Introduction
In the name of Allah, the Most Merciful. Peace and blessings be upon you all. We praise Allah, exalted be He, and send prayers and peace upon His Messenger, may Allah bless him and grant him peace. Welcome, dear brothers, to this new episode of Halaqa Online.
Topic of the Halaqa: Choosing a Mujtahid and Transitioning Between Mujtahids
In today’s session—part of our series on the question: How do we follow Shari’ah?—we discussed Shari’ah legal rulings, their types and classifications; we examined ijtihad (diligent legal inquiry) and its practitioners, including the different categories of mujtahids. In the previous halaqa, we turned to the topic of muqallidun (imitators). We defined imitation (taqlid), distinguished it from ijtihad, and outlined the ranks among followers. This session addresses two key matters concerning imitators: how does an individual choose which mujtahid to follow? And once they have followed one mujtahid, may they later switch to following another? These are the two focal points of our discussion today.
Addendum: There is no imitation in creed.
But before addressing these two points, let me correct an omission from last time—by way of clarification: imitation (taqlid) is only permissible in matters of probabilistic Shari’ah legal rulings. The Muslim who lacks the capacity for ijtihad because he does not possess the necessary qualifications must necessarily imitate—but what? He imitates secondary Shari’ah legal rulings that require diligent inquiry, which he himself cannot derive.
Faith is valid only on the basis of evidence.
In the field of creed and belief, imitation is entirely invalid. It is never permissible for faith to be based on imitation. Faith—belief—is a firm conviction that aligns with reality and is supported by evidence. If a person lacks evidence for what they believe in, then this is not true faith at all. Allah, exalted is He, commanded people regarding matters of belief and creed to bring forth proof. He said:
﴿ قُلْ هَاتُوا۟ بُرْهَـٰنَكُمْ إِن كُنتُمْ صَـٰدِقِينَ ﴾
‘Bring your proof, if you are truthful.’ [2:111; 27:64],
and He said:
﴿ قُلْ هَلْ عِندَكُم مِّنْ عِلْمٍ فَتُخْرِجُوهُ لَنَآ ﴾
‘Say: Do you have any knowledge that you can produce for us?’ [6:148],
and He further stated:
﴿ فَأْتُونَا بِسُلْطَـٰنٍ مُّبِينٍ ﴾
‘Then bring us a clear proof.’ [14:10].
Allah, exalted is He, condemned those who inherit the religions of their forefathers, refusing to accept any new faith or belief—no matter how strong its evidence—if it contradicts what they found their ancestors upon.
﴿ وَإِذَا قِيلَ لَهُمُ ٱتَّبِعُوا۟ مَآ أَنزَلَ ٱللَّهُ قَالُوا۟ بَلْ نَتَّبِعُ مَآ أَلْفَيْنَا عَلَيْهِ ءَابَآءَنَآ ۗ أَوَلَوْ كَانَ ءَابَآؤُهُمْ لَا يَعْقِلُونَ شَيْـًٔا وَلَا يَهْتَدُونَ ﴾
‘When it is said to them, ‘Follow what Allah has revealed,’ they say, ‘No, we follow what we found our forefathers following.’ Even though their forefathers understood nothing and were not guided?’ [2:170].
Whoever follows parents, leaders, scholars or anyone else they trust in matters of iman and creed has wronged himself. He is not following the Shari’ah of Allah, Glorified and Exalted, His religion or His Messenger. He has made imitation his foundation, although iman can never be valid through imitation. In that case, he does not follow the creed itself; he follows the person whom he imitates in matters of creed.
It cannot be said that imitation is permissible in creed just as it is permissible in Shari’ah legal rulings that require ijtihad. This is entirely excluded, because iman is the foundation of human thought, the basis of one’s religion and life, and the foundation of one’s culture and entire way of life. It must therefore be firmly rooted with complete certainty. That is possible only when a person has personally derived the evidence for it. Allah, Glorified and Exalted, has therefore required people to establish evidence for the creed and iman they adopt. We have already recited some of the verses concerning this.
Deducing the foundations of faith is easy for every human being.
Nor can it be said that it may be difficult for an untrained person to derive evidence for faith on their own; such a claim is invalid because the matters we are commanded to believe in—to hold as conviction and thereby become Muslims—are easily demonstrable by every human being. Therefore, no one may imitate another regarding belief in Allah, saying: “I am a believer in Allah because I trust so-and-so, who told me that Almighty Allah exists.” This is not faith; rather, he must possess evidence from his own reasoning and thought that Allah is true—something accessible to every human being.
Likewise, it is impermissible to say: ‘I believe in the Book of Allah and in Muhammad as the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, because I trust the person who told me this.’ This is not iman. One must personally derive the evidence that the Qur’an is the speech of Allah and, consequently, that Muhammad is Allah’s Messenger. Through the definitive texts in Allah’s Book and the Sunnah of His Messenger, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, one must personally derive the evidence for belief in Allah, the angels and the Last Day. Such iman is therefore valid only on the basis of evidence.
There is no faith in imitation. Whoever imitates in matters of faith has not truly walked the path of faith—that is what I wished to highlight.
How does a muqallid choose his mujtahid?
We now turn to our topic: whom does a Muslim who lacks the qualifications for ijtihad follow? He must practise imitation (taqlid), because he cannot perform ijtihad himself. But whom does he follow? There is this mujtahid and that mujtahid, and there have been many mujtahids, although today we remember only a few famous names: al-Shafi‘i, Malik, Ahmad ibn Hanbal, Abu Hanifa, Zayd, Ja‘far and al-Awza‘i. The madhahib of some of these mujtahids have reached us almost in full, while only individual issues have been transmitted from others. In every case, the Muslim faces several madhahib—that is, several mujtahids. Whom should he choose?
The Mujtahids’ Ijtihads Are Shari’ah Legal Rulings
In fact, whether the Muslim muqallid follows this mujtahid or that one, he has adopted a Shari’ah legal ruling derived by a mujtahid, and his obligation is discharged. Whether he takes from one mujtahid or another, Imam al-Shafi‘i’s ijtihad is a Shari’ah legal ruling, Abu Hanifa’s ijtihad is a Shari’ah legal ruling, and the same applies to the ijtihad of Malik, Ahmad, al-Awza‘i, al-Thawri, Zayd and Ja‘far. All of them were mujtahid Imams who performed ijtihad. What they derived through ijtihad constitutes Shari’ah legal rulings, whether they were correct or mistaken in their ijtihad. We have already said, in a meaning-based quotation, that when a mujtahid performs ijtihad and is correct, he receives two rewards; and when he performs ijtihad and errs, he receives one reward. [al-Bukhari, 7352; Muslim, 1716].
The Prevailing Madhahib in Muslim Lands
The reality is that most Muslims naturally find people around them who follow a particular madhhab, so they find no one to teach them except according to that madhhab. Look at many Muslim lands today: in many of them, one madhhab has become widespread. In Morocco, most people follow the madhhab of Imam Malik. In Indonesia, most people are Shafi‘i. In Turkey, most are Hanafi. In the Arabian Peninsula, most people follow Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal, and so on.
The Teacher and Mufti Transmit from the Mujtahid
When a Muslim becomes legally responsible, he finds someone who teaches him according to the prevailing madhhab. By learning from him, he acquires a Shari’ah legal ruling. Of course, he does not imitate the person who taught him. If you studied under a shaykh and learned Shari’ah legal rulings from him, you did not imitate that shaykh, because he is not the mujtahid. He is a teacher or mufti who transmitted to you the ijtihad of a mujtahid.
Allah’s Ruling for the Muqallid
Once a Muslim has studied Shari’ah legal rulings according to a particular madhhab, his obligation is discharged and he has acquired a Shari’ah legal ruling through a valid ijtihad. Once he acts upon the ruling he learned, it becomes Allah’s ruling for him, and he will be held accountable before Allah according to it, because he adopted it through a valid Shari’ah method and acted upon it. Thus, if he learns how to pray according to the madhhab of Imam Abu Hanifa, adheres to it and prays accordingly, the Shari’ah legal rulings he took through Imam Abu Hanifa’s madhhab become Allah’s ruling for him.
Moving Before Acting Upon the Rulings
However, before moving on to the transition from one madhhab to another, I would say this: if a Muslim has learned Shari’ah legal rulings but has not yet acted upon them—that is, he has not practically applied them—he may, if he is confident in another mujtahid’s reasoning, adopt that mujtahid’s legal rulings instead. For example, suppose someone learns the Shari’ah legal rulings of Hajj according to a particular madhhab but has yet to perform Hajj. Later, they encounter a scholar who teaches the rules of Hajj based on another school and are reassured by this scholar’s greater knowledge, higher trustworthiness, and stronger moral integrity. They become convinced that it is appropriate for them to take their rulings—on Hajj and other matters—from this jurist or teacher rather than the one they initially learned from. In such a case, since they have not yet acted upon the legal rulings of the first madhhab they studied, there is no harm in shifting to another school’s rulings.
Moving After Acting Upon the Rulings
Once someone has begun acting upon Shari’ah legal rulings and adopted a particular madhhab as their source of imitation, Allah’s ruling becomes binding for them. Is it then permissible for them to switch to another madhhab?
Shari’ah Criteria for Choosing a Madhhab
Similarly, someone might ask: what if this learner has not yet committed to a particular madhhab and is presented with two options—one scholar teaching according to one school (for example, the Shafi’i) and another teaching according to another (such as the Hanafi)? How should they choose between these two scholars—and thus between these two schools? One teaches the Shafi’i rulings while the other teaches the Hanafi. Now, if this person wishes to learn Shari’ah legal rulings, how do they decide which madhhab—or even a third—to imitate? May he choose freely, as one may choose between a concession and a firm ruling, or between two permissible options?
No, the situation of the imitator is similar to that of a mujtahid presented with two pieces of evidence. He weighs them against each other until he reaches what is stronger. The mujtahid does not accept either piece of evidence outright but instead seeks reconciliation between them. If he cannot reconcile them, it becomes obligatory upon him to prefer one over the other based on his capacity and tools for ijtihad.
Similarly, the imitator has criteria for preference; however, these are not based on the strength of evidence because he lacks the ability to perform ijtihad. What he possesses is the ability to prefer between those who study these schools of thought: if he finds someone whom people testify as trustworthy and just, then he prefers that person over another. If he finds both are just and trustworthy, he takes from the one he trusts more in terms of justice and reliability. Here, he prefers among those who study them. If he trusts a particular teacher or shaykh who advises him to go and study with so-and-so, this becomes his preferred choice. If he finds that one individual is more pious than another, this also influences his preference. If he knows that a particular shaykh is one of the ruler’s scholars, he leaves him and goes to someone else. Integrity is the basis for receiving knowledge and for choosing among the mujtahids. It is also the basis for choosing those who transmit from the mujtahids, because whoever transmits from a mujtahid testifies that a particular mujtahid said such-and-such. He therefore bears testimony, and an essential condition of a witness is integrity.
Knowledge of the Principles as a Valid Criterion
When he is faced with several madhahib, he must therefore rely on criteria recognised by the Shari’ah. One such criterion may be that he has previously studied the Shafi‘i, Hanafi, Maliki and Hanbali madhahib, among others, and examined the legal principles of each to the extent of his ability and knowledge. He may then conclude that one madhhab—for example, the Shafi‘i madhhab—has stronger, firmer and more deeply rooted principles. This becomes a valid criterion for choosing someone who teaches Shari’ah legal rulings according to the Shafi‘i madhhab, or according to another madhhab whose principles he finds stronger. In this way, he has chosen a madhhab to follow.
One Need Not Follow a Single Madhhab in Every Issue
There is no requirement for a person to follow one madhhab in every issue. He may say, ‘I trust the Shafi‘i madhhab and will follow it in all matters.’ But he may also say, ‘I know a trustworthy shaykh who teaches the rulings of worship according to the Shafi‘i madhhab, so I will learn from him. However, I find that another person is stronger and more proficient in matters of transactions, even though he teaches them according to another madhhab, so I will take those rulings from him.’ The Companions would sometimes seek a fatwa from one mujtahid Companion and at other times from another. Neither the Companions nor the Followers relied upon a single senior Companion of the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, for every question. People sought a fatwa on one issue from one Companion and on another issue from a different Companion. No one said—and no evidence indicates—that a Muslim must follow a single madhhab in all his actions.
Transitions Between the Madhahib
However, if a person’s work becomes bound by the imitation of a particular school, then Allah’s ruling applies to him, and it becomes obligatory upon him to adhere to it. He may not shift to another school unless there are valid grounds for doing so. We shall now begin enumerating some of these grounds.
Moving from Lay Imitation to Being a Follower (Muttabi‘)
Suppose, for example, that he learned Shari’ah legal rulings from a teacher who taught him according to a particular madhhab without giving him the evidence. He thereby became a lay muqallid (‘ammi). We previously explained that imitation has two levels: the lay muqallid and the follower (muttabi‘), with the follower being the higher of the two. If he studies legal issues under a shaykh who teaches according to a particular madhhab without giving him the evidence for those issues, he remains a lay muqallid. If he then finds someone who teaches him the issues together with their evidence according to another madhhab, he becomes a follower rather than remaining a lay muqallid. This permits him to move from one madhhab to another, provided that he is confident in taking rulings from that teacher. We previously discussed the grounds for such confidence: integrity, knowledge and so forth. If he is confident in taking these Shari’ah legal rulings, together with their evidence, from another teacher of a different madhhab, this is preferable to what he took without evidence. It therefore permits him to move from one madhhab to another. This is one of the valid grounds for moving.
The Caliph’s Adoption Ends the Dispute
Naturally, there are circumstances where the muqallid must shift from following one school to another. As we previously stated regarding the mujtahid—if it is obligatory upon him, then it is even more so for the follower. We have already mentioned that among the cases requiring a mujtahid to abandon his own ijtihad in favour of another’s is when the Caliph—or rather, when the Islamic state—adopts an opinion contrary to his. If the Caliph or the Islamic state adopts an ijtihad differing from that of Imam al-Shafi’i, then it becomes obligatory upon him to cease acting according to his own reasoning and instead follow the ijtihad adopted by the Caliph—or rather, by the Islamic state. It is even more incumbent upon the muqallid to stop following al-Shafi‘i’s madhhab and instead follow and adhere to what the Caliph—or rather, the Islamic State—has adopted. This is because the Imam’s view resolves the dispute and is binding both outwardly and inwardly. This is therefore a case in which moving becomes obligatory.
Growth in knowledge of the principles of schools of jurisprudence
We now turn to another scenario that permits the muqallid to shift from following one madhhab to another. Suppose the muqallid began his imitation and studied under a particular school of thought while possessing only a certain level of religious knowledge and understanding of jurisprudential principles. Later, he devoted himself to reading books on fiqh and also read works on usul al-fiqh, thereby gaining familiarity with the foundational principles of Imam al-Shafi’i, Abu Hanifah, Malik, and others. After studying these texts and acquiring some meaningful knowledge in ijtihad and legal derivation, he developed an intellectual inclination—meaning that, based on what he had learned, he concluded that the strongest among them in terms of principles, jurisprudence, and reasoning was Imam al-Shafi’i. In this case, it is permissible—and indeed preferable—for him to transition from his previous imitation to following the ijtihad of another school, specifically to follow Imam al-Shafi’i’s madhhab, since he has inclined toward it intellectually.
Previous Trust in the Principles of Another Madhhab
Similarly, let us assume that someone initially believed in the strength of al-Shafi’i’s principles—principles being the foundation of legal rulings, their source and pathway from evidence to Shari’ah legal rulings. Suppose he was confident from the beginning in the strength of a particular school’s principles but found no one teaching him that school when he sought knowledge. Perhaps his teachers were not themselves trained in the very madhhab whose principles and rules of derivation he trusted, or perhaps there was simply no one available to instruct him according to that original school. In such a case, it is permissible for him to shift from one madhhab to another.
Uniting the Muslims
These are the cases where it is permissible for a Muslim to shift from imitating one madhhab to another based on valid Shari’ah considerations. Among them, as stated regarding the mujtahid himself: if the intention is to unite Muslims under a single position, then it is lawful for a follower (muqallid) to abandon his imitation just as it was permissible for the mujtahid to cease his ijtihad in favour of another. Thus, a muqallid may lawfully leave following one madhhab and adopt another. For example, suppose the Imam—the head of state—is not a mujtahid and follows a particular madhhab. If uniting the Muslims requires him to move from that madhhab to another, he may do so, just as occurred with the pledge of allegiance to ‘Uthman, may Allah be pleased with him, which we discussed in an earlier halaqa. This is also a valid ground for a muqallid to move from one madhhab to another.
The General Criterion for Transition
What I have just said, dear brothers, brings together some of the Shari’ah grounds and considerations that allow a muqallid to move from following one madhhab to another. Other grounds may also exist, provided that the consideration leading him to move proceeds from following Allah’s Book and the Sunnah of His Messenger, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, because Allah, exalted is He, says:
﴿ فَإِن تَنَـٰزَعْتُمْ فِى شَىْءٍ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَٱلرَّسُولِ ﴾
‘If you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger.’ [4:59].
Moving Out of Desire and Pursuing the Easier View
The rejected case in any transition from one madhhab to another is when it occurs out of personal inclination or desire—when someone finds a particular madhhab easier than the one he previously followed and thus shifts from imitating his original school to following another simply because it is simpler, more convenient, or more pleasing. In doing so, he becomes a follower of his own desires (muttabi’ al-hawa), whereas Allah, exalted is He, has forbidden following mere whims.
The Obligation to Take One Complete Issue from a Single Mujtahid
A final point I wish to highlight: if you study the Shari’ah legal rulings of an obligatory act—such as prayer, for example—you will find that prayer itself is a comprehensive Shari’ah legal ruling encompassing many others. It includes rules on purity and ablution, ghusl, nullifiers of ablution, nullifiers of purity, conditions for validity, pillars, recommended acts, and invalidators. Here we have an issue containing numerous sub-issues—each one a distinct Shari’ah legal ruling.
The validity of prayer therefore depends on a set of Shari’ah legal rulings. For one mujtahid, this set includes definitive rulings and rulings based on ijtihad. The second mujtahid likewise has a set: some rulings are definitive and agree with the first mujtahid, while others are probable and differ. If you imitate one of the mujtahids, you must take the entire issue from him, because you did not perform ijtihad yourself. Your prayer is not valid, your obligation is not discharged and your duty is not fulfilled on the basis of your own ijtihad, but on the basis of the ijtihad of the mujtahid whom you follow. You have placed your responsibility like a necklace around his neck. Your prayer must therefore be valid according to that mujtahid—or according to whichever other mujtahid you follow. It is not valid to mix different Shari’ah legal rulings relating to this single issue.
You perform ablution in accordance with the madhhab of Imam al-Shafi‘i, then pray following Abu Hanifa’s school. Or you simply say, ‘I have performed ablution.’ If a woman touches me, I declare: ‘I follow Abu Hanifa’s opinion because he holds that touching a woman does not invalidate ablution.’ But if I then come to pray according to the Shafi‘i madhhab, my prayer is invalid under Imam al-Shafi‘i’s rulings—because my ablution was incorrect; I touched a woman. In this case, I have not prayed validly in accordance with either the Shafi‘i or Abu Hanifa schools of law, nor based on my own ijtihad. So whose ruling makes my prayer valid? It is valid under none.
It is correct that you may follow more than one mujtahid, taking each matter from a different scholar. However, when addressing a single issue, it is obligatory to take the entire question—including all its Shari’ah legal rulings—from one mujtahid alone. You must derive prayer and everything related to it from one madhhab—for example, the Shafi’i school—and take fasting rules entirely from that same scholar or another. Likewise, you should learn all pilgrimage regulations from a single madhhab among those of the qualified mujtahids. In this way, if you are not yourself a mujtahid but rather a follower (muqallid), you will have truly followed someone and adopted a Shari’ah legal ruling that is Allah’s command upon you according to the ijtihad of one of the mujtahids.
Conclusion of the Halaqa’s Topic
This was our topic for today. I ask Allah, the Exalted, that He has guided me in clarifying this idea. If I have succeeded, then praise is due to Allah alone by His grace and guidance; if I have erred or fallen short, it is from myself. I ask Allah to forgive us and accept our repentance.
Questions and Discussions
Dear brothers, we have one question from Brother al-‘Abid. He says: many Muslims face a serious problem. They love particular shaykhs and regard everything they say as correct, so they follow them, believing that they should not question someone more knowledgeable than themselves. Does this discharge their obligation? I will illustrate the matter through the issues of participating in elections, ruling and obeying the ruler.
Blind Imitation and Trust in Shaykhs
Dear brothers, I discussed this matter in previous halaqaat: what is called blind imitation is never permissible. All the more so, blindly seeking a fatwa is impermissible. Even a mujtahid is followed only in speculative matters that require ijtihad. As I said, the mujtahid is chosen on the basis of trust in his piety and integrity. All the more must we examine the integrity, trustworthiness and piety of a mufti, shaykh or teacher who is not himself a mujtahid but transmits from one. Even if we trust him and are satisfied that he is among the pious, he must not become an authority regarded as infallible, so that everything he says is treated as certainly true. Otherwise, this would be following human beings, while we are commanded to follow the Shari’ah of Allah, Glorified and Exalted:
﴿ قُلْ إِن كُنتُمْ تُحِبُّونَ ٱللَّهَ فَٱتَّبِعُونِى ﴾
‘Say: If you love Allah, follow me.’ [3:31].
That is, we follow Muhammad, may Allah bless him and grant him peace:
﴿ قُلْ إِن كُنتُمْ تُحِبُّونَ ٱللَّهَ فَٱتَّبِعُونِى يُحْبِبْكُمُ ٱللَّهُ وَيَغْفِرْ لَكُمْ ذُنُوبَكُمْ ﴾
‘Say: If you love Allah, follow me; Allah will love you and forgive your sins.’ [3:31].
We follow the Shari’ah:
﴿ ثُمَّ جَعَلْنَـٰكَ عَلَىٰ شَرِيعَةٍ مِّنَ ٱلْأَمْرِ فَٱتَّبِعْهَا وَلَا تَتَّبِعْ أَهْوَآءَ ٱلَّذِينَ لَا يَعْلَمُونَ ﴾
‘Then We placed you upon a Shari’ah concerning the matter, so follow it and do not follow the desires of those who do not know.’ [45:18].
When Does Trust in a Shaykh Waver?
If you have trusted a shaykh for a day—or perhaps for years—and he then surprises us with a fatwa that clearly contradicts the Shari’ah evidence, may we continue to follow him? What if, after trusting a shaykh, it later becomes clear that he now issues fatwas to please the sultan, the ruler, the king, the prince or the president? Must we maintain our trust in him on the grounds that trust cannot waver? Indeed, trust can waver. Trust in Allah’s Book and Allah’s Messenger, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, does not waver. But trust in any shaykh, teacher or instructor can waver. Trust in any human being other than Allah’s Messenger, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, can waver.
Know the Truth and You Will Know Its People
Our motto must be: truth is not known through men; rather, men are known through the truth. It is reported from Imam ‘Ali, may Allah be pleased with him: ‘Truth is not known through men. Know the truth, and you will know its people.’ We are unable to perform ijtihad in speculative matters that require ijtihad, so we take them from those whom we trust.
A Fatwa That Contradicts Definitive Rulings
But if it is established one day that a shaykh has violated a definitive ruling, does our trust in him then fall away? We may have learned at his hands for years, but one day he issues a fatwa permitting interest-bearing loans from riba-based banks. This is not an issue open to ijtihad. It is a definitive matter on which no earlier mujtahid disagreed. No one can say, ‘I leave my responsibility with him; I placed my trust in him.’ Why continue trusting him after he has violated what the earlier scholars agreed upon and what is established in Allah’s Book and the Sunnah of His Messenger, may Allah bless him and grant him peace? This is not an occasion to continue trusting him. It is an occasion to sever that trust and move from seeking his fatwas to seeking fatwas from someone else who is trustworthy.
Obedience to Rulers Who Rule by Other Than What Allah Has Revealed
Today we have a large group of scholars calling people to submit to tyrants who rule by other than what Allah has revealed, under the pretext that Allah—exalted is He—has commanded obedience to those in authority. Are they obeyed and trusted in this matter? Of course not, for no single evidence indicates it is permissible to submit to a ruler who rules by anything other than what Allah has sent down. Allah has named such a ruler taghut in His Book. What is taghut? Any law other than Allah’s Law is taghut, and any ruler who governs by anything other than what Allah has revealed is ruling by a law other than Allah’s Law. He is therefore a taghut. Allah says:
﴿ أَلَمْ تَرَ إِلَى ٱلَّذِينَ يَزْعُمُونَ أَنَّهُمْ ءَامَنُوا۟ بِمَآ أُنزِلَ إِلَيْكَ وَمَآ أُنزِلَ مِن قَبْلِكَ يُرِيدُونَ أَن يَتَحَاكَمُوٓا۟ إِلَى ٱلطَّـٰغُوتِ وَقَدْ أُمِرُوٓا۟ أَن يَكْفُرُوا۟ بِهِۦ وَيُرِيدُ ٱلشَّيْطَـٰنُ أَن يُضِلَّهُمْ ضَلَـٰلًۢا بَعِيدًا ﴾
‘Have you not seen those who claim to believe in what was revealed to you and what was revealed before you? They wish to seek judgement from the taghut, though they were commanded to reject it. Satan wishes to lead them far astray.’ [4:60].
This is an explicit verse showing that referring judgement to the taghut and submitting to the rule of the taghut is far-reaching misguidance caused by Satan. When a shaykh comes to you and tells you that you must submit to a ruler who rules by something other than what Allah has revealed—that is, submit to the taghut—and calls him one in authority, he must not be obeyed. Those in authority are those who rule the Muslims by what Allah has revealed, because these are the people whom Allah, Glorified and Exalted, commanded us to obey. Allah, Exalted is He, says—listen carefully:
﴿ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ يَأْمُرُكُمْ أَن تُؤَدُّوا۟ ٱلْأَمَـٰنَـٰتِ إِلَىٰٓ أَهْلِهَا وَإِذَا حَكَمْتُم بَيْنَ ٱلنَّاسِ أَن تَحْكُمُوا۟ بِٱلْعَدْلِ ﴾
‘Indeed, Allah commands you to deliver trusts to their rightful owners, and when you judge between people, to judge with justice.’ [4:58],
and justice is the Shari’ah of Allah, Glorified and Exalted.
﴿ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ نِعِمَّا يَعِظُكُم بِهِۦٓ ۗ إِنَّ ٱللَّهَ كَانَ سَمِيعًۢا بَصِيرًا ﴾
‘Excellent indeed is what Allah admonishes you with. Indeed, Allah is All-Hearing, All-Seeing.’ [4:58]
﴿ يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوٓا۟ أَطِيعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَ وَأُو۟لِى ٱلْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ ﴾
‘O you who believe, obey Allah, obey the Messenger and those in authority among you.’ [4:59].
Here Allah, Glorified and Exalted, commanded obedience to those in authority as part of obedience to Allah and His Messenger. In obedience to Allah and His Messenger, you therefore obey the person in authority who rules you by the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of the Messenger of Allah. How can obedience to someone who rules by something other than what Allah has revealed be combined with obedience to Allah and His Messenger? Allah, Exalted is He, says:
﴿ يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوٓا۟ أَطِيعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَ وَأُو۟لِى ٱلْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ ﴾
‘O you who believe, obey Allah, obey the Messenger and those in authority among you.’ [4:59]
—meaning those in authority among you who rule by what Allah, Exalted is He, and His Messenger have ruled.
﴿ أَطِيعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَ وَأُو۟لِى ٱلْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ ۖ فَإِن تَنَـٰزَعْتُمْ فِى شَىْءٍ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَٱلرَّسُولِ ﴾
‘Obey Allah, obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. If you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger.’ [4:59],
not to the taghut, not to a man-made constitution and not to man-made law.
﴿ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَٱلرَّسُولِ إِن كُنتُمْ تُؤْمِنُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْـَٔاخِرِ ﴾
‘Refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you believe in Allah and the Last Day.’ [4:59]
﴿ ذَٰلِكَ خَيْرٌ وَأَحْسَنُ تَأْوِيلًا ﴾
‘That is better and best in outcome.’ [4:59].
The Hadith of ‘Ubadah ibn al-Samit and Manifest Disbelief
When the Messenger, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, commanded obedience to the ruler, he made it conditional upon the ruler governing by what Allah has revealed. Listen to this hadith narrated by ‘Ubadah ibn al-Samit, may Allah be pleased with him: «بايعنا رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم على السمع والطاعة في يسرنا وعسرنا، ومنشطنا ومكرهنا، وعلى أثرة منا، وأن لا ننازع الأمر أهله إلا أن تروا كفراً بواحاً عندكم من الله فيه برهان» — ‘We pledged allegiance to the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, to hear and obey in ease and hardship, in what we liked and disliked, and when others were given preference over us; and not to dispute authority with those entrusted with it, unless you see manifest disbelief for which you have proof from Allah.’ [al-Bukhari, 7055–7056; Muslim, 1709]. What does it mean to see manifest disbelief? It means that the ruler openly establishes a law other than Allah’s Law, because every law other than the Law of Allah is a law of disbelief; it is taghut. When a ruler governs by something other than what Allah has revealed, he has made manifest disbelief appear in the land. This includes introducing capitalist or socialist laws, United Nations legislation, man-made constitutions and laws, or convening a constituent assembly or legislature to legislate and then adopting that legislation. He has thereby established a law of disbelief. This is the appearance of manifest disbelief. In that case, obedience is not obligatory; rather, it is impermissible. More than that, the Muslims are obliged to contest the ruler’s authority and remove him so that they may restore ruling by what Allah has revealed.
The Meaning of Establishing Prayer in Hadiths Regarding Obedience to the Ruler
This is how his statement, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, is understood. In one narration: «لا، ما صلّوا» [Muslim, 1854] — ‘No, as long as they pray’; and in another narration: «لا، ما أقاموا فيكم الصلاة» [Muslim, 1855] — ‘No, as long as they establish prayer among you.’ No, as long as they establish prayer among you. Does prayer here mean prayer alone? Suppose they established prayer but suspended zakat or suspended Hajj. Would they then have made obedience obligatory upon them? Would they thereby have made obedience to themselves obligatory? Certainly not. When the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, mentions prayer here, he mentions it as a part standing for the whole. Have you not seen that Abu Bakr, may Allah be pleased with him, said: «لأقاتلن من فرّق بين الصلاة والزكاة» [Muslim, 20; al-Bukhari, 1399–1400] — ‘I will fight whoever separates prayer from zakat’? Some of the Companions said to him, ‘These people have continued to pray.’ They said, ‘But they have withheld zakat.’ And I will fight them over a camel’s tether which they used to give to the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace.
Prayer as a Reference to Establishing the Deen
Here, the establishment of prayer is a metaphor for establishing religion. This is proven by how the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, referred to the governor sent to judge between people according to what Allah has revealed as wali over prayer—that is, one who governs them on behalf of the Imam. Is this Imam’s role merely to lead people in prayer? No; he is called a wali over prayer because he establishes Islam among them. If others are appointed, one may be designated wali over zakat and another over judicial matters, and so forth. However, the ruler entrusted with all executive authority was named wali over prayer—that is, a governor responsible for implementing Islamic rule—so Allah, exalted is He, described prayer in the Qur’an as faith:
﴿ وَمَا كَانَ ٱللَّهُ لِيُضِيعَ إِيمَـٰنَكُمْ ﴾
‘Allah would never let your faith go to waste.’ [2:143].
Thus, in this hadith, prayer is used in the statement: ‘No, as long as they establish prayer among you.’
This does not mean that a ruler may spread every form of evil while we refrain from rising against him simply because he establishes prayer. This has nothing to do with Allah’s deen. Suppose a ruler permits fornication and riba, spreads prohibited acts and legislates by other than what Allah has revealed, yet still establishes prayer. Would obedience to him be obligatory? If he established prayer while suspending zakah or Hajj, permitting riba or permitting fornication, would he still be the person in authority who must be obeyed?
Obedience as Long as the Ruling Is by Islam
So what do ‘as long as they establish prayer’ and ‘as long as they pray’ signify here? They signify ruling by Islam. That is, as long as they rule by Islam, obedience to them is obligatory, even if they act unjustly, even if they lash your back, even if they mistreat you, and so on. As long as the ruler rules by what Allah has revealed, obedience to him in what is right is obligatory. He is obeyed in what constitutes obedience to Allah, Glorified and Exalted, and is not obeyed if he commands an act of disobedience. But as long as he rules by what Allah has revealed, it is not permissible to rebel against him. He remains the person in authority even if he mistreats people, acts unjustly and falls short, and so on. When he acts unjustly, falls short, mistreats people or makes a mistake, he must be denounced verbally, and his case must be brought before the Court of Injustices in obedience to the command of Allah, Glorified and Exalted:
﴿ فَإِن تَنَـٰزَعْتُمْ فِى شَىْءٍ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَٱلرَّسُولِ إِن كُنتُمْ تُؤْمِنُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْـَٔاخِرِ ﴾
‘If you disagree over anything, refer it to Allah and the Messenger, if you believe in Allah and the Last Day.’ [4:59].
As long as the ruler declares that he governs by what Allah has revealed, and the Shari’ah by which he governs is Allah’s Shari’ah, he remains the person in authority, even if he falls short, mistreats people, acts unjustly or at times unjustly lashes their backs. In that case, he is held to account through speech and his actions are denounced verbally; he is not opposed with the sword.
The Appearance of Manifest Disbelief
But if he rules by other than what Allah has revealed, he has manifested open kufr. He then cannot be the Muslims’ ruler. Moreover, work to remove him becomes obligatory, to restore rule by what Allah has revealed.
Fatwas on Absolute Obedience
Shaykhs today who say that obedience to the ruler is obligatory regardless of his conduct are neither obeyed nor followed. Some went so far as to say that Bremer was the Muslims’ person in authority, and that whoever Bremer appointed was the Muslims’ person in authority and had to be obeyed. They also said that those who rose against Bashar’s regime in Syria had rebelled against the person in authority, and that those who rose against Gaddafi had done the same. This fatwa alone is enough to show that such shaykhs are not trustworthy references to whom one turns for fatwas or to learn Shari’ah legal rulings. It is enough to destroy confidence in their knowledge, so one stops seeking their fatwas and instead asks and learns from others.
No Imitation in Creed or in Judging People
Brother Abdullah asks: if a lay Muslim learns from his shaykh that a particular scholar is ignorant, or that there is a flaw in his creed because, as the shaykh claims, it does not conform to the methodology of the Salaf, does imitating his shaykh discharge his obligation before Allah? If not, what should he do? I have said before, dear brothers, that imitation in matters of creed is impermissible. You therefore cannot rely upon a shaykh’s claim that a particular person or group follows bid‘ah and that their creed contradicts the Islamic creed, the creed of the Salaf or the like. By imitating him, you declare one person’s creed corrupt and another person’s creed corrupt solely through imitation. Shari’ah legal rulings are learned from muftis and teachers so that one may follow the mujtahids, but only in Shari’ah legal rulings that require ijtihad. If you want to know whether a particular person holds the true creed, return to the Islamic creed itself. Do not content yourself with imitating one person or another.
How often have some shaykhs issued a fatwa that a particular person is an innovator? Someone listens to them, follows them and simply accepts their statement: ‘So-and-so is an innovator.’ Then, if he returns to that person’s books or listens to what he actually says, he finds that his shaykh has spoken presumptuously about him, falsely accused him and wronged him. Why return to your shaykh to ask about another person’s creed, iman or madhhab when that person has his own books, views and lectures in which he expresses his opinion directly? Why go to your shaykh to ask about him?
A Historical Example: False Accusations Against Abu Hanifa
How often have some shaykhs falsely accused others? Let me take you deep into history, dear brothers. You know Abu Hanifa, that towering figure whose madhhab was—and still is—followed by millions, indeed hundreds of millions, of Muslims. What campaign did many shaykhs, scholars and jurists wage against him? The works written about this remain preserved to this day. Abu Hanifa was branded a Magian, a heretic, an innovator and much else. Had people continued listening to those who falsely accused Abu Hanifa, he would still be regarded today as a heretic, an innovator, a deviant and a person with a corrupt creed. All that happened was that someone took it upon himself to tell people, ‘So-and-so says such-and-such,’ although that claim was false. Had they returned to his own words and books, they would have found that he did not say what they had been told.
Accusations of Mu‘tazilism and Bid‘ah
A shaykh may come to you today and say, ‘So-and-so’s creed is corrupt; he holds the position of the Mu‘tazilah.’ You then go to that person, listen to him and find that he does not hold the Mu‘tazilah’s position. This alone should be enough for you to lose confidence in the person who told you that his creed was Mu‘tazili. Likewise, a shaykh may tell you, ‘Every Ash‘ari is an innovator.’ You may disagree with the Ash‘aris, as we did in earlier halaqaat, but that does not mean that you may dismiss the integrity of al-Nawawi, al-‘Asqalani and other leading scholars of fiqh and call them innovators. You have every right to say, ‘I am not convinced by the Ash‘aris’ position on this or that issue, and I am not convinced by their theological method.’ But that does not mean that we dismiss the integrity of al-Nawawi, al-‘Asqalani and others merely because a fanatical shaykh tells you that all Ash‘aris are innovators and that all of them are in the Fire. Such a person claims that one group alone is upon the truth and that everything else is false: whatever he says is the truth, he is among those who will be saved, and anyone who disagrees with him on subsidiary questions is an innovator.
The Scourge of Declaring Others Innovators and Discrediting Scholars
This is a grave affliction from which we suffer today. A group of shaykhs adopts a particular position on theological questions and then declares that anyone who disagrees with them has a corrupt creed and is in the Fire. In this way, Imams, scholars, mujtahids, jurists and even Muslim leaders whom we hold in the highest regard are dismissed and sent to the Fire merely because they disagreed on subsidiary questions that scholars have debated for many years. Thus Salah al-Din al-Ayyubi is dismissed because he was Ash‘ari, and Sultan Muhammad al-Fatih is dismissed because he may have been Sufi, Ash‘ari or Maturidi, and so on. People are stripped wholesale of integrity, trustworthiness and iman, placed among the misguided sects and expelled from the saved group solely because they differed with these shaykhs on subsidiary questions that scholars have discussed for many years.
Returning to the Person’s Own Words
You may not imitate a shaykh in these matters, nor may you take such questions from shaykhs. If you trust a shaykh, then learn Shari’ah legal rulings from him. But if you want to know the condition of a particular person, return to that person himself. Ask him directly, read what he has written and listen to what he has said. In this way, you become a person who respects his own thought and reason.
Blameworthy Imitation and Suspending the Intellect
As for suspending your intellect so that you always think with someone else’s mind, this is not praiseworthy imitation; it is blameworthy imitation. It means cancelling your own intellect and treating everything a particular person or shaykh says as correct. Allah, Glorified and Exalted, has made the Muslim one of the most elevated people in thought. O Muslim, Allah has described you as a follower of the truth, so you may not imprison yourself in the cage of a particular shaykh and return to him whenever you want to know anything.
The Proper Scope of Imitation and Seeking Fatwas
Imitation is of mujtahids, not muftis, and it is restricted to Shari’ah legal rulings that require ijtihad and in which you lack the ability to perform ijtihad yourself. Only here does imitation apply. In these matters, one seeks a fatwa in order to reach, through asking the mufti, the Shari’ah legal ruling derived by one of the mujtahids. But if you make the mufti control your intellect in every area of life, so that you hate whomever he hates, love whomever he loves, elevate whomever he elevates and lower whomever he lowers, you have degraded both your humanity and your intellect. Allah, Glorified and Exalted, made the intellect the basis of legal responsibility. On the Day of Resurrection, you will be questioned before Allah because He gave you an intellect with which to think—not because you thought with the mind of one person or another.
Escaping the Affliction of Decline
The Muslims must free themselves from this affliction. It does not befit them; it befits only degraded and declining nations: a person appoints a shaykh to guide him even in matters of his own profession, although the shaykh has no expertise in it. Unfortunately, this is one of the afflictions that struck the Ummah during periods of decline.
Conclusion
Dear brothers, we shall conclude today’s questions here. I ask Allah, Glorified and Exalted, to teach us what benefits us, benefit us through what He has taught us, increase us in knowledge and deeds, and make our actions sincere for His Noble Face alone. I send prayers and peace upon the Messenger of Allah, his family, his Companions and those who support him. May the peace, mercy and blessings of Allah be upon you.
