All Halaqaat
EN

Halaqa 41

Islam — Idea and Method

About this Halaqa

Full title: The System of Islam — Halaqa 41: Islam — Idea and Method

Lecturer: Sheikh Ahmad al-Qasas
Series: Explanation of The System of Islam
Date: 18 June 2018 — 4 Shawwal 1439 AH

Video with subtitles

Full transcript

From the bookThe System of IslamSixth edition · 2001p. 33

Opening text of the book The System of Islam

Consequently, the foundation of the ideology is the universal idea (al-fikrah al-kulliyyah) about universe, man and life, and the method, which brings the ideology into existence and implementation in all the walks of life is indispensable to ensure the existence of the ideology. The universal idea is the foundation since it is the creed (‘Aqeedah), the intellectual basis and the intellectual leadership. On the basis of this universal idea the intellectual direction of man and his viewpoint towards life is defined. Moreover, all thoughts are built upon it and the treatments for the worldly life’s problems emanate from it. The fact that the Tareeqah (method) is essential, is because if the system that emanates from the ‘aqeedah (creed) does not include a clarification of the howness of implementing the treatments, preserving the ‘Aqeedah and carrying the invitation to ideology, then the Idea would become a hypothetical and fanciful philosophy that remains recorded in the books without having any effect in this worldly life. Hence, the ‘Aqeedah, the treatments for the problems and the Tareeqah (Method) are all necessary for the ideology to come into existence.

View book source

Introduction: Islam is an Idea and a Method

Peace and Allah’s mercy and blessings be upon you. Welcome to a new episode of your programme, Halaqa Live. In these episodes, we are still speaking within the framework of intellectual leadership in Islam today. We are discussing an important subject concerning how the contents of ideologies are classified. Islam is one of these ideologies, as an ideology and a system for life, society and the state. Our subject today is the Idea and the Method. Dear brothers, what do we mean by the Idea and the Method?

Organising Human Needs and Instincts

Satisfying the organic needs and instincts in human beings requires behavioural guidelines that show them the correct satisfaction, which leads to happiness and well-being, and distinguish it from the wrong satisfaction, which leads to misery. Allah, the Exalted—the Creator of human beings and of their needs and instincts—therefore sent down the revelation to show people the sound conduct by which these needs are satisfied. He explained the elements of iman, foremost among them belief in Him, glorified be He, as Creator, Organiser and Guide. He then explained the acts of worship through which human beings worship their Creator, such as prayer, fasting, Hajj and others. In this way, He regulated the satisfaction of the instinct of religiousness in human beings and, consequently, their relationship with their Creator.

By prohibiting zina, legislating marriage and laying down the related rulings on parenthood, maintaining family ties, dutifulness to parents and other matters, Islam regulated the satisfaction of the procreation instinct. By legislating the ways of earning wealth and the rulings on ownership, prohibiting theft and the unlawful consumption of people’s wealth, and granting the right to defend oneself and one’s property even if this entails killing, Islam regulated the satisfaction of the survival instinct. By permitting wholesome food and drink and prohibiting what is impure, Islam regulated the satisfaction of the organic needs. These are examples, not an exhaustive list. Islam has regulated the satisfaction of all innate human needs without neglecting any of them, in a balanced manner in which no instinct or need dominates another.

Society Requires a Binding System

Since fulfilling many innate human needs requires establishing relationships with others to exchange agreed benefits and avert dangers, societies had to be formed. Consequently, regulating social relations became essential for organising the satisfaction of these innate needs—for without them, societies would not exist at all. This means that any system aiming to regulate human behaviour must address humanity as a collective beyond individual guidance alone. It also implies that such a system cannot be implemented through voluntary initiative; rather, it requires binding the general populace to its framework.

The Method That Brings the Ideology into Existence and Implements It

This shows the importance of the system that regulates the satisfaction of people’s innate needs being accompanied by a method that explains how this system is brought into existence in real life, implemented and preserved. Islam therefore did not confine itself to the Idea, which explains the correct way to satisfy human instincts and organic needs. It also explained the Method through which the ideology is brought into existence in real life, implemented in society, spread throughout the world and preserved. Islam is therefore an Idea and a Method.

Examples of the rulings of the Idea and Method

In regulating the procreation instinct, Islam prohibited zina and followed this prohibition with the prescribed punishment for zina as the method of implementing this treatment. When Islam prohibited intoxicants, theft, apostasy and the slander of believing men and women, it followed these prohibitions with prescribed punishments for those who violate them. When it prohibited assault against life and limb, it followed this with the rulings of qisas. It also legislated ta’zir as punishment for all other Shari’ah violations.

When Islam commanded the implementation of the Shari’ah in general, it explained the only Shari’ah method for this implementation: the state. It commanded the establishment of the state, explained the method of establishing it and set out its system in detail in the Book and Sunnah. The actions undertaken by the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, from the beginning of his Prophethood until the establishment of the state in Madinah, with the establishment of that state as their objective, therefore constitute the only practical Shari’ah method of establishing the state when it is absent. The state established by the Messenger of Allah, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, in Madinah, which expanded during his lifetime to encompass the Arabian Peninsula, then became the practical model to be followed when implementing Islam in every age as treatments for human problems and regulation of human instincts. The degree to which this model is followed is therefore the measure of success in implementing these systems and treatments.

Islam commanded that its da’wah be carried as a message to the world and also explained the method of carrying it: da’wah and jihad, which the state undertakes and makes the basis of its foreign policy. Islam commanded that the ruler be held accountable and opposed if he violates the Islamic system or implements it badly, and it also legislated a method for this: the obligation to establish political parties based on the Islamic creed. These parties monitor the state and society’s sentiments and culture, fulfilling the duty to enjoin what is right and forbid what is wrong through da’wah, education and accountability. Islam also commanded the defence and protection of its message and legislated a method for this: defensive jihad, through which the enemies of the Ummah and the ideology are repelled.

Islam does not distinguish between the rulings of the Idea and the rulings of the Method in terms of the obligation to observe and abide by them. They are all Shari’ah rulings revealed by Allah, the Exalted, in His Book and in the Sunnah of His Prophet, may Allah bless him and his family and grant them peace. They fall within the meaning of His words:

﴿ ٱلْيَوْمَ أَكْمَلْتُ لَكُمْ دِينَكُمْ وَأَتْمَمْتُ عَلَيْكُمْ نِعْمَتِى وَرَضِيتُ لَكُمُ ٱلْإِسْلَـٰمَ دِينًا ﴾
‘Today I have perfected your religion for you, completed My favour upon you, and chosen Islam as your religion.’ [5:3]

It is therefore impermissible to distinguish between the rulings of the Idea and the rulings of the Method in terms of the obligation to abide by them. Both form part of the religion through which Allah, the Exalted, is obeyed. Allah, the Exalted, says:

﴿ يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوا۟ ٱدْخُلُوا۟ فِى ٱلسِّلْمِ كَآفَّةً وَلَا تَتَّبِعُوا۟ خُطُوَٰتِ ٱلشَّيْطَـٰنِ ۚ إِنَّهُۥ لَكُمْ عَدُوٌّ مُّبِينٌ ﴾
‘O believers! Enter into Islam wholeheartedly and do not follow Satan’s footsteps. Indeed, he is your clear enemy.’ [2:208]

The word al-silm in this verse means Islam in its entirety.

Why do we use this classification?

The distinction between the two categories of rulings—the Idea and the Method—was not present among jurists for most eras since Prophethood through to subsequent centuries. Why then do we rely on this division in our contemporary Islamic culture? This is a valid question, indeed an extremely pertinent one. Anyone who encounters this classification should ask it, for while there may be no dispute over terminology, introducing new classifications and intellectual or juristic terms without practical necessity—merely for the sake of intellectual indulgence—is impermissible. Accordingly, we answer that there are multiple reasons for this division, which will be clarified below.

Over the last two centuries, a notion has prevailed among many Muslim intellectuals and jurists: Islam established rulings to regulate human behaviour and address its problems—these are obligatory rules requiring adherence. It also proposed methods for applying these systems and treatments, which were suitable in early Islamic eras but need not be followed today. Instead, we can adopt other new approaches more aligned with the present age.

The Objectives of the Shari’ah and the Suspension of the Rulings of the Method

Towards the end of the Ottoman Khilafah, new opinions emerged that had been unknown throughout the preceding ages. Some permitted replacing the prescribed Shari’ah punishments with discretionary punishments. The Ottoman Penal Code was then issued, suspending the prescribed punishments and replacing them with discretionary punishments on the pretext that the objective of the Shari’ah was to prevent prohibited acts and that the prescribed punishments were merely a means to this end. They therefore claimed there was no harm in replacing one punishment with another so long as the aim was to deter the offender. Writers and authors at that time went on repeating the theory of the objectives of the Shari’ah. According to this theory, Allah, the Exalted, assigned objectives to the rulings He legislated and legislated those rulings for the sake of those objectives, so the rulings exist or cease according to whether their objectives exist or cease. They therefore held that attention should focus on the objectives rather than on the rulings themselves. This led to the neglect of the rulings on the pretext of observing the objectives.

The truth is that those who adopted this theory fell into several errors. Later and contemporary writers then compounded these errors after disregarding the controls and limits observed by the theory’s earliest proponents.

The Difference Between the Shari’ah Cause and the Objective

The first of these errors was that they confused the Shari’ah cause (‘illah), which the Wise Legislator made the reason for legislating a ruling, with the objective of that ruling. The ‘illah is a description upon which the Wise Legislator based the ruling and to which He linked it, so the ruling exists when the ‘illah exists and ceases when it ceases.

The objectives, however, are outcomes that the Legislator sought to achieve through the rulings without making the rulings conditional upon them—that is, without giving the objectives any effect upon or control over the rulings. An objective may fail to materialise without the ruling thereby ceasing to apply. This differs from the Shari’ah cause, without which the ruling does not exist. Their second error was imagining that they could know the objectives, or the objectives of particular rulings, even when no Shari’ah evidence indicated them. Their third error was imagining that they were authorised to formulate rulings that would realise the objectives of the Shari’ah without any Shari’ah evidence.

They even went so far as to discard rulings that the Legislator had prescribed to realise those objectives. They did this on the pretext that new realities required the rulings to be developed rather than remaining rigidly attached to old approaches, and on the basis of the saying they promoted: ‘It cannot be denied that rulings change with time and place.’ They claimed this was a Shari’ah principle.

The Impact of Western Pressure on Understanding the Rulings of the Method

In our present reality—since the Islamic State has been absent and the Ummah removed from the sphere of Islamic life, and under the pressure of Western culture, the prevailing systems and the organised assault on the rulings of Islam—many Muslim intellectuals have been defeated by this pressure. This includes individuals and groups calling for the resumption of the Islamic way of life. They have submitted to many propositions presented as alternatives to the rulings of Islam, particularly the rulings of the Method. One widespread claim is that Islam did not legislate a detailed system of government and that there is therefore no harm in adopting any man-made system of government that guarantees consultation and justice. This opened the door to accepting the democratic system in its various forms: republican, parliamentary, cabinet government, constitutional monarchy and so on.

It has also become prevalent to argue that jihad was historically necessary due to international customs and limited communication means. However, today—with the recognition of peoples’ right to self-determination and advancements in media and communication—there is no justification for propagating Islam through jihad. Consequently, as they claim, it remains permissible only in response to aggression.

Deviation from the Method of Establishing the Islamic State

A claim has also spread among those working to restore the Islamic State that Islam did not bind us to a specific method of establishing it, and that the actions undertaken by the Messenger, may Allah bless him and his family and grant them peace, to establish the state were merely styles, human ijtihads and experiences that do not bind us. They failed to notice the clear difference between the actions the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, performed as obligations by Allah’s command and those he performed permissibly, choosing styles and means that achieved the Shari’ah objective.

They therefore resorted to approaches to change that contradict the Method of the Messenger, may Allah bless him and his family and grant them peace. At times they adopted armed action without any controls. At other times they resorted to democracy and participation in a government that rules by other than what Allah revealed. At still other times they adopted charitable work as a means of attracting followers and supporters.

The illusion of applying Islam without a State

Some even concluded that Islamic treatments could be implemented without an Islamic State. They claimed that preaching and guidance would be sufficient to encourage people to observe the acts of worship, obligations and recommended acts and to discourage them from prohibited and disliked acts; that private Islamic institutes, schools and universities would be sufficient to teach Muslims Islamic culture and the Islamic sciences; that awqaf, charitable associations and voluntary zakah funds would be sufficient to meet the needs of the poor; that Islamic financial institutions and investment companies would apply Islam’s rulings on wealth and the economy and provide Islamic transactions for Muslim investors; and that Shari’ah courts would regulate social transactions—what they call personal status matters—in accordance with the rulings of the Islamic Shari’ah. Muslims could also agree upon jurists or juristic bodies to judge between them when disputes arise, while modern media and communications, including satellite channels and the internet, would be sufficient to carry the Islamic da’wah to the world.

Islam’s Sovereignty and the System Dominating Society

There are many other such claims that strip Islam of the quality of sovereignty that Allah, glorified and exalted be He, intended for it when He said:

﴿ هُوَ ٱلَّذِىٓ أَرْسَلَ رَسُولَهُۥ بِٱلْهُدَىٰ وَدِينِ ٱلْحَقِّ لِيُظْهِرَهُۥ عَلَى ٱلدِّينِ كُلِّهِۦ وَلَوْ كَرِهَ ٱلْمُشْرِكُونَ ﴾
‘He is the One Who sent His Messenger with guidance and the religion of truth to make it prevail over every other religion, even though the polytheists dislike it.’ [9:33]

The Prophet, may Allah bless him and his family and grant them peace, referred to the same quality when he said: «الإسلام يعلو ولا يُعلى» [سنن الدارقطني، 3620] — ‘Islam prevails and is not prevailed over.’ These people also failed to notice, or perhaps deliberately ignored, that the systems applied by the authority in society necessarily control society’s relationships, stamp them with their own character and play the greatest role in shaping society’s identity and way of life.

Indeed, the charitable, educational, financial and media institutions established by these deluded people cannot exist or operate except with the permission of those systems, in accordance with the prevailing man-made laws and the policies of rulers installed to safeguard the interests of the major powers and spread their culture and way of life. These people forgot, or chose to forget, that no system for life and society can be implemented except through authority and government, and that two systems cannot coexist in one society—especially when one of them is Islam.

This shows the importance of explaining that Islam is not merely a set of spiritual, behavioural and moral inclinations that individuals may voluntarily observe without regard to the system dominating people’s lives in society. Islam is a system: a system for life, society and the state. It contains treatments for the human problems arising from human vital energy and from the relationships this energy requires. It also contains a Method that explains to those who embrace this system how to implement, spread and preserve it.

Summary of Rulings on the Idea and Method

In summary, the creed provides a comprehensive idea about this worldly life, what came before it, what comes after it and its relationship with what came before and what comes after. It thereby solves the greatest problem for human beings. This creed, together with the Shari’ah rulings that regulate human affairs and treat human problems in their capacity as human beings, is what we mean by the term ‘rulings of the Idea’. The rulings that Islam legislated as a Method for implementing these treatments in the reality of life and society, spreading them throughout the world, preserving them and defending them are what we mean by the term ‘rulings of the Method’. The rulings on worship, which regulate satisfaction of the instinct of religiousness in human beings; the rulings of the social system, which regulate family relations, the interaction of men and women and the relationships arising from that interaction; the rulings of the economic system, which explain the rulings on ownership and regulate economic relations; and the rulings on foodstuffs, clothing, manners and morals—all these are rulings of the Idea.

The Islamic State, its institutions and system of government, and the rulings assigned to it—such as establishing schools, the Bayt al-Mal and media outlets, establishing courts, the penal rulings of hudud, qisas and ta’zir, foreign policy and the rulings of jihad—are all rulings of the Method. The obligation to establish political parties and their responsibilities, including monitoring society’s thoughts and sentiments and holding rulers accountable, are also rulings of the Method. The work of carrying the da’wah to Islam and enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong, undertaken by the state and the parties, also falls under the rulings of the Method. Allah, the Exalted, says:

﴿ قُلْ إِن كُنتُمْ تُحِبُّونَ ٱللَّهَ فَٱتَّبِعُونِى يُحْبِبْكُمُ ٱللَّهُ وَيَغْفِرْ لَكُمْ ذُنُوبَكُمْ ۗ وَٱللَّهُ غَفُورٌ رَّحِيمٌ ﴾
‘Say: If you love Allah, follow me; Allah will love you and forgive your sins. Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.’ [3:31]

Summary of the Episode

In this episode, dear brothers, we explained what we mean by the terms Idea and Method. This distinction has one fundamental purpose: to refute claims that Islam brought treatments for regulating human behaviour but left people—left Muslims—to search for the political system, method, means and styles, as they put it, by which to implement those treatments. They thus removed the Method from Islam and retained only its Idea, along with the impurities that cloud their understanding of it. I will leave you now for a short break. We will then return to any questions that may have been submitted during the episode. Peace be upon you. Peace and Allah’s mercy be upon you.

Viewers’ Questions

Welcome back. We will now answer the questions submitted during this live episode.

Are the Terms ‘Idea’ and ‘Method’ an Innovation in Religion?

Brother al-‘Abid asks: The terms Idea and Method do not appear in the Book or the Sunnah. Is this not a form of innovation in the religion?

Introducing terminology that conveys Shari’ah meanings is no form of innovation at all; it has been the practice of scholars and jurists since Islam’s earliest days. If you examine the systematic books of jurisprudence and scholarship—compiled to facilitate access to Shari’ah rulings—you will find they were organised into classifications that make it easier for people to revisit or review those rulings.

For example, the Shari’ah itself did not divide its rulings into worship, transactions, punishments and so on. The Shari’ah consists of commands and prohibitions that Muslims are obliged to observe. To make these rulings easier to find and as part of classifying the Islamic sciences, however, the jurists coined terms such as ‘the chapter on worship’, ‘the chapter on transactions’ and ‘the chapter on punishments’, with sections and further divisions within those chapters.

Another example is their division of Islam into creed and Shari’ah. If you search the Book and Sunnah, you will not find the term ‘creed’: the word ‘creed’ occurs neither in the Qur’an, the Book of Allah, nor in the Sunnah. The jurists nevertheless used this term for matters of iman, which they distinguished from practical Shari’ah rulings belonging to the field of Islamic jurisprudence and legislation.

If we tried to examine all the terms coined by scholars and jurists, the discussion would become lengthy and we could not enumerate them in this session. It is in this same sense that we divide the rulings of Islam—indeed, Islam as a whole—into the Idea and the Method. This is a new classificatory term by which we classify the rulings of Islam.

We distinguish between what was legislated for its own sake to treat human problems in their capacity as human beings and what was not legislated for its own sake, but rather for the sake of the rulings of the Idea. We call the latter the rulings of the Method. They explain how the rulings of the Idea—the treatments applied to the reality of human life in society and to human life generally—are implemented. They explain how the Islamic system and the Islamic ideology are implemented, spread and preserved. During this episode, we explained in detail the reason that led us to make this division between the Idea and the Method.

Is how to pray part of the Method’s rulings?

Brother Abu al-Rashid asks: Does the Messenger’s saying, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, «صلوا كما رأيتموني أصلي» [صحيح البخاري، 631] — ‘Pray as you have seen me pray’ — and the actions of the prayer that he explained form part of the Method advocated by Hizb ut-Tahrir?

Here, by the word ‘Method’, we do not mean its linguistic meaning but its technical meaning. ‘Method’ is a newly coined term used to identify one category of Shari’ah rulings according to the meaning of this term. Not every manner in which an act of worship is performed falls under the term ‘Method’. The manner in which prayer is performed is not one of the rulings of the Method; it is one of the rulings of the Idea. These are all rulings that explain how human beings establish their relationship with their Creator and satisfy their instinct of religiousness.

As for what relates specifically to prayer under the rulings of the Method: when the Islamic State exists, the state punishes a person who abandons the prayer, in accordance with the details set out by the jurists. The punishment of a person who abandons the prayer is therefore one of the rulings of the Method; the manner in which prayer is performed is not. Likewise, Hajj, its rulings, its rites and the manner in which it is performed all belong to the rulings of the Idea, not the rulings of the Method. It is, however, one of the rulings of the Method that the ruler takes care of this obligation, facilitates it for people and administers its affairs. Rulings concerning the Islamic State and the actions carried out by political parties fall under the rulings of the Method. The manner in which acts of worship are performed does not; it belongs to the rulings of the Idea.

Must the Method Be of the Same Nature as the Idea, and How Does It Differ from a Style?

Brother Marwan ‘Abd al-Salam asks: Must the Method be of the same nature as the Idea? And what is the difference between the Method and a style?

In this session, we clarified that the Method consists of Shari’ah legal rulings—just like the Idea. As adherence to the Idea is obligatory, so too must the Method be adhered to. Just as one upholds the prohibition on alcohol—a ruling of the Idea—one must also adhere to its prescribed method: flogging for drinking it. Similarly, since adultery is forbidden under the rulings of the Idea, one must likewise observe its prescribed penalties—flogging or stoning—as obligatory Shari’ah legal rulings. Both the Method and the Idea are one in their obligation; both were legislated by Allah, the Exalted.

As for the second part of the question—the difference between the Method and a style—this is a very important question. The Method is a manner of doing something, and a style is also a manner of doing something. In the contemporary terminology we use, the difference is that the Method is a manner prescribed by Allah, glorified and exalted be He.

Allah, Mighty and Majestic, made amputation of the thief’s hand the Method of implementing the prohibition of theft. Allah, glorified and exalted be He, made qisas the Method of implementing the prohibition of murder and assaults against life and limb. The prescribed manner by which the rulings of the Idea brought by the Shari’ah and made binding upon us are implemented belongs to the rulings of the Method.

A style, however, is a manner that the Shari’ah has left us to choose from among the permitted actions when implementing rulings for which Islam did not specify a particular manner of implementation, or for which it specified part of the manner and left the rest to us.

For example, Allah, glorified and exalted be He, said to the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace:

﴿ خُذْ مِنْ أَمْوَٰلِهِمْ صَدَقَةً تُطَهِّرُهُمْ وَتُزَكِّيهِم بِهَا ﴾
‘Take from their wealth a charity by which you purify and develop them.’ [9:103]

He commanded the Prophet to take zakah from their wealth. The command was addressed to the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace, in his capacity as the ruler of the Muslims at that time. It is therefore addressed to the person in authority in the Islamic State in every age: he must collect zakah from the Muslims. How is this zakah to be collected? Here, the ruler is left to determine a style for collecting it from the Muslims by administrative means, such as departments and so on. This is one of the permitted styles.

Let me give another example. Allah, glorified and exalted be He, commanded the ruler to take care of people’s affairs and prevent harm from reaching them. In some matters, preventing harm requires actions, forms, means and styles from which the ruler may choose. Regulating traffic on the roads and in the streets—the movement of cars, pedestrians and so on—is obligatory because taking care of people’s affairs and preventing harm from reaching them are obligations upon the ruler. The Shari’ah principle states: ‘Whatever is necessary to fulfil an obligation is itself obligatory.’ Regulating people’s affairs in public life is therefore an obligation upon the ruler.

How is this implemented? He may choose a traffic system where drivers drive on the right or on the left; he may adopt from existing systems what suits him. These are among the styles and means: it is permissible for drivers to drive on the right, and permissible to drive on the left. The ruler chooses, and the state adopts a particular driving system that preserves orderly conduct in people’s affairs, prevents conflict, avoids chaos, and protects people from harm. This falls under styles and means.

Umar ibn al-Khattab, may Allah be pleased with him, adopted administrative registers from other states, such as the Romans and Persians. These registers were styles and means adopted to organise records: population counts, employee records, registers of stipends and soldiers, land-tax records, records of war booty and fay’, and so on. Today, these would be called public registers, government departments and public administrations. All of these are styles and permitted things. They are objects, and the original rule concerning objects is permissibility.

Styles are actions that the Shari’ah has indicated are permitted. Means are objects whose original rule is permissibility. We may adopt them so long as they achieve the intended purpose—that is, so long as they realise and establish the Shari’ah ruling commanded by the Legislator. This applies when the Shari’ah has not specified a particular manner of implementing the Shari’ah ruling. When it has specified such a manner, that is called the Method. This is the difference between the Method and a style.

What Is the Relationship of the Constant and the Variable to the Idea, Method and Style?

Brother Abd al-Rahman asks: there is discussion about what is variable and what is constant in Islam, and many movements say that they have not abandoned the constants. What, then, is the relationship of the constant and the variable to the Idea, the Method and styles?

There are no variables in Islam. By Islam, we mean the creed and the legislation. The creed is fixed and the legislation is fixed; what varies is the reality in which human beings live. All talk of Islam containing both constants and variables is false and mistaken. Islam is a Shari’ah legislated by Allah, glorified and exalted be He. Everyone agrees that nothing in the creed can be changed without falling into disbelief and misguidance. The legislation is likewise fixed, since the Shari’ah was completed during the time of the Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace. Allah, the Exalted, says:

﴿ ٱلْيَوْمَ أَكْمَلْتُ لَكُمْ دِينَكُمْ وَأَتْمَمْتُ عَلَيْكُمْ نِعْمَتِى وَرَضِيتُ لَكُمُ ٱلْإِسْلَـٰمَ دِينًا ﴾
‘Today I have perfected your religion for you, completed My favour upon you, and chosen Islam as your religion.’ [5:3]

Islam is therefore fixed and contains no variables.

Reality, however, is variable and changes. When reality changes, we do not say that the Shari’ah rulings that address it or are attached to it have changed. Rather, when reality changes, one fixed Shari’ah ruling that applied to the former reality ceases to apply, and another fixed Shari’ah ruling is applied to the new reality. Every reality has a fixed Shari’ah ruling in the Book of Allah, the Exalted, and the Sunnah of His Prophet, may Allah bless him and grant him peace. All of Islam therefore consists of constants; what changes is reality. Whenever reality changes or something new arises within it, some rulings cease to apply while remaining fixed in themselves, and other rulings are applied while likewise remaining fixed. The rulings are fixed, and every reality has a Shari’ah ruling that applies to it.

If the question instead concerns the fact that styles and means can change, their Shari’ah ruling remains fixed: what is permitted remains permitted. Since these things are permitted, however, we may select from among them what suits our reality. I gave an example of this a short while ago: Umar ibn al-Khattab adopted administrative registers based on an administrative system prevalent in his time.

Today, we are not obliged to use that particular permitted style, although it remains permitted. We may adopt other permitted things today, such as computers and the modern science of administration. All of these are permitted things whose ruling in Islam is fixed, but we select from among the permitted things what suits our reality and time. What is permitted remains permitted, what is prohibited remains prohibited, what is obligatory remains obligatory, what is recommended remains recommended and what is disliked remains disliked. This is the reality of the matter: Islam is fixed and does not change, and no one has the right to change Islam.

What is the relationship between Shari’ah objectives and Idea and Method?

Brother al-‘Abid asks again what the relationship between the Idea and Method is with respect to the objectives of the Shari’ah. I did not understand your intention when you mentioned them.

I mentioned the subject because some people use the idea of the objectives as a route to claiming that the rulings of the Method brought by Islam are not required in themselves and that we are therefore not bound by them. One of them says: Islam legislated objectives; it legislated rulings that have objectives. Among the objectives of the Shari’ah are preserving life and the body, preserving the mind and preserving the religion. They then say that the Shari’ah legislated punishments, for example, to realise these objectives, but that we are not bound by those particular punishments and may realise the same objectives through other punishments.

They say that, to realise these objectives, the Shari’ah legislated—or, as they put it, proposed—methods such as the Islamic State, jihad, the hudud punishments and so on. They then claim that we can replace these methods with new ones: we can adopt a new system for the state or rely on methods other than the state to implement the rulings of Islam; we can dispense with jihad when spreading the Islamic da’wah; we can replace the prescribed punishment for theft with other punishments for thieves; we can dispense with stoning or flogging the person who commits zina; and we can replace qisas with other rulings in order to preserve life or realise the objectives legislated by Islam. They thus entered through the idea of the objectives in order to discard the rulings of the Method. This is why I mentioned the matter in this discussion during the episode.

Conclusion

My dear brothers, these are the questions that arose during our session today. I ask Allah, may He be exalted and glorified, to reward us and you all, accept our deeds, increase us in knowledge and righteous action, and make our knowledge and actions sincere for His Noble Face. I send prayers of peace upon the Messenger of Allah, his family, companions and supporters. Until we meet again in a future session, if Allah wills. May peace be upon you, mercy from Allah and His blessings.

In this Halaqa

Language and display

Reading language
Subtitles
Text size
Theme
Playback speed
Download SRT subtitles

Copy and share