All Halaqaat
EN

Halaqa 51

Morals in Islam

About this Halaqa

Full title: The System of Islam — Halaqa 51: Morals in Islam

Lecturer: Sheikh Ahmad al-Qasas
Series: Explanation of The System of Islam
Date: 8 October 2018 — 28 Muharram 1440 AH

Video with subtitles

Full transcript

From the bookThe System of IslamSixth edition · 2001pp. 147–148

Text from the Book

Morals do not affect the building of a society, because society is built upon the systems of life and is affected by emotions and thoughts. So, morals have no effect in establishing the society or determining its ascent or decline. Instead, the effective factor is the general custom (al-urf al-aam) that stems from the concepts about life. Society is not steered by morals, but by the systems applied within it and the thoughts and emotions people carry. Indeed, morals themselves stem from the thoughts, emotions and result from the implementation of the system.

View book source

Introduction

Peace and blessings of Allah be upon you. Welcome, my brothers, to another new episode of your programme broadcast live. Today’s topic is of the utmost importance: morals in Islam. I am not here to enumerate all the moral qualities prescribed by Islam or to list every verse and hadith that addresses this subject. Nor do I intend to instruct people on the virtues of Islamic character in this session alone. Rather, within the context of our previous episodes—particularly those under the title Intellectual Leadership in Islam—I wish to discuss the critical role of morals in carrying the da’wah. Are morals essential components of societal formation? Do nations rise or decline based on their moral quality? Is civilisation built upon ethical foundations? This is the subject we address today.

Preachers, guides and carriers of the da’wah often emphasise that morals are the foundation of society’s structure. Nations elevate themselves through moral conduct but decline when it weakens or disappears entirely. This idea is frequently echoed in public discourse by preachers, speakers and teachers, particularly through a renowned verse by Ahmad Shawqi, Amir al-Shu’ara’, who stated: “Nations endure only as long as their morals remain; if their morals perish, they too will perish.” Such claims are supported by Qur’anic verses that exhort moral excellence and highlight its significance for Muslims, alongside the sayings of the Prophet (saw). Among the most cited by preachers is his well-known hadith: “I have been sent to perfect moral qualities.” [Bayhaqi 21301] Another version reads: “I have been sent to complete virtuous conduct.” [Ahmad 8952] This tradition has multiple narrations.

Morals as a Component of the Islamic Personality

Respected brothers, there is no doubt that Islamic morals are among the essential components of a Muslim’s personality and of the Islamic character. For an individual to possess a truly Islamic personality, their moral foundation must be built upon the Islamic creed.

The foundation of forming an Islamic personality lies in its core thought being the Islamic creed—the comprehensive understanding of the universe, humanity, and life—which provides a perspective on existence, imparts meaning to one’s life, and establishes a purpose for living. This creed determines one’s path through life and outlines the principles governing conduct.

When examining the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger (saw), we find that after matters of creed, the commands and prohibitions are distributed among worships, transactions, and morals.

Consequently, for a believer to develop an Islamic personality, their creed must first and foremost be Islamic—it is the foundation and gateway to Islam. One cannot be a Muslim unless they are a believer who has embraced the Islamic creed.

After establishing one’s creed, the formation of their personality must be completed by ensuring that their worships are Islamic, their transactions with people are Islamic, and their morals are Islamic.

Here we recall hadiths of the Prophet (saw) that show the importance of morals in forming the Islamic personality. He said: ‘Among those of you whom I love most and who will sit closest to me on the Day of Resurrection are those with the best morals: the approachable and easy-going, who feel affection for others and receive affection from them.’ [Tirmidhi 2018; al-Tabarani 6].

Thus, the Prophet (saw) clarified that among people with the strongest faith are those whom He loves most—they are those whose morals are the best. The noblest of you in moral quality are those who strengthen communities: the humble ones who know how to make friends and win hearts through inherent goodness and noble conduct.

The Place of Morals Among Islamic Rulings

It is inherently erroneous to elevate morals above faith, let alone above worships and transactions. The error lies in placing them above worships—even transactions—for worships and transactions are matters of obligation, while prohibitions apply only partially, as they do in many cases where commands and prohibitions coexist. Indeed, morals also encompass both obligations and prohibitions.

There are moral qualities that Allah, exalted is He, has commanded adherence to—such as truthfulness, trustworthiness, righteousness, fulfilling covenants, and a cheerful demeanour—and others from which He has forbidden deviation, including lying, deceit, lewdness, and treachery. These commands and prohibitions are obligations upon the believer by virtue of their faith in Allah, exalted is He, and their belief in His religion.

Obedience to Allah, Not Benefit

It is not permissible for adherence to morals to be based on anticipated benefit. Whoever upholds moral qualities merely in expectation of material gain or social approval has not obeyed Allah, exalted is He.

For just as you fulfil the worships—such as prayer, fasting, pilgrimage and zakat—and adhere to the Shariah rules of transactions out of faith in Allah, exalted is He, so too must your obedience be for His sake alone, seeking His pleasure.

Commitment to morals must be commitment to Allah the Exalted, in submission to His commands and avoidance of what He has forbidden.

The value that the believer attains, and seeks to attain by observing morals, is the moral value: obeying Allah ﷻ, seeking His pleasure, and avoiding His anger and punishment.

The Morals of the Carrier of the Da’wah

Thus, morals are a fundamental component of an individual’s character. If they are essential for every Muslim, then the carrier of the da’wah is undoubtedly the most deserving to uphold them, since he must lead by example in adhering to all of Shariah and embodying a complete Islamic personality.

Moreover, adherence to morals facilitates the carrier’s connection with people, earning their affection while making him beloved among them.

Allah’s address to His Messenger was also an address to his Ummah. Allah ﷻ therefore said to the Prophet (saw):

﴿ فَبِمَا رَحْمَةٍۢ مِّنَ ٱللَّهِ لِنتَ لَهُمْ وَلَوْ كُنتَ فَظًّا غَلِيظَ ٱلْقَلْبِ لَٱنفَضُّوا۟ مِنْ حَوْلِكَ ﴾
‘It is by Allah’s mercy that you were gentle with them. Had you been harsh and hard-hearted, they would have dispersed from around you.’ [3:159]

The Prophet (saw) was believed in by his Companions and all people due to their conviction in the decisive proofs that he is Allah’s Messenger. They followed his Shariah rules in obedience to Allah the Exalted, certain that what he brought was from Him—since he carried miracles confirming his prophethood.

This Prophet, whom people followed because they were certain that he was Allah’s Messenger, is the very one about whom Allah ﷻ says, addressing him:

﴿ وَلَوْ كُنتَ فَظًّا غَلِيظَ ٱلْقَلْبِ لَٱنفَضُّوا۟ مِنْ حَوْلِكَ ﴾
‘Had you been harsh and hard-hearted, they would have dispersed from around you.’ [3:159]

The Messenger of Allah, who brings news from heaven and receives revelation—would people disperse from around him! This is what Allah ﷻ says: if he had been harsh and hard-hearted—and far be it from Allah’s Messenger to be so—

﴿ وَلَوْ كُنتَ فَظًّا غَلِيظَ ٱلْقَلْبِ لَٱنفَضُّوا۟ مِنْ حَوْلِكَ ﴾
‘Had you been harsh and hard-hearted, they would have dispersed from around you.’ [3:159]

If the Messenger of Allah (saw) could have faced people dispersing from around him had he been harsh and hard-hearted, then what of the carriers of the da’wah, who are human beings?

Human beings possess human nature and are not infallible, unlike the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him). They are reproached whenever they disobey Allah’s commands or violate His prohibitions—including neglecting good moral qualities or committing bad conduct.

Thus, carriers of the da’wah must fully adhere to Islam and embody a complete Islamic character in all aspects, including their role in carrying the da’wah—and this includes possessing good moral quality. However…

Do Morals Build Societies?

Despite all that has been mentioned, is it claimed that morals build societies or that nations elevate themselves through moral qualities? Or if one wishes to establish a civilisation, must they focus solely on cultivating moral quality? Such statements have no truthful basis and are entirely unsupported—neither by the Shariah nor by observable reality nor by history.

Societies do not consist of morals as one of their fundamental components. While morals may adorn them or make people within them shine, a society is not formed through moral qualities alone.

How Does a Society Form?

We have previously discussed this topic, but society forms because people need to gather and interact, establishing reciprocal relationships for mutual benefit. Since ancient times, individuals were incapable of living alone; thus, they had no alternative but to come together—to exchange shared interests and ward off common dangers—by forming relations and thereby constituting a society.

How does this society become a community? It becomes one through what establishes relationships among people, examining the nature of these relationships: what creates them and what leads to their collapse or dissolution.

We see that people only unite when their ideas align. Their opinions—concepts regarding benefits and interests—are what bring them together into a single society.

When their concepts agree on what is good and what is evil, but if they differ in opinion over the distinction between good and bad, then no relations can be established among them. Thus, the fundamental basis for forming relationships—so that people may become a society—is a unified system of ideas; when these ideas converge, community-building begins.

Shared Emotions

We also observe that shared emotions unite people in society. This is most evident in communities characterised by emotional intensity—communities from which Islam deliberately distances itself—but it serves as proof that emotions play a fundamental role in the formation of societies.

Observe now European societies: despite sharing one culture and living by the same way of life, their multiplicity of emotions still renders them distinct nations. The Europeans have failed to form a single nation within one state, even though they live identically and constitute a unified civilisation. French national sentiment persists in making the French a separate people, German nationalism keeps the Germans as a distinct nation from others, and British national pride maintains the British as a distinct entity without merging with other peoples—hence we see them now inclined toward separation from the European Union on grounds of nationalist sentiment. We shall not elaborate further on this matter at present.

Yet I wish to say here that it is the emotions which unite or divide people that play a fundamental role in forming society—or, conversely, in unravelling its cohesion.

Islamic Society: Thoughts, Emotions and Systems

Islam established that the emotions of the Islamic community are bound to the Islamic creed, closely linked to the principles that united these people. It ensured that emotions were inseparable from thoughts, neither allowing nor permitting them to exist independently.

Thus did we find in the Islamic society that tribal sentiments dissolved, only to be replaced by feelings of loyalty to Allah—loyalty to Him, His Messenger and the believers. The emotions within the Islamic community were those arising from Islam’s principles.

From this, we see that the Islamic society was formed from a single culture producing sentiments that united people upon the foundation of this creed, its derived ideas and the systems it engendered.

This is the third pillar in shaping society: its life systems. We observe that the systems applied within a society complete its identity; thus, societal identity cannot be formed without these implemented systems. A capitalist society must necessarily operate under capitalist systems—otherwise, it would not qualify as a capitalist society. The Western world was termed a ‘capitalist society’ because it emerged from capitalist ideas, became associated with certain capitalist emotions, and adopted capitalist systems, thereby constituting itself as a capitalist society.

Similarly, the Islamic society is Islamic because it was founded upon the Islamic creed. The ideas that established relationships among people and united their bonds were concepts of Islam, while the strength of these relational ties lay in emotions tied to the Islamic creed and its principles. It was then the application of Shariah rules that completed the structure of the Islamic society.

Thus, the Islamic society is one built upon the Islamic creed, so its thoughts are Islamic, its emotions are Islamic, and the systems applied within it are those of Islam.

Morals Are a Feature of Society, Not One of Its Components

Therefore, the components of society are ideas, emotions, and systems. It is incorrect to say that morals constitute society or build it or give it its identity.

No—yes; every society has a distinct pattern in terms of moral qualities and ethics. However, this is not because these morals and ethics shaped the society itself, but rather because the concepts, emotions, and systems that formed it produced those particular moral qualities.

When the Islamic society embodies Islam’s ideas, sentiments, and systems, it becomes evident that this community is adorned with Islamic morals and radiates its moral qualities. More than that, what makes this society so attractive—the luminous quality visible on its face—is precisely these Islamic morals, which form a compelling draw for people.

However, those who join this society do not become part of it merely by adopting the moral qualities they observe among Muslims. Their morality does not need to be Islamic in itself; rather, they become members only when they embrace Islam’s creed, carry its ideas and sentiments, commit to its systems, and submit to them. Only then do they truly belong to this society.

Morals within a society are among its defining traits—they adorn the Islamic community. The moral qualities of Islam constitute one aspect of its appeal to other nations: what surfaces and permeates it is the result of Islamic creed, Islamic concepts, and Islamic sentiments—qualities strengthened by Islam’s systems.

Critique of Building Society Through Morals

It is therefore incorrect for such an approach to emerge in our times—as we widely observe today—.

Many da’wah carriers, preachers, guides, and speakers claim that the Ummah’s problem lies in its morals. They say that if Islamic moral qualities return to the Muslim community, it will revive. This is superficial reasoning: nations do not rise through morals alone or etiquette alone—even though Allah has commanded both. We emphasise this so no one misinterprets us as dismissing morals; they are indeed important and essential components of a believer’s character. Yet societies are not built upon them alone.

If associations arise on the basis that they call for morals and seek to build society through them, aiming to revive the former glory of the Muslim community by reviving Islamic moral qualities, this is a deviation from the correct path and a turning away from it. For it is upon ideas that nations are built; thus, what must be said—with equal weight as Ahmad Shawqi stated—is: “Nations remain only so long as their ideas endure.” If their ideas vanish, then they too perish.

Why Islamic Society Declined

When the Islamic nation declined and fell behind, and its state collapsed, its issue was not with morals. Our ancestors inform us that there was elevation in moral qualities during their time, while Muslims today have deviated in their moral conduct. So why did the Islamic State fall? Why has Muslim society declined? Simply because the components of the Islamic society were shaken until a time came when they collapsed, and thus the entire Islamic society collapsed.

The Islamic society was Islamic because it consisted of Islam’s ideas, its concepts, its emotions, and its systems.

When Muslims adopted Western ideas, which infiltrated their societal composition and thought processes—causing disruption in their Islamic thoughts—they also experienced disturbances in their emotions. Nationalist and patriotic sentiments entered their hearts, while tribal and clan-based feelings were revived anew; this too contributed to the disintegration of society.

That society then weakened further. When Muslims either applied or were subjected to systems other than those of Islam, the Islamic community lost its identity and transformed from being an Islamic society into a non-Islamic one—one without colour, flavour, or distinct identity. For it neither fully abandoned Islam nor completely embraced capitalism; thus, it became a society devoid of identity, character, or way of life, leading the nation to its current state of decline.

The Path to Revival

The path to revival, then, lies in restoring the components of Islamic society: Islam’s thoughts must be clear in the minds of Muslims and understood by them; their outlook on life must accord with what Islam brought; their emotions must be attached to Islam; and they must return to applying Islam’s systems. Their society will then return, and it will naturally shine and flourish with Islamic morals, because Islamic morals are the result of faith, Islamic thoughts and emotions, and the establishment of Muslim society.

This is what I intended to convey today regarding this segment on morals. Thank you for your kind listening and attentiveness. May Allah’s prayers and peace be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family, companions, and all those who support him. Peace and mercy of Allah be upon you.

Questions and Discussion

Welcome again as we address some of the questions posed by you, my noble brothers.

Placing Morals Above Obligations and the Degrees of Moral Rulings

My dear sister, may peace and blessings of Allah be upon you. Many people mistakenly believe that morals are the foundation of everything—they claim a person may neglect prayer or a woman may fail to observe hijab as long as their heart is pure and their moral quality is good. However, when called to adhere to Shariah rules, they argue: “Look at those who are religiously committed—what matters most is that the heart be sound.” How should one respond? Are there degrees in morals or absolute limits beyond which a Muslim cannot compromise without sinning? Must a Muslim resemble angels in both moral quality and worship to be considered truly Islamic? The signature appears to belong either to Aisha or Hamza, meaning we have two names—by Allah…

Of course, I will not dwell extensively on those who speak against or belittle the observance of Shariah rules while elevating morals above them to such an extent that they consider morals as the entirety of commitment and all of Islam. Their statements stem regrettably either from ignorance of Allah’s religion or from stubbornness in claiming that what truly matters is having good morals, without requiring adherence to worships, transactions, or compliance with Islamic legislation. Such discourse naturally originates only from those who have severed ties with the faith by dismissing the obligation of Shariah rules, neglecting duties, and abandoning prescribed obligations. This constitutes a denial of fundamental truths inherent in Islam: whoever diminishes the importance of prayer, fasting, zakah, or pilgrimage—or any other obligatory act—has effectively disbelieved in Allah’s religion, for they contradict what Allah has affirmed.

Regarding the question of whether there are degrees in morals or absolute limits that cannot be compromised: the principle is clear—whatever Allah commands with a definitive commandment is obligatory. Whatever He requests from us definitively is also obligatory, whether it pertains to worships, transactions, or moral qualities. Fundamentally, Shariah does not classify legal rulings into categories of worships, transactions, and morals; this classification is merely our own terminological distinction. Rather, anything Allah commands with a definitive commandment must be adhered to, and whoever neglects such an obligation incurs sin.

And whatever Allah forbids—whether in matters of food, clothing, transactions, or moral qualities—we must abstain from it. There is what Allah commands definitively; adherence to it is obligatory, and whoever neglects it incurs sin deserving punishment. There is also what Allah forbids definitively: this constitutes the haram (unlawful). If a moral quality has been forbidden by Allah definitively—such as lying, betrayal of trust, or disobedience to parents—and so forth—all such morals are prohibited by Him absolutely. Indeed, some of these forbidden traits reach the level of major sins, for example, disobedience to one’s parents. Thus, whatever Allah forbids definitively is inherently unlawful and must be avoided by a believer; if they commit it, they incur sin deserving punishment.

Just as Shariah rules include what is absolutely forbidden and what is merely disliked (makruh).

Similarly, whatever Allah commands without definitive obligation falls under recommended acts. Allah, through the words of His Prophet (saw), commanded smiling at a Muslim’s face: “Your smile towards your brother’s face is charity.” [Tirmidhi 1956] However, this command is clearly not definitive. Thus, it can be stated that smiling in the presence of a believer is recommended. If a believer performs it, they will earn reward; if they do not, no sin attaches to them for its omission.

Thus, when Allah commands us with an absolute decree regarding morals, it is incumbent upon us to uphold them, and whoever neglects this incurs sin. When He prohibits certain moral qualities with an absolute ban, they become forbidden, and committing them entails guilt. When commanded without strict obligation, performing such acts leads to elevation before Allah (Exalted be He) and earns reward; no blame arises if one refrains. Similarly, when prohibited without stringent force, abandoning these acts yields merit, while compliance incurs no sin. This is the criterion by which we distinguish what must be adhered to from what is merely recommended.

Of course, no human being can be like the angels. Allah ﷻ created the angels without the capacity to disobey or to choose. They do what they are commanded:

﴿ لَا يَعْصُونَ ٱللَّهَ مَآ أَمَرَهُمْ وَيَفْعَلُونَ مَا يُؤْمَرُونَ ﴾
‘They do not disobey Allah in what He commands them, and they do as they are commanded.’ [66:6]

They have no capacity to disobey Him. Therefore, they are not described as legally responsible in the way that humans and jinn are. A human being cannot be an angel. A believer observes the rules of the Shariah, but may have shortcomings in his morals, which he must avoid whenever they occur. The saying of the Prophet (saw) applies to every believer: ‘Every son of Adam sins, and the best of those who sin are those who repent.’ [al-Tirmidhi 2499].

The Relationship Between Creed, Thoughts and Morals

Sister Darah al-Ghaliyah also sent a second question: Is there a relationship between the thoughts and principles within a person and their moral qualities?

For a believer, the ideology—that is, the Islamic creed—must certainly be reflected in his morals. Faith requires observance of Allah’s commands and prohibitions. There is a well-known saying, though it is not a hadith of the Prophet (saw): ‘Faith is what settles in the heart and is confirmed by action.’ Allah ﷻ says:

﴿ قُلْ إِن كُنتُمْ تُحِبُّونَ ٱللَّهَ فَٱتَّبِعُونِى يُحْبِبْكُمُ ٱللَّهُ وَيَغْفِرْ لَكُمْ ذُنُوبَكُمْ ﴾
‘Say: If you love Allah, follow me; Allah will love you and forgive your sins.’ [3:31]

Say: ‘My Lord is Allah,’ then remain steadfast. ‘Say: I believe in Allah, then remain steadfast.’ [Muslim 38].

Faith necessitates that the entire conduct of the believer be bound by Allah’s commands and prohibitions. Thus, the morals of the believer are but the fruit of their faith: if you have believed, then it is incumbent upon you to adhere to what Allah has commanded and abstain from what He has forbidden.

Yes, the moral qualities of all other people—including non-believers—are largely tied to their worldview. However, this is not the case for Muslims; a Muslim adheres to obedience to Allah in hope of His reward and Paradise, and in fear of His punishment. By nature, the believer’s creed manifests in every action, every behaviour, and every relationship: his relationship with Allah, his relationship with himself, and his relationships with all other people.

Are the Individual’s Morals a Component of Society?

The devout brother asks: “You say that society is composed of individuals, thoughts, emotions and systems.” I reply more precisely that it consists of people, ideas, feelings and systems. He then states that morals are among the components of the individual; since the individual is made up of the components of society—which itself comprises those same components—it follows that every component of the individual, including morals, is part of society. What do you say?

The matter is not so straightforward: many individuals possess unique attributes and moral qualities unrelated to society’s foundational elements. While these personal traits become visible in human interactions, what I have stated here is that the morals exhibited by individuals are not what establish society. Rather, they emerge within society and relationships spontaneously. However, when a society forms, it does so through its core components: shared ideas—meaning common concepts—shared opinions, collective emotions, and systems regulating these relationships. Morality is therefore not among society’s foundational elements; as previously mentioned, moral qualities are characteristics that define an existing society and arise from its interactions, shaped by its thoughts, feelings, and institutional frameworks.

At times, we observe certain manifestations in society and assume these traits define the community. Yet the relationship is inverted: it is society itself that produces such moral qualities—not those qualities that create society. The Islamic community generates virtuous morals and embodies them.

This is because the Islamic society, by its very nature, influences individuals; when these individuals are shaped by it, they become Islamic personalities. Thus, their moral qualities being Islamic becomes part of their character formation, making the society appear adorned with such virtues. However, these morals did not establish that society—they were not among its foundational components.

Do Morals Unite the Ummah?

Brother Awni Toubassi says: “A society without morals will never succeed in this world. Morality unites the nation; your argument is utterly unconvincing.”

I have my proofs for what I say, and you may respond with your own. If you claim not to be convinced, that is between you and yourself—I cannot force conviction by sheer power. What I told you was that society adorns itself through the moral qualities of its people and distinguishes itself accordingly. Yet it is not these morals themselves that produce society—that is our assertion.

Society can never succeed in this world without morals. Morals do not unify a nation; rather, if there were no shared customs and systems, nations would not unite. There exists no society unified solely by morals—this is mere rhetoric that people may prefer or wish to hear: the idea of communities gathering around shared moral qualities alone. Such unity does not occur in reality. Societies coalesce through common customs and established systems; without these, no societies could exist. These customs give rise to moral qualities, which then shape the distinctive traits of such societies—among them, morals themselves.

The Hadith of ’Inah and Returning to the Religion

Brother Youssef Douek asks what is understood from the final part of the hadith of al-‘aynah, where the Prophet (saw) said in its conclusion: «Allah will impose upon you humiliation that shall not be lifted until you return to your religion» [Abu Dawud 3462].

In simplicity, the Prophet (saw) informs us that if we deviate from Islam in our dealings, we destroy the components of Islamic society. This leads to decline—from this decline comes a state of humiliation for people—for when a community regresses and degenerates, it weakens and thus becomes susceptible to subjugation by its enemies, whether internal or external.

The reality of humiliation we witness today is evidence of this: when Islamic society lost its components, the Ummah fell behind and declined, resulting in disgrace, degradation, and defeat—just as the Prophet’s (saw) saying foretold.

Changing Thoughts Amid Corrupt Morals

Brother Muhammad Al-Qadir, do you believe that thoughts can be transformed into Islamic ones while morals and thoughts themselves remain corrupt?

The Prophet (saw) came with a message to transform faith in the Islamic creed within a society whose creed was corrupted and many of whose moral qualities were likewise corrupted. Among them, there were certain moral qualities that Islam affirmed but restructured upon its own foundation—rather than leaving them as they were under pre-Islamic Arab pagan traditions. Islam transformed belief itself, altered faith, changed conviction, and shifted the perspective on life.

This shift in outlook toward life and its meaning automatically led to a change in people’s concepts of things, altering their emotions and the nature of their feelings. Consequently, they naturally found within themselves moral qualities demanded by the Islamic creed—qualities that faith itself required. The creed was established first; upon it were built thoughts, which people then adhered to. Thus, alongside this adherence emerged moral qualities, for whoever committed himself to Islam’s ideas and Shariah rules based on establishing the creed would inevitably adhere to Islamic morals, since the creed demanded it of him—and his faith likewise required it.

Does This Mean Abandoning the Call to Good Morals?

Brother Abdullah asks: You are aware of the harmful effects of the absence of morals in Muslim life today. Does such discourse mean disregarding the call to embody Islamic moral qualities—such as sincerity and trustworthiness in trade and transactions, as well as courage?

My dear brother, whoever listens to this episode from beginning to end will hear clearly that morals are an integral part of Islam’s commands. They comprise divine injunctions and prohibitions from Allah—the Exalted, who commanded prayer, truthfulness, charity, kindness, fasting, honesty in worship and transactions, and Islamic moral qualities while forbidding evil conduct. All these are His commands and prohibitions, which must be strictly adhered to.

The discussion was not about this; rather, it addressed: if one seeks to build society, should they construct it upon morals or upon the Islamic creed—along with the thoughts, emotions, and systems that arise from it? In this case, morals become a consequence of adhering to Islam, rather than being the foundation on which society is built. There is a distinction between saying that morals are the result of commitment to Islam and the establishment of an Islamic society, and claiming: “I wish to build a society upon morals alone.”

Morals do not establish societies; they produce individuals who appear pleasing—whom people love and who are loved in return. Yet the beloved person does not construct a community. Many are beloved, but they fail to foster sound relationships among people or engage with others due to their perspective on matters, contracts, and social connections.

There is a fundamental difference between stating that morals are obligatory—on which there is no disagreement—and asserting that the carrier of the da’wah must embody high moral qualities—also undisputed—and claiming that societies are built upon morals or that their foundation lies in them—a claim unsupported by either reality or Shariah.

Courage and Holding the Ruler Accountable

The learned brother asks: Is courage not a moral quality? And the hadith states, “Hamza is the chief of martyrs; and there is a man who stood up to an oppressive ruler, commanded him and forbade him until he killed him” [Al-Hakim 4884]. If it were not for the moral quality of courage, would that man have risen to command or forbid? Is this not proof of the necessity of calling people to moral qualities?

Here, this act may be considered part of morals because it involves courage. However, its requirement does not stem from being a moral quality in itself but rather arises from the nature of one’s relationship with the Ruler—Allah, the Exalted. Through His Prophet (saw), He established a specific form of accountability toward the ruler: whenever he transgresses, he must be held to account, whether through speech, writing, demonstration, or action. The ultimate expression of this accountability is that an individual may bear it even unto martyrdom—that one might be killed in upholding such accountability. Thus, this matter was not prescribed as a mere moral virtue, though it encompasses great moral qualities.

Yet, this subject pertains to the inherent nature of relationships ordained by Islam between the ruler and the ruled—specifically, that society must hold its ruler accountable. The core issue here concerns societal relations: among the established relationships within a community is that between the ruler and those he governs. What defines this relationship is precisely that society and its members must hold their ruler to account. One manifestation of such accountability is courage in confronting the ruler, which may include noble moral qualities—but the primary focus lies not on morals themselves but on the relational framework within society.

For example, jihad is a matter of Shariah legislation and does not fall under ethics. Yet just as this stance here includes the moral quality of courage, so too must a mujahid possess bravery; without it, they cannot wage jihad. It would be incorrect to say that calling for jihad is an appeal to morals—though it indeed encompasses noble traits such as bravery, generosity, strength, and dignity. Nevertheless, its essence lies in the foundational relationships that constitute society, which inherently incorporate Islamic moral qualities by nature.

Comment on the Components of Society

Peace and blessings be upon you. Based on the components of society, we can say that there are currently no sound societies; this is not a true elevation or revival. This comment concludes with gratitude: thank you. May Allah bless you all and reward you with goodness.

The Morals of the Carriers of the Da’wah

Sister Umm Musab Darin greets you with peace and blessings from Allah. May Allah exalt your voice and bless the efforts you exert for the enlightenment of the Muslim nation. May He honour you all. I wish to remind you that we should advise Muslims in general—and particularly those carrying the da’wah—to uphold high moral qualities, far removed from arrogance and self-importance, and distant from a hardened heart or harsh demeanour. This is in strict adherence to the commands of the Prophet (saw).

I believe, my dear sister, that what I said during this session was very clear: if morals are among the components of a Muslim individual and the defining traits of an Islamic personality, then those who carry the da’wah—being Islamic personalities in their own right, and even more so because they convey Islam and goodness to people—are the most deserving of upholding these moral qualities. They are foremost in their commitment to Islam as a whole, including morals; indeed, they must embody them above all others, for such conduct either positively or negatively influences how they carry the da’wah to the people.

I cited Allah’s words, and I repeat them, in which He addresses His Prophet (saw):

﴿ فَبِمَا رَحْمَةٍۢ مِّنَ ٱللَّهِ لِنتَ لَهُمْ وَلَوْ كُنتَ فَظًّا غَلِيظَ ٱلْقَلْبِ لَٱنفَضُّوا۟ مِنْ حَوْلِكَ ﴾
‘It is by Allah’s mercy that you were gentle with them. Had you been harsh and hard-hearted, they would have dispersed from around you.’ [3:159]

The matter concerns the carrier of the da’wah, who is keen that people do not disperse from around him, however elevated and correct his words may be. Here is the Prophet (saw), the best of mankind, speaking through revelation, yet Allah ﷻ says to him:

﴿ وَلَوْ كُنتَ فَظًّا غَلِيظَ ٱلْقَلْبِ لَٱنفَضُّوا۟ مِنْ حَوْلِكَ ﴾
‘Had you been harsh and hard-hearted, they would have dispersed from around you.’ [3:159]

Yes, the carriers of the da’wah are the people most deserving of lofty morals, noble qualities and refined manners.

Yes, how painful it is when one sees a brother strong in thought who knows how to refute opposing views and engage in debate while proving his arguments—yet he combines this strength of evidence with harshness and vulgarity in speech. This causes people to turn away from the power of his argument toward the coarseness of his words, leading them to distance themselves from him and use it as justification to deter others from approaching him.

I urge my brothers among those carrying the da’wah who convey goodness to people: avoid harsh speech, refrain from severe language, and do not deliberately target individuals. Do not address a person who debates you or opposes your views personally; focus instead on the idea itself. Present your words in an attractive and pleasing manner so that they may easily enter the minds of people.

Obedience and Its Moral Fruit

Brother Hilal Al-Shami, peace be upon you and Allah’s mercy and blessings. Peace be upon you as well, with Allah’s mercy and blessings, and may Allah bless you all. I understand that if we listen to the words of Allah and obey them, then this obedience itself produces moral qualities. For example, if one hears Allah’s command regarding jihad or holding rulers accountable, the result is courage; whereas hearing His prohibition against lying yields truthfulness.

Yes, exactly. If you obey Allah ﷻ, one result of that obedience is that you possess good morals, whether the moral quality is commanded directly or results from the Shariah rules you were commanded to observe. Allah ﷻ says:

﴿ إِنَّ ٱلصَّلَوٰةَ تَنْهَىٰ عَنِ ٱلْفَحْشَآءِ وَٱلْمُنكَرِ ﴾
‘Indeed, prayer restrains from indecency and wrongdoing.’ [29:45]

One result of prayer is that it produces good morals. Some morals also result from observing Allah’s commands and prohibitions and from observing the rules of the Shariah. Other morals are observed by the Muslim because Allah ﷻ commanded them directly. Simply observing Allah’s commands and prohibitions produces morals.

However, to say that these morals alone are what build, create, and shape societies is incorrect. As I mentioned in the episode, many people mistakenly focus solely on morals by claiming: “If we produce a society with refined moral qualities, this community will rise and become one of elevation.” This statement is false; no matter how much emphasis you place on morals alone, they cannot produce an elevated society. Societies are constructed through ideas, concepts, the unity of people’s emotions, and the systems that define their identity.

Honourable brothers, these were today’s questions. I thank you for your attentive listening and pray to Allah, the Exalted, that He reward me and you with abundant good. May peace and blessings be upon the Messenger of Allah, his family, companions, and all those who follow them in truth. Peace, mercy, and blessings of Allah be upon you.

In this Halaqa

Language and display

Reading language
Subtitles
Text size
Theme
Playback speed
Download SRT subtitles

Copy and share