we judge that someone is rational and possesses a mind? We judge by the person’s actions. If he acts purposefully, perceives things as they are, speaks coherently, and deals with things productively, we say: “This person has a sound mind through which he acts and engages with life.” We perceive the effect of the mind, not the mind itself.

We therefore affirm that a person possesses a mind through the mind’s effects. This is one example.

Another example: You enter a building, a house, or another place and find the lights on. You immediately conclude that electricity is present, because the lights would not be on without it. Who can see an electric current? Can it be seen? Of course not. But you can see its effect: electrical devices are working. This means that electricity is present. You see plants and conclude that the area contains water, even if the water is neither visible nor tangible, because life would not exist without it:

﴿ وَجَعَلْنَا مِنَ ٱلْمَآءِ كُلَّ شَىْءٍ حَىٍّ ﴾
“And We made every living thing from water.” [21:30]

In this way, you affirm the existence of many things in life without touching them or perceiving them directly, simply because you perceive their effects. Suppose you enter a room and find a lit cigarette but no one in the house. You conclude that someone was there a short while ago, lit the cigarette, and left it in its usual place. A cigarette does not light itself and remain there. Someone must have lit it. That person is either still present or has only just left; had more time passed, the cigarette would have burned out. The second way of perceiving that things exist is therefore to perceive their effects. That is the second way. Is there a third?

The Certain News

Since I perceive the existence of things, there is indeed a third path agreed upon by all the reasonable, namely, the certain news. Each of us relies on news to ascertain the existence of things, events, persons, and so on.

Is there any reasonable person among us today who denies the existence of a personality in history named Napoleon, for example? Is there any reasonable person who denies the existence of an event named the Second World War?

Certainly not. Is there any reasonable person who denies the existence of the First World War? Certainly not. Although most people saw neither war, they learned about it through a certain report. Millions of people told millions of others that they had lived through the conditions of a war called the First or Second World War.

Here is an example. Suppose you are in a certain place, and a person comes and tells you that a commotion and an altercation have occurred there. For you, this is a speculative report. You think the event may have happened, because the person could be mistaken. If a second person then brings you the same report, followed by a third, a fourth and a fifth, and you have confirmation that they could not have agreed to lie and that none knows the others, you finally say: yes, I am now certain that this event occurred. You have perceived the existence of something without sensing or seeing it and without sensing its effect.

It was the certain report that proved to you the existence of something. These, then, are three ways by which the mind judges.

Through them, the mind judges the existence of things. Let us now return to the subject of enlightened thinking.

Shallow, Deep, and Enlightened Thinking

What do we mean by enlightened thinking? Enlightened thinking is one of the divisions or one of the types of thinking. This is a division from a certain perspective. We say there is shallow thinking, there is deep thinking, and there is enlightened thinking. What do we mean by each of these three?

Shallow thinking is that thinking built upon a superficial view of things, passing, unexamined, and not profound. Many things in our lives do not actually require depth in thinking; they do not require depth to say, “This is a chair,” and “This is a table.” A superficial, passing view suffices to judge things by saying, “This is a car,” and “This is an aeroplane,” and “This is a table,” and “This is a plate,” and so on.

But if a person looks at everything in this shallow way, he becomes intellectually backward and falls behind in life, because there are matters for which a shallow view and shallow thinking are insufficient. Some matters can only be perceived through deep thinking. By deep thinking, we mean thinking based on a deep, careful, thorough, and repeated examination of a thing, together with firmly connecting it in the mind to previous information about what is being perceived. Consider, for example, a physicist, a chemist, or a biologist. If such a person’s thinking were shallow, could he reach the truths reached by physics, chemistry, and biology? Of course not. Deep thinking is necessary. Consider a person reading a legislative text. Is a shallow reading enough to understand it? Of course not. Deep thinking is necessary. We need this depth in many areas of life. People have different specialisations, and each person goes deeply into his own field. Each of us examines certain matters deeply in order to reach the truths and results that require such depth.

Deep Thinking

This is deep thinking. But deep thinking does not enable the human being to know every truth. Although it goes deeply into a subject, it does not necessarily move beyond examining the thing itself. A physicist examines matter deeply. A biologist examines cells, the body’s organs, and so on. Each goes deeply into a particular field without necessarily moving beyond it.

We are therefore left with a higher level: enlightened thinking. What do we mean by it? Enlightened thinking is neither shallow nor content with deep thought that remains confined to the thing itself. It goes beyond the thing to examine what lies behind it, concerns it, and is connected to it. Take a physicist as an example. If he moves beyond studying matter and asks, “Since all matter consists of atoms, and atoms are the basis from which all things are formed, how did the atom come into existence? Who first brought it into existence?”, he has moved beyond depth to enlightenment. He now examines what lies behind the thing and what is connected to it. This enlightenment is necessary in order to perceive what does not fall under the senses. Let me give you one final example to distinguish the three levels of thinking: shallow, deep, and enlightened thinking.

Example Illustrating Enlightened Thinking

A group of people are sitting together when they suddenly hear commotion, noise, and loud voices. They immediately look out of the window and see a crowd chanting and moving together in a semi-organised march. One person takes a quick, shallow look and says: “This is a demonstration.” Yes, no more than a shallow look and judgment is needed to identify it as a demonstration. A second person studies it more carefully and tries to estimate the number of demonstrators. He says: “There seem to be about one or two thousand. They are chanting such-and-such slogans and carrying such-and-such placards. Most appear to be middle-aged,” and so on. He has examined the scene deeply, so his judgment is deep rather than merely shallow. He looks closely and repeatedly to understand the details of the demonstration. A third person has political thought and political awareness. Like the second person, he studies the demonstration’s reality, details, and characteristics. But he immediately connects it to its surroundings, related matters, and the circumstances before and during it. What happened yesterday? How is a particular political statement connected to this demonstration? To which group do these people belong? Are they middle-class or poor? Are they educated or uneducated? Where did they begin, and where are they going? How does all of this relate to the surrounding political climate? What objective is intended through this demonstration? His thought is not confined to the demonstration’s size, characteristics, and chants. He goes beyond these details to understand what lies behind it, its aim, and what is connected to it, as well as what it may produce. This person is an enlightened thinker.

This is what we mean by enlightened thinking. The student who asked his classmates, “Can you see the teacher’s mind?”, showed this kind of thinking. They said no, and he concluded, according to the teacher’s rule, that the teacher had no mind. The example shows that we can affirm the existence of something without seeing it directly: We perceive its effect and thereby perceive the thing hidden from the senses. This is enlightened thinking. All of this was presented to answer those who claim that the human being cannot reach a conclusion about the origin of the universe, the human being, and life and what lies beyond them—whether they have a Creator. We can examine the things that make up the universe, the human being, and life to understand their reality. By understanding their reality, we perceive that they cannot exist by themselves. They do not exist by themselves; they came into existence at a particular time; and by their nature, they will end at a particular time. This means that someone created them. We use this enlightened thinking to prove our creed. It establishes the existence of the Creator, the Glorified and Exalted, through rational evidence based on examining things in order to reach their Creator, the Glorified and Exalted. This is what we are expected to begin in the next episode, Allah willing, on the basis Allah, the Glorified and Exalted, explained in His Noble Book. Many verses call on the human being to examine the universe, the human being, and life so that he may perceive the existence of their Creator. He is exalted above what they associate with Him.

Praise be to Allah, Lord of worlds.

Questions and Discussions

Brother Abu Anas al-Maqdisi asks: What if what is described as a person’s creed does not solve his biggest knot? If the biggest knot is not solved, it is not a creed, because the creed’s function is to answer these questions. When the answers are given, the knot is solved. If the creed tells the human being that the universe, the human being, and life were created by a Creator, that the Creator existed before them, and that accountability before the Creator follows this life, then it connects worldly life with what preceded it and what follows it. It has thereby solved the human being’s knot. But if a person carries this creed in a deficient way and does not understand its meaning, it does not fully solve his knot in practice. This is the reality of many Muslims. They acknowledge the Islamic creed and understand that the universe, the human being, and life were created by a Creator; that the Creator existed before them; that the Hereafter comes after them; that the human being’s relationship with the Creator is to be an obedient servant; and that the relationship between worldly life and the Hereafter is one of accountability, reward, and punishment. But the creed is not fully crystallised and understood in them. For example, they do not fully understand the connection between worldly life and what preceded it: that their entire life must be conducted according to Allah’s commands and prohibitions. If a person restricts his relationship with the Creator to acts of worship, he wrongs himself, and his biggest knot remains only partly solved. He has not made the creed the foundation of his life, his intellectual basis, and his intellectual leadership throughout life.

The Relationship Between Reason and Transmitted evidence

Abu Qasi asks: How can we explain the difference between our statement that reason should be the arbiter in establishing the creed, and reason alone in establishing the creed, versus those who accuse us of glorifying reason and placing it above transmitted evidence?

From this speech they make, yes, unfortunately, some of the religious and some of the intellectuals among us—the religious who have been educated with a certain limited culture—see it as either reason or transmitted evidence, meaning either we rely on reason or we rely on transmitted evidence in everything. And when they were given a choice between reason and transmitted evidence, they said, “We are a nation of transmitted evidence,” and thus they cast reason aside and follow transmitted evidence. Naturally, they have wronged themselves.

First, the Qur’an is explicit in commanding people to use their reason, and in making reason the condition for legal responsibility. This is first. Second, transmitted evidence and reason are not two contradictory or opposing things. As I mentioned earlier, transmitted evidence is one of the paths of reason to reach the truth; the news is one of the paths of reason to reach the facts.

However, the Islamic creed has two parts. One part falls under the realm of the senses; the path to its perception and proof, and the arguments upon it, is reason. When we are faced with the subject of proving the existence of the Creator, the search for proving the existence of the Creator is a search into the reality of created things, regarding whether they are created or not created. If we are searching into the sensible, and the mind realises that the essence of things is powerless, deficient, and limited, We will explain this further in the next episode, Allah willing. Reason concludes that these things were created and thereby reaches the existence of the Creator. The Creator’s existence is therefore proven through reason. The same applies when we examine the Qur’an: Is it Allah’s Book or not? We cannot tell someone who does not yet believe that the proof that the Qur’an is Allah’s speech is Allah’s speech. In other words, we cannot use a Qur’anic verse to prove that the Qur’an is Allah’s speech before the person believes in the Qur’an. When Allah, the Exalted and Glorious, commanded people to believe in the Qur’an and called them to believe in Muhammad’s ﷺ message, He required them to do so through the use of their reason.

How? He said to them: “This is a miraculous book that no human being can produce the like of. If you can produce something like it, or even a surah like it, you have thereby proven that it is not the speech of Allah. But if you cannot, that becomes evidence against you that it is the speech of Allah.” This is a rational argument. Allah, the Exalted and Glorious, said:

﴿ وَإِن كُنتُمْ فِى رَيْبٍ مِّمَّا نَزَّلْنَا عَلَىٰ عَبْدِنَا فَأْتُوا۟ بِسُورَةٍ مِّن مِّثْلِهِۦ وَٱدْعُوا۟ شُهَدَآءَكُم مِّن دُونِ ٱللَّهِ إِن كُنتُمْ صَـٰدِقِينَ ۝ فَإِن لَّمْ تَفْعَلُوا۟ ﴾
“And if you are in doubt about what We have revealed to Our servant, then produce a surah like it and call your witnesses besides Allah, if you are truthful. But if you do not…” [2:23–24]

﴿ وَلَن تَفْعَلُوا۟ فَٱتَّقُوا۟ ٱلنَّارَ ٱلَّتِى وَقُودُهَا ٱلنَّاسُ وَٱلْحِجَارَةُ ۖ أُعِدَّتْ لِلْكَـٰفِرِينَ ﴾
“…and you will never do so—then fear the Fire whose fuel is people and stones, prepared for the disbelievers.” [2:23–24]

Here Allah addresses human reason to prove that the Qur’an is the speech of Allah. The Qur’an is before us and can be sensed; therefore, reason proves that the Qur’an is the speech of Allah. For creeds whose subject can be sensed, the proof is rational. As for creeds that neither fall under the senses nor have any effect that falls under the senses, their proof is transmitted evidence; direct rational proof has no role in them. Reason alone cannot prove the existence of angels, Paradise, Hell, the Day of Judgment, jinn and devils, the horrors of the Day of Resurrection, or the account of creation. These are not sensible things and have no effect that falls under the senses. However, transmitted evidence has been established through reason: reason established that the Qur’an is the speech of Allah and that what Muhammad brought came from his Lord, the Exalted and Glorious. Reason is therefore certain that this report is certain. What he brought establishes with certainty that angels are real, jinn are real, Paradise is real, Hell is real, accountability is real, the Scale is real, and so on. Why? Because these matters were established through one of reason’s paths to the truth: transmitted evidence in the form of a certain report. We therefore say that some matters of creed are proven by reason and others by transmitted evidence. Here, by “matters of creed,” we mean the matters that constitute the Islamic creed. The creed comprises several matters; some are proven by reason, some are proven by reason, and others are proven by transmitted evidence.

Al-Tahawi’s Creed

Sister, may Allah bless you, asks. What is Al-Tahawi’s Creed? She wrote ‘طحوبة’. And why is it named so? What is the difference in the naming? Unfortunately, it is named after a person. Al-Tahawi’s Creed is a term commonly used among Muslims, indicating a book written by a scholar named Al-Tahawi. Instead of saying “Al-Tahawi’s Book on the Creed,” people have circulated for hundreds of years saying “Al-Tahawi’s Creed.” In our view, this is not correct and not valid. The creed is the creed of Islam; it is the Islamic creed. It should have been said “Al-Tahawi’s Book on the Creed,” and not “Al-Tahawi’s Creed.”

Science and the Perception of the Existence of Allah

A brother asks whether there is a connection between science and perceiving the existence of Allah, the Glorified and Exalted. Must such a connection necessarily exist, or not? What do I mean? I gave an example in my presentation. A person may be a scientist. If “science” here means the material and experimental sciences, such as physics, chemistry, biology, and other natural sciences, a person may be highly skilled and deeply specialised in them, while his perception of these sciences and their knowledge never moves beyond them to what lies behind them.

Thus, he does not reach faith in Allah, the Glorified and Exalted. These are the people about whom Allah, the Glorified and Exalted, said:

﴿ يَعْلَمُونَ ظَـٰهِرًا مِّنَ ٱلْحَيَوٰةِ ٱلدُّنْيَا وَهُمْ عَنِ ٱلْـَٔاخِرَةِ هُمْ غَـٰفِلُونَ ﴾
“They know only the outward aspect of this worldly life, while they are heedless of the Hereafter.” [30:7]

These people know the outward aspect of worldly life. However deeply they delve into it and however much they engage with its details, they do not move beyond it to what lies behind it. But if a human being goes beyond these sciences and feels a sense of responsibility—if, after perceiving these manifest truths, he moves beyond them to think about what lies behind them—and says that this limited, powerless, and deficient matter cannot exist by itself, and that matter subject to a law cannot exist unless there is One who subjected it to that law, then scientists who specialise in material science are the most knowledgeable about the laws of matter. They are therefore the most entitled to ask who imposed these laws upon matter, which cannot change them. Who subjected it to these laws? There must therefore be One who subjected it to these laws. If he thinks in this way and concludes that there is a Creator who created, and his awareness of the Creator’s existence leads him to recognise the importance of establishing a bond between the human being and his Creator—a bond of guidance—he then searches for a Messenger from Allah, the Glorified and Exalted, so that he may be guided by His guidance. Through this thinking, he naturally reaches faith and true faith. But this human being must sincerely seek the truth and submit to it. He must be sincere towards truth and reality, and thus towards Allah, the Exalted.

For Those Who Did Not Receive the Message

Our brother asks: If the Islamic creed is rational, reason is fundamentally the same in every human being, and every person can reach the Islamic creed through thought, why are people who did not receive the call, or to whom no messenger came, not held accountable? The answer is simple. Reason leads the human being to the Creator’s existence. It also makes him certain that he needs the Creator’s guidance, because only the Creator has the right to tell the human being the meaning of his existence in this life. He therefore recognises his need for a message and a Messenger from Allah, the Glorified and Exalted. But if the Messenger’s message does not reach him, how can he complete his creed? He has concluded that he was created by a Creator and has recognised his need for the Creator. But without the Creator’s message, he cannot believe in Allah’s Book—or Allah’s books and messengers—and cannot know what lies beyond the universe, the human being, and life. How could he know the beginning of existence, the details of creation that Allah related in His Noble Book, Paradise, Hell, and the angels?

To the extent that he is naturally unable to know that, Allah, the Glorified and Exalted, does not hold him accountable. Allah, the Glorified and Exalted, therefore said:

﴿ وَمَا كُنَّا مُعَذِّبِينَ حَتَّىٰ نَبْعَثَ رَسُولًا ﴾
“We would never punish until We had sent a Messenger.” [17:15]

Creed, the Universal Idea, and the Intellectual Basis

Brother Muhammad Mansour asks: Is there a difference between these terms: creed, universal idea, intellectual basis, solution to the biggest knot? Are they one and the same thing, or is there a specific definition for each? Yes, they are all names and attributes for one thing. We say “creed” in the sense that it is the idea upon which the human heart has settled, and it is also a contemporary term applied to the universal idea about the universe, the human being, and life—that is, the fundamental idea. As for the universal idea, it is an idea that gives an idea about everything surrounding the human being. The human being is the greatest reality living within the human being; he is a human living in the universe. Thus, it is an idea about the human being, life, and the universe; it is a universal idea about the reality in which the human being lives, giving him an answer to the greatest realities he experiences. As for it being the intellectual basis or the intellectual basis, it is so because it is the foundation of all ideas, because it provides or solves the biggest knot in the human being, and it gives the human being a universal idea about the universe, the human being, and life. It was worthy and the sole entitled to be the fundamental idea, so we named it the intellectual basis—that is, the basis upon which all the human being’s ideas are built—and it is the solution to the biggest knot. We have previously explained why it is the solution to the biggest knot, because it solves a problem or answers the basic questions of the human being; if he answers them, he can then answer all other questions. Thus, they are names and attributes for one thing.

Is Enlightened Thinking Exclusive to the Creed?

Kanan Hamza asks: Is enlightened thinking limited to the creed, or can enlightened thinking be about everything, not limited to the creed, and is it not required to be about everything? As for it not being limited to the creed, certainly, it is a faculty in the human being; enlightened thinking is a faculty in the human being, and thus it is a faculty that can be used and relied upon in his life where necessary. Thus, naturally, this thinking is not exclusive to the creed. As I mentioned earlier by example, a politician thinks in an enlightened manner, and one who does not possess enlightened thinking and is not accustomed to thinking in an enlightened manner is not fit to be a politician or a leader, nor to be interested in public affairs and a guardian of the most prominent matters of the state. What is most prominent in politicians, in men of politics, in men of the state, is not that they possess clear enlightened thinking; rather, what is most prominent in them is enlightened thinking, because they always look beyond the event, not at the event itself. This is not all; for example, criminal investigators rely primarily on enlightened thinking. They come to the crime scene to see the traces of the crime, and then they analyse, deduce, and arrive at the culprit by linking the pieces of the matter together, step by step, until they reach the culprit. They reach the culprit by following his traces. This is what is called enlightened thinking.

Conclusion and Introduction to the Next Halaqa

My dear brothers, let us suffice with this extent of questions today, and we ask Allah, the Glorified and Exalted, that He may have benefited us and may benefit us with further benefit through these topics and these episodes.

In the next episode, Allah willing, we will begin with you in applying the rules we established in the first and second episodes. We will begin by establishing the evidence for the Islamic creed, foremost among which is proving the existence of the Creator and Arranger, the Glorified and Exalted. So be with us next Monday. Peace be upon you, and the mercy of Allah and His blessings.

In this Halaqa

Language and display

Reading language
Subtitles
Text size
Theme
Playback speed
Download SRT subtitles

Copy and share